(AGENPARL) - Roma, 30 Novembre 2023 - (AGENPARL) – gio 30 novembre 2023 Newsletter
Weeks XLIX – XLX: 4th to 15th December 2023
Contact us
@ENDesk
Jacques René
Zammit
Press Officer
Monica Pizzo
Assistant
Desk Email
Week XLIX – 4th to 8th December
Tuesday 5th December
Judgment in Case C-128/22 Nordic Info
(Citizenship of the Union)
In March 2020, the World Health Organisation (WHO) described the Covid-19 epidemic
as a pandemic. Belgium banned non-essential travel to and from countries classified
as “red zones” because of the health situation there. In addition, all travellers coming
from such countries had to undergo a screening test and observe quarantine.
In July 2020, Sweden was briefly classified as a “red zone” by the Belgian authorities.
Following this classification, NORDIC INFO, an agency specialising in travel to
Sorchadh
Scandinavia, cancelled all planned trips between Belgium and Sweden. It then sought
Higgins & Olivia
Moore assisted
in the
preparation of
this Newsletter.
Follow
@EUCourtPress
on X (formerly
Twitter)
Download our
compensation for the damage caused. A Belgian court asked the Court of Justice
whether Belgian legislation was in line with EU Law.
Background Documents C-128/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Tuesday 5th December
Judgment in Joined Cases C-451/21 P Luxembourg v Commission and C-454/21 P
Engie Global LNG Holding and others v Commission
(State Aid)
By decision of 20 June 2018, the Commission found that the Luxembourg tax
authorities had adopted two series of tax rulings in the context of complex corporate
and financial arrangements within the Engie group. It considers that a tax treatment
was granted by virtue of which almost all the profits made by the subsidiaries
established in Luxembourg were not taxed. It concluded that these tax rulings
constituted State aid that was incompatible with the internal market and had to be
recovered by the Luxembourg authorities from their beneficiaries.
Communications Directorate
Press and Information unit
curia.europa.eu
Newsletter
Weeks XLIX – XLX: 4th to 15th December 2023
The General Court, seised by the Engie group and Luxembourg, accepted all of the
Commission’s arguments and dismissed the actions. The Engie group and
All times are 9:30
unless otherwise
stated.
Luxembourg appealed to the Court of Justice.
Background Documents C-451/21 P
Background Documents C-454/21 P
Don’t forget to
check the diary
There will be one press release for these cases.
on our website
for details of
other cases.
Tuesday 5th December
Judgment in Cases C-683/21 Nacionalinis visuomen?s sveikatos centras and C807/21 Deutsche Wohnen
(Data protection)
During the recent Covid-19 pandemic, a situation arose whereby the Lithuanian
Minister for Health instructed the Director of the Public Health Authority to organise
the acquisition of an IT system for recording and monitoring the data of persons
exposed to Covid-19. A company was chosen by the public health authority to create a
mobile application for this purpose. A privacy policy was drawn up in which the
company creating the mobile application and the public health authority were
designated as data controllers. Between 4 April 2020 and 26 May 2020, 3,802 people
made use of this application and provided the requested geolocation data.
In 2020, as part of an investigation into the processing of personal data, the national
data protection authority found that the processing of personal data to monitor
compliance with a quarantine was unlawful and imposed a fine.
Deutsche Wohnen SA (‘DW’), a property company with its registered office in Berlin,
indirectly owns, through holdings in various companies, approximately 163,000
housing units and 3,000 commercial units. In the course of their commercial activities,
DW and the companies in its group process the personal data of tenants of
commercial and housing units. Having doubts as to the lawfulness of the practice of
saving documents containing tenants’ personal data in an electronic archiving system
without checking whether the saving was necessary and without regularly deleting the
data, an administrative fine was imposed on the property company by the German
supervisory authority.
The Lithuanian regional court and the German higher regional court referred the case
to the Court of Justice for an interpretation of the General Data Protection Regulation.
Background Documents C-683/21
Background Documents C-807/21
Newsletter
Weeks XLIX – XLX: 4th to 15th December 2023
There will be one press release for these cases.
Thursday 7th December
Judgment in Case C-634/21 SCHUFA Holding and others (Scoring) and in Joined
Cases C-26/22 SCHUFA Holding and others and C-64/22 SCHUFA Holding and
others
(Approximation of Laws)
A number of citizens are challenging before a German court the refusal of the
competent data protection commissioner to take action against SCHUFA in relation to
“scoring” and the storage of information relating to the early discharge of outstanding
debts taken from public registers. Scoring is a statistical method that consists of
evaluating, according to a certain number of criteria linked to a certain person, the
probability of that person’s behaviour in the future. For example, this could relate to
the repayment of a loan. Information relating to the early discharge of outstanding
debts is kept for six months in public registers and for three years by SCHUFA.
The German court asks the Court to clarify the scope of the protection of personal
data, as provided for by the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
Background Documents C-634/21
Background Documents C-26/22
Background Documents C-64/22
There will be one press release for these cases.
Thursday 7th December
Judgment in Case C-518/22 AP Assistenzprofis
(Non-discrimination)
Assistenzprofis is a German company specialising in assistance and advice for people
with disabilities. In 2018, it advertised that it was recruiting personal assistants to help
a 28-year-old student with all aspects of her daily life. The advert states “a preference
for people aged between 18 and 30”. A candidate outside this age group whose
application was rejected felt discriminated against on the basis of her age.
The German Federal Labour Court, hearing this case, asked the Court of Justice to
what extent protection against age discrimination, on the one hand, and protection
against discrimination on grounds of disability, on the other, could be reconciled.
Newsletter
Weeks XLIX – XLX: 4th to 15th December 2023
Background Documents C-518/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Week XLX – 11th to 15th December
Thursday 14th December
Judgment in Case C-457/21 P Commission v Amazon.com and Others
(State aid)
A Commission decision in 2017 found that a Luxembourg tax ruling granted to the
Amazon group constituted aid incompatible with the internal market. By means of this
tax ruling, the Amazon group had requested confirmation of the treatment of two of
its subsidiaries for Luxembourg corporation tax purposes. Luxembourg and Amazon
challenged the Commission’s decision before the General Court.
In May 2021, the General Court ruled that the Commission had not demonstrated to
the requisite legal standard that a European subsidiary of the Amazon group
benefited from an undue reduction in its tax burden. It found that there was no
selective advantage in favour of a Luxembourg subsidiary of the Amazon group and
therefore annulled the Commission’s decision.
The Commission is appealing the General Court judgment.
Background Documents C-457/21 P
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 14th December
Judgment in Case C-206/22 Sparkasse Südpfalz
(Social policy)
This case arises in the context of a dispute between a citizen (claimant) and the
Sparkasse Südpfalz concerning entitlement to further days of leave per calendar year
due to an official quarantine measure during the allocated leave.
The person had been employed by the Sparkasse since 2013 as a private customer
advisor and works full time. The collective agreement for the civil service in the savings
bank sector applies to his employment contract.
Newsletter
Weeks XLIX – XLX: 4th to 15th December 2023
The Sparkasse granted the claimant leave from 3 to 11 December 2020.
By letter dated 2 December 2020, the Germersheim district administration, Germany
decided to place the claimant in quarantine in accordance with national regulations in
the context of the pandemic linked to COVID-19 between 2 and 11 December 2020, as
the claimant had had contact with a colleague who had tested positive for COVID-19.
The claimant spent the quarantine period in the bedroom and bathroom of his home
in order to avoid contaminating other members of his family.
The claimant is requesting that the Sparkasse deduct the days of quarantine from his
annual leave.
The national court seeks to ascertain whether the Working Time Directive and the EU
Charter on Fundamental Rights preclude national provisions or practices under which
the right to leave is also enforced in a situation in which the worker is affected by an
unforeseeable event, such as an official quarantine measure, which prevents the
unrestricted exercise of the right to leave.
Background Documents C-206/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 14th December
Judgment in Case C-340/21 Natsionalna agentsia za prihodite
(Approximation of laws)
The Bulgarian National Agency for Public Revenues (NAP) is an authority attached to
the Bulgarian Minister of Finance. As part of its tasks, which include identifying,
securing and collecting public debts, it is responsible for processing personal data.
On 15 July 2019, the Bulgarian media announced that there had been unauthorised
access to NAP’s computer system and that, as a result of this cyber-attack, personal
data concerning millions of people had been published on the Internet. Many people
took NAP to court to obtain compensation for non-material damage resulting from
their concerns and fears about the future misuse of their personal data.
The Bulgarian Supreme Administrative Court referred several questions to the Court
of Justice for a preliminary ruling on the interpretation of the General Data Protection
Regulation (GDPR). It requested clarification on the conditions for compensation for
non-material damage claimed by an individual whose personal data, in the possession
of a public agency, was published on the internet following an attack by hackers.
Newsletter
Weeks XLIX – XLX: 4th to 15th December 2023
Background Documents C-340/21
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 14th December
Judgment in Case C-109/22 Commission v Romania (Decommissioning of
landfills)
(Environment)
EU law aims to prevent or reduce as far as possible the negative effects of landfillings
on the environment.
In 2018, the Court ruled that Romania had failed to fulfil its obligations to stop
landfilling and close 68 landfills that were not authorised to be in operation. The
Commission brought an action for failure to fulfil obligations in 2022, taking the view
that Romania had still not complied with this judgment.
Background Documents C-109/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 14th December
Opinion in Case C-626/22 Ilva and Others
(Environment)
Several residents of the southern Italian city of Taranto are taking legal action in a
Milan court against the continued operation of the Ilva steelworks located in Taranto.
They believe that the steel mill’s emissions jeopardise their health and claim that it
does not comply with the EU Industrial Emissions Directive.
Back in 2019, the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) found that the steelworks
– one of the largest in Europe with around 11,000 employees and approximately 1,500
hectares – had a significant negative impact on the environment and affected the
health of local residents. Measures to reduce the adverse environmental impact have
been included in the authorisation conditions since 2012, but the deadlines for their
implementation have been repeatedly extended.
The Milan court has asked the Court to clarify the authorisation requirements under
the Industrial Emissions Directive. It wants to know the importance of certain
information on the impact of the steelworks on human health as well as information
Newsletter
Weeks XLIX – XLX: 4th to 15th December 2023
on certain emissions, and whether it is permissible to repeatedly extend the deadline
for the implementation of certain authorisation conditions.
Background Documents C-626/22
There will be a press release for this case.
HEARINGS OF NOTE*
Court of Justice
Thursday 7th December: 09:30 – Joined cases C-771/22 HDI Global and C-45/23 MS
Amlin Insurance (Consumer protection – package travels)
Thursday 7th December: 09:30 – C-35/23 Greislzel (Area of freedom, security and
justice – Judicial cooperation in civil matters)
Tuesday 12th December: 09:00 – Joined cases C-611/22 P and
C-625/22 P Grail v Commission and Illumina (Competition)
General Court
Tuesday 05th December: 09.30 – T-743/22 Mazepin v Council (Restrictive measures –
Ukraine)
Tuesday 12th December: 09:30 – Joined cases T-309/22 and T-739/22 Rashevsky v
Council (Restrictive measures – Ukraine)
Wednesday 13th December: 09:30 – Joined cases T-758/22 Bayerische Ärzteversorgung
and Others – T-759/22 Sächsische Ärzteversorgung (Economic policy)
Thursday 14th December: 14:30 – T-58/23 Supermac’s v EUIPO – McDonald’s
International Property (BIG MAC) (Intellectual property – trade marks)
* This is a non-exhaustive list and does not include all the hearings over the next two
weeks.
Trending
- La Cina rafforza la sua influenza in Asia centrale: accordo strategico sul gas in Kazakistan e nuove intese economiche nella regione
- Rifondazione Comunista: ddl anti Palestina liberticida, campo largo si impegni a abrogarlo
- COMUNICATO STAMPA CONSIGLIO DEI MINISTRI N. 198 18/11/2026 PALAZZO CHIGI
- Riforma forense, Ostellari (Lega): impegno mantenuto, più garanzie per avvocati e cittadini
- FEMMINICIDIO: BILOTTI (M5S), A SALERNO 3 DONNE UCCISE IN POCHE ORE. NON SI SPOSTI FULCRO DA VIOLENZA
- BOSCAINI (FI) AL GOVERNO: “SIANO VERIFICATE LE COPERTURE FINANZIARIE DEL PROGETTO DI POTENZIAMENTO, CHE VA REALIZZATO ENTRO 6 ANNI, PRIMA DELLA GALLERIA DEL BRENNERO”
- MANOVRA: DOMANI CONFERENZA STAMPA FDI ALLA CAMERA SUGLI INTERVENTI PER L’AGRICOLTURA
- DL CORTEI. ZUCCONI (FDI): PLAUSO A EMENDAMENTO STOP SOCIAL UNDER 13. UNA BATTAGLIA DI CIVILTÀ
- DDL ANTISEMITISMO: ORSINI (FI), “IL DIRITTO DI ESSERE ANTISEMITI NON FA PARTE DELLA LIBERT?
- DDL ANTISEMITISMO: ORSINI (FI), “SCHLEIN INCOERENTE SULLA DEFINIZIONE IHRA
