(AGENPARL) - Roma, 9 Novembre 2023 - (AGENPARL) – gio 09 novembre 2023 Newsletter
Weeks XLVI – XLVII: 13th to 24th November 2023
Contact us
@ENDesk
Jacques René
Zammit
Press Officer
Monica Pizzo
Assistant
EN Desk Email
Week XLVI – 13th to 17th November
Thursday 16th November
Judgment in Joined Cases C-583/21 NC – C-584/21 JD – C-585/21 TA – C-586/21 FZ
(Transfer of Spanish Notarial Office)
(Social Policy)
Four employees of a notary’s office in Madrid (Spain) asked a Madrid court to declare
that their dismissals by the new owner of the office were unlawful. According to the
Madrid judge, the workers had been employed continuously by successive notaries in
the practice. The new notary justified their dismissal on the grounds that they had not
passed their probationary period.
Sorchadh
Higgins & Olivia
Moore assisted
in the
preparation of
this Newsletter.
Follow
The employees also asked the judge to calculate their seniority, to all intents and
purposes, from the day they began working in the office. The titular notary, on the
other hand, considers that their seniority only began to run from the date of the
employment contracts concluded with him.
The Madrid judge asked the Court of Justice whether, in view of the specific nature of
@EUCourtPress
the profession of Spanish notaries, the Directive on the safeguarding of employees’
on X (formerly
rights in the event of transfers of undertakings was applicable to this situation.
Twitter)
Background Documents C-583/21
Download our
Background Documents C-584/21
Background Documents C-585/21
Background Documents C-586/21
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 16th November
Judgment in Case C-333/22 Ligue des droits humains (Verification of data
treatment by controlling authority)
Communications Directorate
Press and Information unit
curia.europa.eu
Newsletter
Weeks XLVI – XLVII: 13th to 24th November 2023
All times are 9:30
unless otherwise
stated.
Don’t forget to
check the diary
(Fundamental Rights – Data Protection)
A citizen applied to the Belgian national security authority for a security clearance for
professional purposes. This document was refused on the grounds that he had taken
part in protests years earlier. Invoking his right of access to his data, the citizen
contacted the Police Information Review Body, which informed him that he had only
on our website
indirect access and that it would itself verify the lawfulness of the processing of his
for details of
data. However, once this verification had been carried out, as required by Belgian law,
other cases.
the body merely replied that it had carried out the necessary checks. The citizen then
took legal action, but the Belgian court of first instance declared that it did not have
jurisdiction.
Referred to by the person concerned and the Ligue des droits humains (Human Rights
League), the Brussels Court of Appeal asked the Court of Justice whether EU law
provides for the possibility that the person concerned by the processing of his or her
data may challenge the decision of the supervisory authority when exercising that
person’s rights with regard to the processing in question.
Background Documents C-333/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Week XLVII – 19th to 24th November
Wednesday 22nd November
General Court
Judgment in Joined Cases:
T-302/20 Del Valle Ruiz and others v SRB
T-303/20 Arias Mosquera and Others v SRB
T-307/20 Calatrava Real State 2015 v SRB
and in
T-304/20 Molina Fernandez v SRB, and T-330/20 ACMO and others v SRB
(Banking – Economic and Monetary Policy)
These cases concern a series of actions brought against Decision SRB/EES/2020/52 of
the Single Resolution Board of 17 March 2020 determining whether compensation
needs to be granted to the shareholders and creditors in respect of which the
resolution actions concerning Banco Popular Español S.A. have been effected.
Background Documents T-302/20
Background Documents T-303/20
Newsletter
Weeks XLVI – XLVII: 13th to 24th November 2023
Background Documents T-304/20
Background Documents T-307/20
Background Documents T-330/20
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 23rd November
Judgments in Case C-209/21 P Ryanair v Commission (aid to airline companies
licenced in Sweden) and C-210/21 P Ryanair v Commission (aid to airline
companies licenced in France)
(State Aid)
In March 2020, France notified the European Commission of an aid measure in the
form of a moratorium on payment of the civil aviation tax and the solidarity tax on
airline tickets. This moratorium, which benefited airlines holding a French licence,
consisted of the deferral of the payment of these taxes until 1 January 2021 and then
spreading the payments over a period of 24 months, i.e. until 31 December 2022.
In April 2020, Sweden notified the Commission of an aid measure in the form of a loan
guarantee scheme of up to SEK 5 billion to support airlines holding a Swedish
operating licence in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic.
The European Commission approved the aid measures. Ryanair challenged these
approval decisions before the General Court of the European Union, which dismissed
the appeals after finding that the disputed aid measures complied with EU law.
It held that the Swedish aid scheme was presumed to have been adopted in the
interests of the Union. Furthermore, the moratorium introduced by France was
appropriate to remedy the economic damage caused by the Covid-19 pandemic and
did not constitute discrimination.
Ryanair has appealed both the General Court decisions.
Background Documents C-209/21 P
Background Documents C-210/21 P
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 23rd November
Judgment in Case C-321/22 Provident Polska
Newsletter
Weeks XLVI – XLVII: 13th to 24th November 2023
(Consumer Protection)
Three citizens have entered into consumer credit agreements. Under the terms of
these contracts, they are obliged to pay various fees and commissions in addition to
the sum borrowed plus interest. These credit costs, excluding interest, are very high.
They correspond to several tens of percentage points of the amounts lent. By invoking
the overvalued and unreasonable nature of these costs, the consumers asked a Polish
court to declare that the clauses relating to them were unfair and therefore not
binding on them.
That court hesitated as to whether those terms could be so classified on the sole
ground that the charges and commissions were manifestly excessive. Moreover, the
Polish court noted that,under some of these contracts, the weekly instalments are
payable exclusively in cash in the hands of the lender’s agent when he visits the
consumer’s home. Such a solution would, in turn, be abusive because it could only be
explained by the desire to exert emotional pressure on the consumer.
However it is doubtful as to whether declaring a single clause governing the method
of payment to be unfair would be tantamount to declaring the entire contract null and
void. Uncertain about the interpretation of the Directive on unfair terms in consumer
contracts, the Polish judge turned to the Court of Justice.
Background Documents C-321/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 23rd November
Judgment in Case C-354/22 Weingut A
(Agriculture and fisheries)
A winegrower in the Moselle region of Germany also uses the terms “Weingut”
(winegrowing estate) and “Gutsabfüllung” (bottling on the estate) for wine he produces
from grapes grown on rented vineyards around 70 km from his own farm. Under the
terms of the contract that this eponymous winegrower has signed with the
winegrower to whom these vineyards belong, the latter cultivates the rented vines
according to the former’s instructions.
In addition, each year this other winegrower rents a pressing facility from the
eponymous winegrower for a period of 24 hours, during which time the grapes from
the rented vineyards are pressed exclusively in accordance with the eponymous
winegrower’s oenological practices. The resulting wine is then transported to the
winegrower’s premises.
Newsletter
Weeks XLVI – XLVII: 13th to 24th November 2023
The Land of Rhineland-Palatinate considers that the eponymous winegrower cannot
use the indications in question for wine made on the premises of the other
winegrower. In order for certain indications referring to a holding, such as “Weingut”,
to be used, EU law requires that the grapevine product be made exclusively from
grapes harvested in the vineyards cultivated by that holding and that the winemaking
be carried out entirely on that holding.
The German Federal Administrative Court, hearing the case, referred a question to the
Court of Justice concerning the latter condition.
Background Documents C-354/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 23rd November
Opinion in Case C-29/22 P KS and KD v Council and C-44/22 P Commission v KS
and others
(Common Foreign and Security Policy – External Relations)
Two individuals lost family members in the aftermath of the Kosovo conflict in 1999.
The murders and disappearances remained unsolved. In 2008, the European Union
established a civilian mission – the EU Rule of Law Mission in Kosovo (Eulex Kosovo) that had, among its tasks, the investigation of such crimes.
The two individuals felt that Eulex Kosovo did not properly investigate the crimes
involving their family members. As a result, they claimed a breach of their
fundamental rights. They brought an action for damages requesting compensation
before the General Court of the EU. The General Court dismissed their action, holding
that it lacked jurisdiction to hear the action. The individuals and the EU Commission
appealed the General Court’s decision.
Background Documents C-29/22 P
Background Documents C-44/22 P
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 23rd November
Opinion in Case C-351/22 Neves 77 Solutions
(Common Foreign and Security Policy)
Newsletter
Weeks XLVI – XLVII: 13th to 24th November 2023
Neves 77 Solutions SRL (Neves), is a Romanian company that has, as its main activity,
brokering in the sale of products in the field of aviation. In 2020, the Romanian
National Tax Administration Agency issued an infringement notice against Neves. It
considered that Neves had infringed restrictive measures against the Russian
Federation introduced by a Council Common Foreign & Security Policy (CFSP) Decision
as well as the Romanian law regulating national implementation of such measures.
The Agency fined Neves around € 6,000 and confiscated approximately €3 million,
representing the sums that Neves had received from the offending brokering
transactions that fell within the scope of the CFSP Decision. Neves contested the
Agency infringement notice before the Romanian courts. The referring Romanian
court wonders whether the national implementing measures run counter to EU law
and rights contained in the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union.
This indirectly raises the question whether the EU Courts have jurisdiction over
matters concerning CFSP measures.
Background Documents C-351/22 P
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 23rd November
Judgment in Case C-84/22 Right to Know
(Access to Documents – Environment)
On 8 March 2016, Right to Know CLG, a not-for-profit organisation governed by Irish
law, made a request to the Irish Taoiseach (Prime Minister) for access to all documents
which showed cabinet discussions on Ireland’s greenhouse gas emissions from 2002
to 2016. The Taoiseach (Prime Minister) refused that request in June 2016 following an
internal review procedure. Right to Know thereupon brought proceedings before the
High Court seeking a judicial review of that decision.
By judgment of 1 June 2018, Right to Know CLG v An Taoiseach ([2018] IEHC 372), the
High Court remitted the decision to the Taoiseach (Prime Minister) for reconsideration.
The High Court held inter alia, on the basis of a precedent discussed by the parties,
that meetings of the Irish Government were to be characterised as ‘internal
communications’ of a public authority, with the result that the requirement to disclose
records on emissions into the environment did not apply. The Taoiseach (Prime
Minister) had, however, failed to weigh the public interest served by disclosure and the
interest in confidentiality.
By order of 16 August 2018, the Taoiseach (Prime Minister) granted partial access to
the requested documents. Right to Know thereupon made a fresh application to the
Newsletter
Weeks XLVI – XLVII: 13th to 24th November 2023
High Court for judicial review of that second decision. The judge who had delivered the
judgment of 1 June 2018 is no longer responsible. The new judge referred the case to
the Court of Justice.
The present request for a preliminary ruling seeks to clarify whether records of
government cabinet discussions come either under the exception for internal
communications or under the exception for proceedings of public authorities. It must
also be considered whether this question may be re-examined at all if it has already
been decided in an earlier final judgment on the same request for access.
Background Documents C-84/22
There will be an Info Rapide for the case (available on request).
Thursday 23rd November
Opinion in Case C-801/21 P EUIPO v Indo European Foods
(Intellectual property – Effects of Brexit)
By its appeal, the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) seeks
annulment of the judgment of the General Court of the European Union of 6 October
2021 in Case T-342/20 Indo European Foods v EUIPO – Chakari (Abresham Super
Basmati Selaa Grade One World’s Best Rice). In that judgment, the General Court
upheld the challenge brought by Indo European Foods Ltd against the decision of the
Fourth Board of Appeal of the EUIPO of 2 April 2020 concerning the application for
registration of the figurative mark Abresham Super Basmati Selaa Grade One World’s
Best Rice.
This case gives the Court the opportunity to clarify the issue of the disappearance
during the proceedings of the right on which an application to oppose the registration
of a Union trade mark was based, as a result of the withdrawal of the United Kingdom
of Great Britain and Northern Ireland from the Union.
More particularly, the question arises as to the procedural implications of such a
disappearance, since the appeal is concerned exclusively with the Court’s examination
of the admissibility of the action for annulment of the decision rejecting the opposition
application.
Background Documents C-801/21 P
There will be an Info Rapide for the case (available on request).
HEARINGS OF NOTE*
Newsletter
Weeks XLVI – XLVII: 13th to 24th November 2023
Court of Justice
Wednesday 23rd November: 09.30 – C-757/22 Meta Platforms Ireland (GDPR)
* This is a non-exhaustive list and does not include all the hearings over the next two
weeks.
Trending
- ptn – lancio 437-16 novembre +++ Provincia / Dichiarazioni di Federighi alla cerimonia di Collescipoli
- Intelligenza artificiale, allarme di BCE e Federal Reserve: attacchi informatici, trading automatizzato e rischi di crisi finanziaria
- Libia, le maggiori riserve petrolifere dell’Africa non bastano ad attirare le grandi compagnie occidentali: instabilità e tensioni politiche frenano gli investimenti
- FIORE (FN): “È ORA DI PORTARE LA LUCE NEL PORTO DELLE NEBBIE
- Sp 30 ‘Sant’Angelo-Montelabbate’, mercoledì 18 novembre lavori di Marche Multiservizi in fascia notturna
- Data center sottomarini, la nuova frontiera dell’intelligenza artificiale divide il mondo: meno consumi sulla terraferma, ma crescono le proteste per la tutela degli oceani
- Energia nucleare, l’Asia guida il 73% delle nuove centrali mondiali: Cina, India, Giappone e Corea del Sud accelerano la transizione energetica
- Stati Uniti, allarme dell’intelligence su possibili attacchi iraniani a Washington: nel mirino funzionari di Trump, ipotesi bomba sporca e armi chimiche
- Capo Verde, José Maria Neves rieletto presidente con il 64% dei voti: netta vittoria su Joana Rosa, ma preoccupa la bassa affluenza
- Stati Uniti, guasto tecnico a JPMorgan Chase provoca disservizi bancari a livello nazionale: rallentamenti nei pagamenti e problemi con Zelle
