(AGENPARL) - Roma, 13 Ottobre 2023 - (AGENPARL) – ven 13 ottobre 2023 PRELIMINARY
ASSESSMENT
VOTING AND RESULTS
REPORTING
2023 GENERAL ELECTION
2 I Preliminary Assessment – Voting and Results Reporting 2023 General Election
As planned, the official results have now been posted to the Elections Manitoba (EM)
website. In addition to the summary results provided on election night, results are now
provided by voting area. The institutional votes that were counted after election day
and a few small, remote and northern communities which faced weather and flight
challenges are also reported in the official results.
Official results are posted following the final tally process which reviews the counts from election night.
A few numbers:
• 488,979 Manitobans voted out of 884,853 eligible voters, 55% turnout
• 80% increase in advance voting
• 97% of results were reported on election night
As you know we faced several issues on election day and election night reporting: the stormy weather that
knocked out power at some polling stations, firewall issues with our website and the learning curve associated
with the introduction of new processes and technology in the field. Here’s a quick look at a few key areas:
Website
Our website faced challenges from the start of voting on election day and throughout the day, and those challenges
continued as election night results were being reported. There had been considerable work internally and with
external experts to review and protect our digital systems as it is known that elections are a target for malicious
players. Despite this work and testing, a firewall went down, and our systems had to be rebuilt and redeployed
on election day. We are engaging external subject-matter experts to determine what exactly happened and what
additional steps are needed to protect the site in future. The website issues are a serious matter that must be fully
reviewed and addressed.
It is worth noting that at no time were vote counting machines or voting results compromised. We can reassure
all Manitobans that the issues we experienced with our website did not affect the integrity of the election. Vote
counting machines feature many levels of security to maintain the integrity of voting. For example, voting machines
are not connected to the Internet and each machine goes through rigorous testing to ensure they are in proper
working order. Despite this, the delays we experienced were inconvenient and regrettable, and we are working
diligently to address them.
Preliminary Assessment – Voting and Results Reporting 2023 General Election I 3
Voting
EM had three types of service delivery for advance voting and election day: full technology with a computer
system and vote counting machine; computer system with manual counting; and traditional manual polls in
smaller locations. For all three models, the focus is delivering uninterrupted services to voters. We build in
contingency plans to respond to any issues that arise.
One of the contingency plans involved using an auxiliary ballot box should a vote counting machine be inoperable or
another problem arose such as a power failure. Voters could continue to vote, and their ballot securely placed in the
auxiliary ballot box. For both advance voting and election day voting, the auxiliary boxes were used far more than
anticipated, and resulted in more manual counting than had been anticipated, which takes more time.
Counting and Reporting
Election Day
A large and long-lasting storm started election day with power outages and some delays. Voting proceeded across
the province until the close of polls at 8:00 PM. At that point election day counting began. This consisted of:
ploading the advance voting results from vote counting machines to EM’s result reporting system.
unning the results tape from the vote counting machine in each election day polling location and entering
the results into the EM laptop, or in a few cases calling in the results to the local election office.
• E ntering in the results from all manual counts of election day and advance voting.
anual counting of the auxiliary boxes from both election day and advance voting and entering these
numbers into the results system. This manual process affected more polling places than anticipated,
largely due to the storm.
n election night 97% of the results were in and reported.
ur website experienced service disruptions on election day, which at one point led to intermittent
problems including an approximate 30-minute delay in results being updated on election night.
Advance Voting – Reporting
There was an 80% increase in advance voting – a significant uptake from voters. For reference, counting this volume
of advance votes by hand would have taken until approximately 3:00 am before results would have been reported.
The unexpected increase in using the auxiliary ballot boxes for advance voting did increase manual counts. The use
of auxiliary boxes was largely a result of staff getting used to using new technology and processes. While those
issues were sorted, voting continued using auxiliary boxes. On the evening of September 27th, we did run a number
of these advance ballots through the vote counting machines, but there remained a number of ballots that needed
to be hand counted.
4 I Preliminary Assessment – Voting and Results Reporting 2023 General Election
A key learning for us this election concerned the reporting of advance non-resident votes. Each electoral division
had to tabulate and report the non-resident votes (those who voted early outside their home electoral division)
from each of the other 56 electoral divisions. These results were reported separately for the first time this year. In
some cases, there were zero non-resident votes to count. For example, the Agassiz electoral division received zero
non-resident votes from the St. Vital electoral division. In those cases, zeroes should have been entered, which would
have displayed results as counted on our website. Unfortunately, in some cases those fields were blank, which meant
the system appeared to show some non-resident votes were yet to be counted when in fact there were zero votes to
count. We are now examining ways to eliminate this procedural error for future elections.
We could have made this process clearer to the public, candidates and parties as we worked through confirming
the zero counts. Results matter and we take the time needed to ensure accuracy, and it does indeed take
considerable time.
New Processes and New Technology
The introduction of new technology and processes affected voting officials very directly. As in previous elections,
we have some take-aways on training and streamlining processes to make it easier to deliver services. We will be
consulting with staff in the weeks ahead to gather more ideas and suggestions.
Initial observations suggest that more technology be used, particularly for print-on-demand ballot printers
and to look at the processes that speed up service. We expect to hear more as we work through our debriefs
and assessments.
Official Results/Declaration of Candidate Timing
In this election we allocated 10 days, as compared to seven days, for the final tally for two reasons. One was to
acknowledge the Thanksgiving weekend and allow staff to take a bit of time off. The timeline was discussed and
agreed to by Advisory Committee members and was noted in the Notice of Election posted in all local election
offices. The other was a take-away from the 2019 general election. With a permanent voters list, we can update
voter information during voting and during final tally. In 2019, we learned that updating voter information and
ensuring voters who voted are struck from the list took longer than anticipated but is still a worthwhile effort to
ensure the final voters list is current, complete and accurate. Before the permanent voters list, this type of work
didn’t occur until after the official results were declared. With technology, we can do it more immediately and
therefore more accurately, but that does require more time during the final tally process.
Preliminary Assessment – Voting and Results Reporting 2023 General Election I 5
Process Audits
EM decided to take the initiative to conduct three process audits on October 11 and 12 in the electoral divisions
of Waverley, Lagimodiere and Brandon West, which had the lowest pluralities. While all ballots in these electoral
divisions were manually counted, it was not a formal recount. We wanted to check how our new processes
performed, particularly the accuracy of the vote counting machines. Scrutineers and candidates from the parties
involved in each of the electoral divisions were invited to witness the process, and approximately 12 scrutineers
watched the three audit processes.
As a result of the review, there were minor changes in numbers, which is not unusual. The elected candidate in
each electoral division did not change.
Next Steps
Elections Manitoba will prepare a statement of votes, the annual report and be ready to appear before the
all-party Legislative Affairs Standing Committee following the tabling of the annual report, or when determined
by the committee. Those reports will reflect the continued analysis and review the organization will undertake
in the months ahead, and include any recommendations for changes or updates.
Elections Manitoba is committed to transparency in reporting results and reporting on the activities of the
organization. This does require time and careful attention to detail to ensure the work is done correctly.
As an organization, Elections Manitoba will continue to listen and learn to better serve Manitobans.
We are confident that the election was free and fair. We thank Manitobans for their participation in the
general election.
Trending
- Confcommercio Venezia, celebrati gli 80 anni dalla fondazione. A Mestre una cerimonia per ripercorrere la storia dell’associazio
- Domani alla Camera conferenza «Ora, lege et labora. Una regola civile per l’era dell’Intelligenza Artificiale»
- Domani la presentazione dell’ultima tappa del progetto “Diario veneziano
- VENEZUELA, BERGAMINI (FI): BENE LIBERAZIONE ECHENAGUCIA, AVANTI CON TRANSIZIONE DEMOCRATICA
- CS POLITICA ATESSA, LA NOTA FDI
- [INGV Comunicato stampa] 90 anni dalla fondazione dell’Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica: la visione di Guglielmo Marconi alle origini di una grande storia scientifica
- Domani la presentazione del progetto “Gli abiti di Silvia” a favore di Avapo
- VVF Incendio struttura
- COMUNICATO STAMPA – Bagheria servizio coordinato di controllo del territorio – un arresto per spaccio e due denunce da parte dei carabinieri.doc
- FICO INIZIA LE BONIFICHE AD AILANO: VITTORIA DI FORZA NUOVA