(AGENPARL) - Roma, 23 Gennaio 2025 - (AGENPARL) – gio 23 gennaio 2025 Newsletter
Weeks V – VI: 27th January to 7th February 2025
Contact us
@ENDesk
Jacques René
Zammit
Press Officer
Monica Pizzo
Assistant
Desk Email
Week V: 27th to 31st January
Monday 27th January
Formal sitting of the Court of Justice. The President and Members of the new
European Commission will give a solemn undertaking before the Court of Justice of
the European Union.
The formal streaming will be live streamed here. The link will be active on Monday.
There will be a press release for this event.
Tuesday 28th January
Niamh
Judgment in Case C-253/23 ASG 2
Leneghan
assisted in the
preparation of
this Newsletter.
(Competition)
32 sawmills established in Germany, Belgium and Luxembourg claim to have suffered
damage as a result of a cartel. As part of this practice, the Land of North Rhine-
Follow
@EUCourtPress
on X (formerly
Twitter)
Download our
Westphalia (Germany) allegedly applied, at least from June 28, 2005 to June 30, 2019,
excessive prices to the sale of roundwood from this Land to these sawmills.
Each of the sawmills concerned has assigned its claim for damages to ASG 2, which, as
a ‘provider of legal services’ within the meaning of German law, has brought a
collective action for damages against the Land before the German courts. It is acting in
its own name and at its own expense, but on behalf of the sawmills, in return for a fee
in the event of success.
The Land contests ASG 2’s standing to bring the action, arguing that German law, as
interpreted by certain national courts, does not allow the service provider to bring the
collective action for recovery in the context of an infringement of competition law.
According to the German court, a collective action for recovery is the only collective
procedural mechanism enabling the right to reparation in cartel cases to be enforced
effectively in Germany.
Communications Directorate
Press and Information unit
curia.europa.eu
Newsletter
Weeks V – VI: 27th January to 7th February 2025
All times are 9:30
They therefore asked the Court of Justice whether European Union law, in particular
unless otherwise
the Article 101 TFEU and the Directive 2014/104/EU precluded the interpretation of
stated.
Don’t forget to
check the diary
on our website
for details of
national legislation which prevents persons injured by a cartel from having recourse to
this type of action.
Background Documents C-253/23
There will be a press release for this case.
other cases.
Wednesday 29th January
General Court
Judgment in Joined Cases T-70/23, T-84/23 and T-111/23 Data Protection
Commission v European Data Protection Board
(Law governing the institutions)
In 2018, three individuals from Belgium, Germany, and Austria, through the non-profit
NOYB – European Center for Digital Rights, lodged complaints against Facebook
Ireland Ltd (now Meta Platforms Ireland Ltd) and WhatsApp Ireland Ltd. The
complaints focused on alleged breaches of the EU’s General Data Protection
Regulation (GDPR) in processing data from Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp users.
Due to the cross-border nature of these operations, Ireland’s Data Protection
Commission (DPC) acted as the lead supervisory authority under GDPR, conducting
investigations and preparing draft decisions for input from other EU and EEA data
protection authorities.
The complaints primarily alleged violations of GDPR Articles 6 and 9, which govern the
lawful basis for processing personal data and the handling of sensitive data,
respectively. Several objections arose from other supervisory authorities, particularly
regarding Meta and WhatsApp’s targeted advertising practices and the lack of user
consent for processing sensitive data. As consensus could not be reached on these
objections, the matter was referred to the European Data Protection Board (EDPB)
under GDPR’s consistency mechanism. In December 2022, the EDPB issued binding
decisions, requiring the DPC to amend its draft decisions, find specific GDPR
infringements, and impose corrective measures on Meta and WhatsApp.
The EDPB also directed the DPC to conduct further investigations into whether Meta
and WhatsApp processed sensitive data under Article 9 and whether such processing
complied with GDPR. New draft decisions were mandated based on these findings. In
response, the DPC challenged the EDPB’s authority to impose these measures in
binding decisions, leading to legal actions in early 2023.
Cases T-70/23, T-84/23 and T-111/23 were joined by decision of April 21, 2023.
Newsletter
Weeks V – VI: 27th January to 7th February 2025
Background Documents T-70/23
Background Documents T-84/23
Background Documents T-111/23
There will be an Info Rapide for the case (available on request).
Thursday 30th January
Advocate General’s Opinion in Case C-759/23 PJ Carroll and Nicoventures Trading
v Ireland
(Approximation of laws – Freedom to provide services)
The Tobacco Products Directive regulates the manufacture, presentation, and sale of
tobacco and related products in the European Union. Under Article 7, cigarettes and
roll-your-own tobacco with a characterising flavour, as well as their flavoured
components, were prohibited. Additionally, Article 11 set out mandatory labelling
obligations for cigarettes, roll-your-own tobacco and waterpipe tobacco.
The directive empowers the Commission to extend the scope of Articles 7 and 11 to
additional particular product categories if a Commission report can demonstrate a
substantial change of circumstances. This is defined as significant increases in sales or
youth consumption across multiple Member States, provided the product category
exceeds 2.5% of total tobacco sales at the EU level. Furthermore, the directive
mandates that the Commission monitor developments related to novel tobacco
products and assess whether amendments to the directive might be required.
In 2022, the European Commission adopted Delegated Directive 2022/2100, extending
the provisions of Articles 7 and 11 to include ‘heated tobacco products’. This
amendment prohibited the sale of flavoured heated tobacco products and introduced
labelling requirements for these products.
In 2023, Ireland transposed the Delegated Directive 2022/2100 into Irish regulations.
The applicants, PJ Carroll & Company Ltd and Nicoventures Trading Ltd, challenged the
validity of these regulations in the High Court of Ireland. They contended that the
Commission overstepped its authority under the Tobacco Products Directive.
The High Court referred two questions to the Court of Justice regarding the
interpretation of the Directive’s provisions and the scope of the Commission’s
authority.
Background Documents C-759/23
There will be an Info Rapide for the case (available on request).
Newsletter
Weeks V – VI: 27th January to 7th February 2025
Week VI: 3rd to 7th February
Tuesday 4th February
Judgment in Case C-158/23 Keren
(Area of Freedom, Security and Justice – Asylum policy)
An Eritrean arrived in the Netherlands at the age of 17 and was recognised as a
beneficiary of international protection. When he reached the age of 18, the Dutch
authorities informed him of his obligation under Dutch law to undergo civic
integration training. This meant that, in principle, he had to pass all parts of the civic
integration exam within three years. This deadline has been extended several times.
However, the young Eritrean did not attend certain courses and exams and did not
pass those he did attend.
The authorities fined him €500. He also had to repay in full the €10,000 loan he had
taken out with the authorities, on the grounds that he had not completed the civic
integration programme within the stipulated period. The Eritrean took his case to the
Dutch courts.
The Council of State (Netherlands) decided to refer questions to the Court of Justice
for a preliminary ruling on the compatibility of the Dutch system with EU Directive
2011/95/EU on international protection.
Background Documents C-158/23
There will be a press release for this case.
Wednesday 5th February
General Court
Judgments in Cases T-830/22 Poland v Commission, T-156/23 Poland v
Commission and T-1033/23 Poland v Commission
(Law governing the institutions)
On April 1, 2021, the European Commission brought an action against Poland before
the Court of Justice for failure to fulfil obligations (C-204/21 Commission v Poland
Trending
- Iran, la missione all’ONU respinge le accuse sul presunto piano di attentato a Washington
- Orti sociali di via di Salviano, nuovo bando per gli over 65
- RETURN HUB IN RUANDA, TARQUINIO (S&D): COSÌ L’EUROPA DEPORTA ANCHE LE PROPRIE RESPONSABILIT?
- FONDI CIPESS, MARCHETTI (LEGA): “OLTRE 132 MILIONI PER INVESTIMENTI STRATEGICI, SVILUPPO E SICUREZZA DEL TERRITORIO”
- Scuola. Di Maggio (Fdi), con Fdi sconti sui libri. Vediamo chi sta con le famiglie e chi no
- Rifondazione: Come si prova a capovolgere la storia
- NATO, gli Stati Uniti preparano il riequilibrio militare in Europa. Revisione attesa entro il 1° dicembre
- Agenzia nr. 2159 – “Metroquadrato”, il teatro entra nella Casa circondariale di Taranto: due appuntamenti per raccontare un laboratorio finanziato dal Garante regionale
- LEGA, DOMANI VISITA ISTITUZIONALE AL CENTRO DI MONASTIR. A SEGUIRE PUNTO STAMPA
- Camera dei deputati: Informativa Crosetto, iscritti a parlare dopo Ministro
