(AGENPARL) - Roma, 26 Giugno 2025 - (AGENPARL) – Thu 26 June 2025 PRESS RELEASE No 77/25
Luxembourg, 26 June 2025
Judgments of the Court in Joined Cases C-464/23 P, C-465/23 P, C-467/23 P, C-468/23 P and C-470/23 P |
EVH and Others v Commission and in Cases C-466/23 P | Stadtwerke Hameln Weserbergland,
C-469/23 P | eins energie in sachsen, C-484/23 P | Mainova and C-485/23 P | enercity v Commission
The Court of Justice confirms, as previously done so by the General Court,
the Commission’s approval of the acquisition of certain E.ON generation
assets by RWE
In March 2018, the German energy companies RWE and E.ON, which are active in several European countries,
announced that they wanted to engage in a complex asset swap by means of three concentration operations.
By the first concentration operation, RWE wished to acquire sole or joint control over certain generation assets of
E.ON. The second concentration operation consisted in the acquisition by E.ON of the sole control over the
distribution and retail energy business, as well as certain generation assets of Innogy, a subsidiary of RWE. As for the
third concentration operation, it concerned the acquisition of 16.67% of E.ON’s shares by RWE.
The first and second concentration operations were reviewed and authorised by the European Commission, 1 while
the third concentration operation was reviewed and authorised by the Federal Competition Authority, Germany.
Eleven German municipal authorities challenged the two Commission approval decisions before the General Court
of the European Union.
By judgments of 17 May 2023, the General Court dismissed the actions challenging the approval of the first
operation (acquisition of generation assets of E.ON by RWE), some on the substance and others on grounds of
inadmissibility. 2 The General Court observed that an asset swap between independent undertakings did not
constitute a ‘single concentration.’ It also held that the Commission had not made any manifest errors in its
assessment of the compatibility of that first concentration with EU competition law.
Next, by judgments of 20 December 2023, the General Court dismissed the actions of the municipal authorities
challenging the approval of the second concentration operation (acquisition of the distribution and retail energy
business as well as certain generation assets of Innogy by E.ON). 3 The General Court again confirmed that an asset
swap between independent undertakings did not constitute a ‘single concentration.’ Nor had the Commission made
any manifest errors in its assessment of the compatibility of that second concentration with EU competition law.
Nine of the 11 municipal authorities brought appeals before the Court of Justice against the judgments of the
General Court of 17 May 4 and 20 December 2023. 5
By its judgment in EVH and Others, the Court of Justice dismisses five of the nine appeals brought against the
judgments of the General Court of 17 May 2023, delivered on the substance, and thus confirms, as did the
General Court, the Commission’s approval of the first concentration operation (acquisition of generation
assets of E.ON by RWE). The Court of Justice confirms, in particular, that an asset swap between independent
undertakings does not constitute a ‘single concentration.’
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
By contrast, by its four other judgments delivered today, the Court of Justice sets aside four judgments of the
General Court of 17 May 2023 by which the General Court had dismissed the respective actions as inadmissible on
the ground that the municipal authorities in question were not individually concerned by the Commission’s approval
of the first operation (acquisition of generation assets of E.ON by RWE). The Court of Justice notes that those
municipal authorities had put forward certain arguments relating to the allegedly substantial effect on their market
position following that operation. However, according to the Court of Justice, the General Court failed to fulfil its
obligation to state reasons by not providing any statement of reasons, not even a brief one, to make it possible to
understand whether those arguments were examined and, if so, why they were considered to be incapable of
establishing such an effect.
However, giving final judgment itself in the four disputes in question, the Court of Justice finds, after
examining those arguments, that the four municipal authorities have not established that their market position was
substantially affected by the operation concerned. Consequently, they have not established that they are
individually concerned by the relevant Commission decision. The Court of Justice therefore dismisses, as the
General Court did, the four actions as inadmissible.
The appeals brought against the judgments of the General Court of 20 December 2023 concerning the
Commission’s approval of the second concentration operation (the acquisition of the distribution and retail energy
business as well as certain generation assets of Innogy by E.ON) are pending before the Court of Justice.
Municipal
authority
Appeals before
Actions before
the Court of
the General
Justice against
Court
the judgments of
concerning the the General Court
first
relating to the
concentration
first
operation
concentration
operation
Actions before
the General
Court
concerning the
second
concentration
operation
Appeals before
the Court of
Justice against
the judgments of
the General Court
relating to the
second
concentration
operation
T-312/20
C-464/23 P
T-53/21
C-171/24 P
Stadtwerke Leipzig
T-313/20
C-465/23 P
T-55/21
C-172/24 P
Stadtwerke Hameln
Weserbergland
T-314/20
C-466/23 P
T-58/21
C-174/24 P
T-315/20
C-467/23 P
T-56/21
C-173/24 P
Naturstrom
T-316/20
T-60/21
EnergieVerbund
Dresden
T-317/20
C-468/23 P
T-61/21
C-176/24 P
eins energie in
sachsen
T-318/20
C-469/23 P
T-59/21
C-175/24 P
T-319/20
C-470/23 P
T-62/21
C-177/24 P
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
Mainova
T-320/20
C-484/23 P
T-64/21
C-178/24 P
enercity
T-321/20
C-485/23 P
T-65/21
C-179/24 P
Stadtwerke
Frankfurt am Main
T-322/20
T-63/21
NOTE: An appeal, on a point or points of law only, may be brought before the Court of Justice against a judgment or
order of the General Court. In principle, the appeal does not have suspensive effect. If the appeal is admissible and
well founded, the Court of Justice sets aside the judgment of the General Court. Where the state of the proceedings
so permits, the Court of Justice may itself give final judgment in the case. Otherwise, it refers the case back to the
General Court, which is bound by the decision given by the Court of Justice on the appeal.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice.
The full text and, as the case may be, an abstract of the judgments (C-464/23 P, C-466/23 P, C-469/23 P, C-484/23 P
and C-485/23 P) is published on the CURIA website on the day of delivery.
Stay Connected!
Decision C(2019) 1711 final of 26 February 2019 declaring a concentration compatible with the internal market and the EEA Agreement (Case
M.8871 – RWE/E.ON Assets) and Decision C(2019) 6530 final of 17 September 2019 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the internal market
and the EEA Agreement (Case M.8870 – E.ON/Innogy); see also Commission press releases IP/19/1432 and IP/19/5582.
Judgments of 17 May 2023, EVH v Commission, T-312/20, Stadtwerke Leipzig v Commission, T-313/20, Stadtwerke Hameln Weserbergland v Commission,
T-314/20, TEAG v Commission, T-315/20, Naturstrom v Commission, T-316/20, EnergieVerbund Dresden v Commission, T-317/20, eins energie in sachsen v
Commission, T-318/20, GGEW v Commission, T-319/20, Mainova v Commission, T-320/20, enercity v Commission, T-321/20 and Stadtwerke Frankfurt am
Main v Commission, T-322/20; see also press releases Nos 81/23 and 82/23.
Judgments of 20 December 2023 EVH v Commission, T-53/21, Stadtwerke Leipzig v Commission, T-55/21, TEAG v Commission, T-56/21, Stadtwerke
Hameln Weserbergland v Commission, T-58/21, eins energie in sachsen v Commission, T-59/21, Naturstrom v Commission, T-60/21, EnergieVerbund Dresden
v Commission, T-61/21, GGEW v Commission, T-62/21, Stadtwerke Frankfurt am Main v Commission, T-63/21, Mainova v Commission, T-64/21, and enercity
v Commission, T-65/21; see also press release No 197/23.
See the municipal authorities listed at the beginning of the press release. For an overview of the cases, see the table above.
See the table above.
Communications Directorate
Trending
- FERRARA, FABBRI SECONDO TRA I SINDACI DEI COMUNI TRA 120MILA E 260MILA ABITANTI CON IL 58,5% DI GRADIMENTO SECONDO IL SONDAGGIO LAB21. SINDACO: “UN RISULTATO CHE MI RENDE FELICE. IL CONSENSO VA CONQUISTATO OGNI GIORNO
- Domenica ecologica, oltre mille alberi e piantine donati ai cittadini al Parco San Giuliano
- MANIFESTAZIONI A PARMA, RUSSO (FDI): GRAZIE A FORZE DELL’ORDINE, SMENTITA LA NARRAZIONE DI UN GOVERNO CHE REPRIME IL DISSENSO
- NEWS RELEASE: Six months on, accessing hard-to-reach communities key to halting Ebola outbreak
- BASKET IN CARROZZINA, LA BRIANTEA84 CANTU’ CONQUISTA LA SUPERCOPPA MARTIN MANCINI
- Sicurezza stradale, Casu (PD): 2.868 morti in un anno, cambiare il codice per fermare la strage
- SICUREZZA STRADALE. DE CORATO (FDI): È PRIORITÀ PER GOVERNO MELONI
- Cybersicurezza. Piccolotti (Avs): Meno di 600 milioni alla cyber difesa, miliardi per le armi. Al Ministro Foti ricordiamo che ospedali e scuole non si difendono con gli F-35
- Mastella: “Classifica Italia Oggi, Benevento si conferma da primato per sicurezza e migliora sul lavoro, la città è cresciuta
- Codice giallo per rischio idrogeologico idraulico del reticolo minore
