(AGENPARL) - Roma, 21 Dicembre 2023 - (AGENPARL) – gio 21 dicembre 2023 PRESS RELEASE No 210/23
Luxembourg, 21 December 2023
Judgment of the Court in Case C-297/22 P | United Parcel Service v Commission
Termination of the UPS-TNT merger agreement: the irregularity committed
by the Commission is not the determining cause of UPS’ alleged loss of
profit and therefore cannot justify a compensation payment
By deciding not to go ahead with acquiring TNT as soon as the decision at issue was announced, UPS broke the
causal link between the Commission’s infringement and the alleged damage
In 2013 1, the Commission declared a notified concentration between UPS and TNT, two undertakings specialising in
the express delivery of small packages, to be incompatible with the internal market. While announcing publicly that
it would not go ahead with that concentration, UPS brought an action before the General Court seeking the
annulment of the Commission decision. By judgment of 7 March 2017 2, the General Court upheld that action and,
by judgment of 16 January 2019 3, the Court of Justice dismissed the appeal brought by the Commission against the
General Court judgment. In the meantime, the Commission declared a concentration between TNT and FedEx, a
competitor of UPS, to be compatible with the internal market 4.
In late 2017, UPS brought an action for damages against the Commission seeking compensation for the economic
losses allegedly suffered due to the unlawfulness of the incompatibility decision adopted in 2013. Those losses
included the costs associated with its participation in the procedure for the control of the concentration between
FedEx and TNT, the payment to TNT of a contractual termination fee following the cancellation of the merger
agreement concluded with TNT, and loss of profit resulting from the fact that it was impossible to implement that
merger agreement. The General Court dismissed that action in February 2022 5.
UPS requests that the Court of Justice set aside the 2022 judgment of the General Court.
By its judgment delivered today, the Court of Justice dismisses UPS’ appeal.
First, the Court of Justice observes that, by disputing the circumstances in which the merger agreement concluded
with TNT was terminated, UPS does not call into question the General Court’s legal reasoning, but rather the factual
assessment made by that court. However, unless the facts have been distorted, which has not been demonstrated
in the present case, the appeal procedure does not allow the facts as established by the General Court to be
disputed.
Second, the Court of Justice confirms that the payment of the termination fee stemmed from a contractual
obligation which was included in the merger agreement. In so doing, the parties to the agreement together took on
the risk that the proposed transaction would not obtain prior approval from the Commission. However, the
harmful consequences of contractual commitments freely consented to by the addressee of a Commission decision
cannot constitute the determining cause of the damage suffered as a result of illegalities vitiating that decision.
Lastly, the Court of Justice finds that the General Court correctly established that there was no causal link in
relation to the three separate types of damage alleged; therefore, UPS’ action for damages, which is required to
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
demonstrate the existence of such a link, cannot in any way succeed.
NOTE: An appeal, on a point or points of law only, may be brought before the Court of Justice against a judgment or
order of the General Court. In principle, the appeal does not have suspensive effect. If the appeal is admissible and
well founded, the Court of Justice sets aside the judgment of the General Court. Where the state of the proceedings
so permits, the Court of Justice may itself give final judgment in the case. Otherwise, it refers the case back to the
General Court, which is bound by the decision given by the Court of Justice on the appeal.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice.
The full text and, as the case may be, the abstract of the judgment are published on the CURIA website on the day of
delivery.
Stay Connected!
Commission Decision C(2013) 431 of 30 January 2013 declaring a concentration incompatible with the internal market and the functioning of the
EEA Agreement (Case COMP/M.6570 – UPS/TNT Express); see also Commission press release IP/13/68.
Judgment of the General Court of 7 March 2017, United Parcel Service v Commission, T-194/13 (see also CP No 23/17).
Judgment of the Court of Justice of 16 January 2019, Commission v United Parcel Service, C-265/17 P (see also CP No 3/19).
Decision of 8 January 2016 declaring a concentration compatible with the internal market and the functioning of the EEA Agreement (Case M.7630 –
FedEx/TNT Express), a summary of which has been published in the Official Journal of the European Union.
Judgment of the General Court of 23 February 2022, United Parcel Service v Commission, T?834/17 (see also CP No 34/22).
Communications Directorate
Trending
- Lollobrigida: “Grazie Carabinieri e Procura di Trani per operazione traffico mezzi agricoli. Tutelare imprese contro illegalità”
- ZES Unica, Caltanissetta davanti alla sfida degli investimenti: incentivi fino al 60%, ma soltanto tre autorizzazioni e 10 posti di lavoro previsti
- Guerra ibrida, Mulè (FI): da governo Conte più grande investimento sugli F-35, ora M5S sia coerente
- +++I GIUDICI LUCA ANTONINI E STEFANO PETITTI VICEPRESIDENTI DELLA CORTE COSTITUZIONALE +++
- ONU, l’Argentina di Milei tra i sei astenuti sul testo contro la violenza sulle donne: 175 sì
- Piemonte: Il diritto allo studio: una garanzia irrinunciabile per la libertà e la dignità di ogni minore
- Sconvocata la seduta della commissione COVID di oggi
- AGRICOLTURA, RUSSO (FdI): “INCHIESTA SU BLOCCHI TRATTORI SVELA UNA VICENDA BEN DIVERSA DA QUELLA NARRATA DALLA SINISTRA. A PAGARNE IL PREZZO I CONSUMATORI”
- Venezuela, il ministro della Difesa precisa le condizioni dell’intesa con gli USA: sovranità e comando militare restano nazionali
- L’avvocato generale Szpunar esamina la compatibilità con il diritto dell’Unione della normativa belga che rafforza la remunerazione degli editori di pubblicazioni giornalistiche, degli autori e degli artisti-interpreti per l’utilizzo dei loro contenuti online.
