(AGENPARL) - Roma, 9 Gennaio 2025 - (AGENPARL) – gio 09 gennaio 2025 PRESS RELEASE No 2/25
Luxembourg, 9 January 2025
Judgment of the Court in Case C-394/23 | Mousse
GDPR and rail transport: a customer’s gender identity is not necessary
data for the purchase of a transport ticket
The collection of data regarding customers’ titles is not objectively indispensable, in particular where its
purpose is to personalise commercial communication
The association Mousse challenged, before the French data protection authority (the CNIL), 1 the practice of the
French railway undertaking SNCF Connect whereby the latter systematically requires its customers to indicate their
title (‘Monsieur’ or ‘Madame’) (‘Mr’ or ‘Ms’) when purchasing transport tickets online. That association takes the view
that that requirement infringes the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), 2 in particular in the light of the
principle of data minimisation, because an indication of the title, which corresponds to a gender identity, does not
appear to be necessary for the purchase of a rail transport ticket. In 2021, the CNIL decided to reject that complaint,
finding that that practice did not constitute an infringement of the GDPR.
Mousse disagreed with that decision and brought an action before the French Council of State seeking to have the
decision annulled. The Council of State asks the Court of Justice whether, in particular, the collection of data
regarding customers’ titles, limited to the titles ‘Monsieur’ and ‘Madame’ (‘Mr’ and ‘Ms’), can be classified as lawful
and consistent with, in particular, the principle of data minimisation, where that collection is aimed at enabling
personalised commercial communication with those customers, in accordance with commonly accepted practices in
that field.
The Court reiterates that, in accordance with the principle of data minimisation, which gives expression to the
principle of proportionality, the data collected must be adequate, relevant and limited to what is necessary in
the light of the purposes for which those data are processed.
The Court also reiterates that the GDPR sets out an exhaustive and restrictive list of the cases in which processing
of personal data can be regarded as lawful: that is so, inter alia, where it is (i) necessary for the performance of a
contract to which the data subject is party, or (ii) necessary for the purposes of the legitimate interests pursued by
the controller or by a third party. 3
As regards the first of those two justifications, the Court reiterates that, for data processing to be regarded as
necessary for the performance of a contract, that processing must be objectively indispensable in order to enable
the proper performance of that contract. In that context, the Court finds that personalisation of the commercial
communication based on presumed gender identity according to a customer’s title does not appear to be
objectively indispensable in order to enable the proper performance of a rail transport contract. The railway
undertaking could choose to communicate based on generic, inclusive expressions when addressing a
customer, which have no correlation with the presumed gender identity of those customers. That would be a
workable and less intrusive solution.
As regards the second justification, the Court, whilst referring to its settled case-law on the matter, states that the
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
processing of data regarding the title of customers of a transport undertaking, the purpose of which is to
personalise the commercial communication based on their gender identity, cannot be regarded as necessary
(i) where those customers were not informed of the legitimate interest pursued when those data were collected;
(ii) where the processing is not carried out only in so far as is strictly necessary for the attainment of that
legitimate interest; or (iii) where, in the light of all of the relevant circumstances, the fundamental freedoms and
rights of those customers can prevail over that legitimate interest, in particular where there is a risk of
discrimination on grounds of gender identity.
NOTE: A reference for a preliminary ruling allows the courts and tribunals of the Member States, in disputes which
have been brought before them, to refer questions to the Court of Justice about the interpretation of European
Union law or the validity of a European Union act. The Court of Justice does not decide the dispute itself. It is for the
national court or tribunal to dispose of the case in accordance with the Court’s decision, which is similarly binding on
other national courts or tribunals before which a similar issue is raised.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice. The presentation of the facts and of the legal
context refers to the relevant time and is based on the case file.
The full text and, as the case may be, an abstract of the judgment is published on the CURIA website on the day of
delivery.
Stay Connected!
Commission Nationale de l’Informatique et des Libertés.
Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the
processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data, and repealing Directive 95/46/EC (General Data Protection Regulation).
The GDPR contains other grounds on which processing of data can be regarded as lawful. However, the French Council of State refers exclusively to
those two justifications.
Communications Directorate
Trending
- Camera dei deputati: Coperture Centemero
- Armi nucleari in Europa, Mosca avverte Lituania e Polonia: possibili contromisure se cambiano le restrizioni
- IMAM DI REGGIO EMILIA, SPUNTA IL POST IN MEMORIA DI UN SOSTENITORE DI BIN LADEN E RIEMERGONO LE DICHIARAZIONI SHOCK SU HAMAS. CISINT (LEGA): “FUORI I PREDICATORI D’ODIO CONTRO L’OCCIDENTE”
- Agenzia regionale 1215.26 Ciliento incontro Protezione civile Campi Salentina
- SICUREZZA: CATTANEO (FI), “FAVORIRE PARTECIPAZIONE DI TAIWAN A INTERPOL PER RAFFORZARE CONTRASTO ALLA CRIMINALITÀ TRANSNAZIONALE”
- DDL CONCORRENZA, MANCINI (FDI): SU ARTICOLO 13 SI DISCUTA NEL MERITO, RISPETTO COMPETENZE VALE PER TUTTE LE PROFESSIONI
- Zingaretti: Solidarietà ai colleghi del Movimento 5 Stelle. Nessuno può interferire con il libero esercizio del mandato parlamentare europeo
- Lega: Toccalini nuovo capogruppo in commissione Finanze
- Manovra, Malavasi (Pd) a Gemmato: governo sostenga proposta Pd e sposti 1.6 miliardi voucher over 75 su fondo Ssn
- Marche, Schlein: Antimafia faccia chiarezza, incredibile se ne parli così poco
