(AGENPARL) - Roma, 1 Agosto 2025 - (AGENPARL) – Fri 01 August 2025 PRESS RELEASE No 104/25
Luxembourg, 1 August 2025
Judgment of the Court in Case C-600/23 | Royal Football Club Seraing
Football: the Court affirms the right, for clubs and players in particular, to
obtain effective judicial review of arbitral awards made by the Court of
Arbitration for Sport
The courts or tribunals of the Member States must be able to carry out an in-depth review of those awards for
consistency with the fundamental rules of EU law
In the field of football, as in many other sports, the submission of disputes to arbitration is generally not freely
accepted but unilaterally imposed on athletes and on clubs by international associations, such as the Fédération
internationale de football association (FIFA).
In those circumstances, it is essential that recourse to arbitration does not undermine the rights and freedoms that
the fundamental rules of EU law guarantee athletes, clubs and, more broadly, any other person practising a
professional sport or pursuing an economic activity linked to that sport. On those grounds, the Court of Justice rules
today that the national courts or tribunals must be empowered to carry out, at the request of individuals or of the
court’s or tribunal’s own motion, an in-depth judicial review as to whether arbitral awards made by the Court of
Arbitration for Sport (the CAS) are consistent with EU public policy.
Furthermore, if national legislation or rules of a sports association prevent the national courts or tribunals from
exercising their powers, those courts or tribunals are required to disapply that legislation or those rules.
In 2015, a Belgian club, Royal Football Club Seraing (RFC Seraing), concluded financing agreements with the Maltese
company Doyen Sports; those agreements provided for the transfer to that company of a part of the economic
rights of some of RFC Seraing ‘s players. Finding that that type of contract was in breach of the prohibition on third
parties holding players’ economic rights, FIFA imposed a number of sanctions on the club, namely a prohibition on
the registration of new players during several periods as well as a fine. Those sanctions were upheld by the CAS,
which is the global body for dispute resolution in the field of sports, and subsequently by the Swiss Federal Supreme
Court.
Challenging the compatibility of the FIFA rules with EU law, RFC Seraing then brought the case before the Belgian
courts. The court of first instance and the court of appeal found that the award made by the CAS was final and had
the authority of res judicata, and that, therefore, they could not carry out a fresh assessment of that question of
compatibility. Seised of the case, the Belgian Court of Cassation decided to refer a question to the Court of Justice
for a preliminary ruling. It asks, in essence, whether, having regard to EU law, the national courts or tribunals may be
prevented, pursuant to the principle of the authority of res judicata, from reviewing an arbitral award made by the
CAS and upheld by the Swiss Federal Supreme Court, namely a court of a third country that does not have the
option open to it of referring a question to the Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling.
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
The Court of Justice holds that national rules granting the authority of res judicata such a scope are contrary to EU
law. The application of rules of this kind deprives individuals of the possibility of obtaining, from the courts or
tribunals of the Member States, effective judicial review of such arbitral awards.
More specifically, the Court recalls, first of all, that recourse to arbitration by individuals is in principle possible,
adding, nevertheless, that if that arbitration is to be implemented within the European Union, it is necessary to
ensure that it is compatible with the judicial architecture of the European Union and that it is consistent with EU
public policy.
Next, the Court finds that, in the present case, the CAS award was made pursuant to an arbitration mechanism that
was unilaterally imposed by an international sports association (FIFA), as is often the case in sports-related disputes.
For that reason, the Court rules that, in order to ensure effective judicial protection for athletes, clubs and other
individuals who might be affected as a result of pursuing a sports-related economic activity within the European
Union, the awards made by the CAS must be amenable to effective judicial review. Thus, even though it may
legitimately be limited in order to take account of the specific features of arbitration, that review must in any event
allow individuals to obtain in-depth judicial review as to whether those awards are consistent with the
principles and provisions of EU public policy. Furthermore, the possibility must exist to obtain interim relief and
to have a reference made to the Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling.
Lastly, where an infringement of the competition rules or of a freedom of movement is at issue, the individuals
concerned must be able to request those courts or tribunals not only to find that that infringement exists and to
order damages for the harm caused to them, but also to bring to an end the conduct amounting to that
infringement.
Furthermore, the Court adds that a national court or tribunal is required to disapply of its own motion any
national legislation or rules of a sports association that would hinder such effective judicial protection as
regards individuals.
NOTE: A reference for a preliminary ruling allows there courts and tribunals of the Member States, in disputes
which have been brought before them, to refer questions to the Court of Justice about the interpretation of
European Union law or the validity of a European Union act. The Court of Justice does not decide the dispute itself. It
is for the national court or tribunal to dispose of the case in accordance with the Court’s decision, which is similarly
binding on other national courts or tribunals before which a similar issue is raised.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice.
The full text, and, as the case may be, an abstract of the judgment are published on the CURIA website on the day of
delivery.
You will find here an explanatory video on the judgment from the Court of Justice of the European Union.
Stay Connected!
Communications Directorate
Trending
- Medioetruria, Giani sacrifica sviluppo territori su altare scontro politico
- CORRI LIBERA, RAUTI: LA DIFESA PER LA CULTURA DEL RISPETTO DONNE
- LUCA ZINGARETTI IN VISITA ALLA MOSTRA DI PALAZZO DEI DIAMANTI. UN RITORNO NELLA CITTÀ DEL SUO ESORDIO AL CINEMA. L’ATTORE IN QUESTI GIORNI A FERRARA PER “MARCO POLO E LE CITTÀ INVISIBILI”, IN SCENA AL TEATRO COMUNALE
- MANOVRA: BERGAMINI, “FORZA ITALIA LAVORA PER MIGLIORARLA, IL CAMPO LARGO PENSA A NUOVE TASSE
- GIORNATA VITTIME STRADA. DE CORATO (FDI): SICUREZZA È PRIORITÀ PER GOVERNO MELONI
- Le Commissioni consiliari di lunedì 16 novembre
- Emergenza abitativa, lunedì a Forlì il convegno sul Piano Casa. Tassinari «Più garanzie ai proprietari per rimettere in affitto le case sfitte»
- FERRARA, FABBRI SECONDO TRA I SINDACI DEI COMUNI TRA 120MILA E 260MILA ABITANTI CON IL 58,5% DI GRADIMENTO SECONDO IL SONDAGGIO LAB21. SINDACO: “UN RISULTATO CHE MI RENDE FELICE. IL CONSENSO VA CONQUISTATO OGNI GIORNO
- Domenica ecologica, oltre mille alberi e piantine donati ai cittadini al Parco San Giuliano
- MANIFESTAZIONI A PARMA, RUSSO (FDI): GRAZIE A FORZE DELL’ORDINE, SMENTITA LA NARRAZIONE DI UN GOVERNO CHE REPRIME IL DISSENSO
