(AGENPARL) - Roma, 28 Settembre 2023 - (AGENPARL) – gio 28 settembre 2023 PRESS RELEASE No 149/23
Luxembourg, 28 September 2023
Judgment of the Court in Case C-692/20 | Commission v United Kingdom (Fiscal marking of gas oil)
The Court of Justice orders the United Kingdom to pay a lump sum penalty
of € 32 million for having failed to prohibit the use of marked fuel in
private pleasure boats within the time limit prescribed by the Commission
The United Kingdom did not comply with the judgment establishing the infringement until after the court
proceedings were brought, after a period of almost three years
By the judgment of 17 October 2018 1, the Court of Justice held that, by allowing the use of fuel that was marked (by
the addition of colouring) for the propulsion of private pleasure craft, even where the fuel in question was taxed at
full rate, the United Kingdom had infringed EU law.
Under an EU directive 2, fiscal marking is intended to make it possible to identify gas oil that is not subject to the full
rate of taxation, such as that used in commercial boats. That aim cannot be achieved if the marking may also be
used for gas oil intended for uses subject to taxation at the full rate, such as that used for propulsion of private
pleasure craft.
The Commission sent a letter of formal notice to the United Kingdom inviting it to submit its observations regarding
compliance with the judgment establishing the original infringement and, to that end, granted it a time limit of four
months starting from the date of receipt of that letter within which to respond, namely by 15 September 2020. By
that date, that State had already withdrawn from the European Union. However, Union law and therefore the
directive in question continued to apply to the United Kingdom as a whole during the transition period which did
not end until 31 December 2020. Since 1 January 2021, EU law has no longer applied to that State, except in respect
of Northern Ireland.
Taking the view that the United Kingdom had not taken all the necessary measures to comply in good time with the
judgment establishing the original infringement, the Commission, on 21 December 2020, brought before the Court a
second infringement action against that State seeking, first, a declaration that the United Kingdom had failed to fulfil
its obligation to comply with that judgment and, second, an order for that State to pay a financial penalty, namely a
daily penalty payment and a lump sum.
Given that, with effect from 1 October 2021, the use of marked fuel in private pleasure craft for propulsion was
prohibited in Northern Ireland, the Commission withdrew its claim for the United Kingdom to be ordered to pay a
daily penalty payment. Nevertheless, it maintained its claim for an order requiring that State to pay a lump sum.
By its judgment handed down today, the Court holds, first, that the United Kingdom has failed to fulfil its
Judgment of 17 October 2018, Commission v United Kingdom, C-503/17.
Council Directive 95/60/EC of 27 November 1995 on fiscal marking of gas oils and kerosene (OJ 1995 L 291, p. 46).
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
obligation to take all the necessary measures to comply with the judgment establishing the original
infringement within the time limit prescribed by the Commission, namely by 15 September 2020, and, second,
that the infringement did not persist up until the examination of the facts of the case by the Court.
According to the Court, it is clear that the United Kingdom had not taken all the necessary measures to
comply with that judgment within that time period. In that respect, it rejects the United Kingdom’s argument
that the Commission’s letter of formal notice and its action were brought prematurely. In addition, the Court
considers that the failure to comply with that judgment cannot be justified by any difficulties related to the
legislative procedure, the general election, public consultations, geographic features, the variety in port sizes,
difficulties in supplying both marked fuel and unmarked fuel, or the COVID-19 pandemic.
As regards the claim for the United Kingdom to be ordered to pay a lump sum, the Court takes account of the
seriousness of the infringement, its duration and that State’s ability to pay.
As regards the seriousness of the infringement, the Court recalls the importance for the establishment of the
internal market of the rule infringed. In addition, it observes that both United Kingdom citizens wishing to enter
waters of neighbouring Member States, and citizens of those Member states wishing to enter United Kingdom
waters and needing to refuel with marked fuel before returning, risked facing difficulties during checks by the
authorities of those Member States and, in particular, having fines imposed on them by those authorities.
In that regard, the Court recalls that the practical difficulties referred to by the United Kingdom cannot be taken into
account as a mitigating circumstance. The same is true as regards that State’s cooperation with the Commission
during the pre-litigation procedure; only cooperation with the Commission characterised by steps showing an
intention to comply within the shortest time possible with the judgment establishing the infringement in question
may be taken into account for that purpose.
By contrast, the Court takes into account as a mitigating circumstance, first of all, the fact that the United Kingdom
took a certain number of measures both before the present action was lodged and while the proceedings were
ongoing in order to comply with the judgment establishing the original infringement. Next, the effect of the
infringement is reduced since 1 January 2021 in so far as, since that date, the directive at issue has no longer
applied in that State, except in respect of Northern Ireland. Finally, the Court also takes into account, in that
context, the fact that the United Kingdom had never previously failed to give effect to a judgment establishing an
infringement delivered by the Court.
As to the duration of the infringement, almost three years elapsed between the delivery of the judgment
establishing the original infringement and its implementation by the United Kingdom.
As regards the United Kingdom’s ability to pay, it is true that, since 1 January 2021, the infringement at issue has
concerned only Northern Ireland. However, it is the United Kingdom’s authorities and not those of Northern Ireland,
which are responsible for the proper application of EU law in Northern Ireland. Therefore, the fact that, since 1
February 2020, the United Kingdom is no longer a Member State is irrelevant for the assessment of its ability to pay,
with the result that it is not appropriate to treat it differently from the Member States in that regard.
Moreover, a penalty imposed on the United Kingdom calculated taking into account only the gross domestic
product (GDP) of Northern Ireland, as regards the continuation of the infringement after the end of the
transition period, would not be sufficiently dissuasive and therefore would not make it possible to achieve
the aim of effectively preventing the repetition of similar infringements of EU law in the future.
Furthermore, given that, since the end of the transition period, EU law no longer applies in the United
Kingdom except in respect of Northern Ireland is a mitigating circumstance which plays a role in the
assessment of the seriousness of the infringement, there is no reason to take that factor into account once
again as regards the United Kingdom’s ability to pay.
According to the Court, it is therefore appropriate to take into account the GDP of the United Kingdom as a
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
whole for the entire period of the infringement for the purpose of determining its ability to pay, with account
being taken of recent trends in that GDP.
NOTE: An action for failure to fulfil obligations directed against a Member State which has failed to comply with its
obligations under EU law may be brought by the Commission or by another Member State. If the Court of Justice
finds that there has been a failure to fulfil obligations, the Member State concerned must comply with the Court’s
judgment without delay.
Where the Commission considers that the Member State has not complied with the judgment, it may bring a further
action seeking financial penalties. However, if measures transposing a directive have not been notified to the
Commission, the Court of Justice can, on a proposal from the Commission, impose penalties at the stage of the
initial judgment.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice.
The full text and, as the case may be, the abstract are published on the CURIA website on the day of delivery.
Stay Connected!
Communications Directorate
Trending
- Intelligenza artificiale, allarme di BCE e Federal Reserve: attacchi informatici, trading automatizzato e rischi di crisi finanziaria
- Libia, le maggiori riserve petrolifere dell’Africa non bastano ad attirare le grandi compagnie occidentali: instabilità e tensioni politiche frenano gli investimenti
- FIORE (FN): “È ORA DI PORTARE LA LUCE NEL PORTO DELLE NEBBIE
- Sp 30 ‘Sant’Angelo-Montelabbate’, mercoledì 18 novembre lavori di Marche Multiservizi in fascia notturna
- Data center sottomarini, la nuova frontiera dell’intelligenza artificiale divide il mondo: meno consumi sulla terraferma, ma crescono le proteste per la tutela degli oceani
- Energia nucleare, l’Asia guida il 73% delle nuove centrali mondiali: Cina, India, Giappone e Corea del Sud accelerano la transizione energetica
- Stati Uniti, allarme dell’intelligence su possibili attacchi iraniani a Washington: nel mirino funzionari di Trump, ipotesi bomba sporca e armi chimiche
- Capo Verde, José Maria Neves rieletto presidente con il 64% dei voti: netta vittoria su Joana Rosa, ma preoccupa la bassa affluenza
- Stati Uniti, guasto tecnico a JPMorgan Chase provoca disservizi bancari a livello nazionale: rallentamenti nei pagamenti e problemi con Zelle
- Nero su Bianco – Sunay Akin
