(AGENPARL) - Roma, 24 Ottobre 2024 - (AGENPARL) – gio 24 ottobre 2024 PRESS RELEASE No 184/24
Luxembourg, 24 October 2024
Judgment of the Court in Case C-227/23 | Kwantum Nederland and Kwantum België
Intellectual property: Member States are required to protect works of art
in the European Union, irrespective of the country of origin of those works
or the nationality of their author
Vitra, a Swiss company that manufactures designer furniture, holds intellectual property rights over chairs designed
by the since-deceased spouses, Charles and Ray Eames, who were nationals of the United States of America. That
furniture included the Dining Sidechair Wood, which was created as part of a furniture design competition organised
by the Museum of Modern Art in New York (United States) and exhibited in that museum from 1950.
The company Kwantum, which operates a chain of interior furnishing shops in the Netherlands and in Belgium,
marketed a chair called the ‘Paris chair’, allegedly in breach of Vitra’s copyright in the Dining Sidechair Wood. Vitra
brought proceedings before the Netherlands courts with the aim, inter alia, of putting an end to that marketing. In
that context, the Supreme Court of the Netherlands decided to refer questions to the Court of Justice for a
preliminary ruling relating to the protection which, under Directive 2001/29
and Article 17(2) and Article 52(1) of
the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (‘the Charter’), may be granted in the European Union to a
work of applied art originating in a third country and the author of which is not a national of a Member State.
In international law, the Berne Convention 2 provides that authors who are nationals of the signatory countries
enjoy in the other signatory countries, in principle, the same rights as national authors. However, the protection of
works of applied art constitutes an exception to that principle. In that regard, the contracting parties have laid down
a material reciprocity clause according to which works of applied art originating in countries in which such works are
protected solely as designs and models are not entitled, in the other signatory countries, to such protection in
addition to copyright protection.
In this respect, the question referred to the Court of Justice by the Supreme Court of the Netherlands seeks to
ascertain whether the Member States are still free to apply the material reciprocity clause contained in the Berne
Convention to works of applied art originating in third countries which protect those works solely under a special
regime, even though the EU legislature has not provided for such a limitation.
In its judgment, the Court of Justice answers in the negative: within the scope of Directive 2001/29, the
Member States are no longer competent to implement the relevant stipulations of the Berne Convention.
First of all, the Court clarifies in that regard that a situation in which a company claims copyright protection for a
subject matter of applied art marketed in a Member State, provided that such subject matter may be classified as a
‘work’ within the meaning of Directive 2001/29, falls within the material scope of EU law.
Next, the Court finds that the EU legislature, in adopting that directive, necessarily took into account all the works
for which protection is sought in the territory of the European Union; moreover, that directive does not lay down
any criterion relating to the country of origin of those works or to the nationality of their author. The Court adds that
the application of the material reciprocity clause contained in the Berne Convention would undermine the objective
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
of Directive 2001/29, which consists in the harmonisation of copyright in the internal market, since, under that
clause, works of applied art originating in third countries might be treated differently in different Member States.
Lastly, the Court points out that, since the intellectual property rights in question are protected under Article 17(2) of
the Charter, any limitation of those rights must, in accordance with Article 52(1) of the Charter, be provided for by
law. It is for the EU legislature alone to determine whether the grant in the European Union of the rights laid down
in Directive 2001/29 should be limited.
In those circumstances, a Member State cannot rely on the Berne Convention in order to exempt itself from the
obligations arising from that directive.
Therefore, a Member State may not, by way of derogation from the provisions of EU law, apply the material
reciprocity clause contained in the Berne Convention in respect of a work the country of origin of which is
the United States of America.
NOTE: A reference for a preliminary ruling allows the courts and tribunals of the Member States, in disputes which
have been brought before them, to refer questions to the Court of Justice about the interpretation of European
Union law or the validity of a European Union act. The Court of Justice does not decide the dispute itself. It is for the
national court or tribunal to dispose of the case in accordance with the Court’s decision, which is similarly binding on
other national courts or tribunals before which a similar issue is raised.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice.
The full text and, as the case may be, the abstract of the judgment is published on the CURIA website on the day of
delivery.
Stay Connected!
Directive 2001/29/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 22 May 2001 on the harmonisation of certain aspects of copyright and
related rights in the information society.
Convention signed in Berne on 9 September 1886 (Paris Act of 24 July 1971), as amended on 28 September 1979.
Communications Directorate
Trending
- Piemonte: Il diritto allo studio: una garanzia irrinunciabile per la libertà e la dignità di ogni minore
- Sconvocata la seduta della commissione COVID di oggi
- AGRICOLTURA, RUSSO (FdI): “INCHIESTA SU BLOCCHI TRATTORI SVELA UNA VICENDA BEN DIVERSA DA QUELLA NARRATA DALLA SINISTRA. A PAGARNE IL PREZZO I CONSUMATORI”
- Venezuela, il ministro della Difesa precisa le condizioni dell’intesa con gli USA: sovranità e comando militare restano nazionali
- L’avvocato generale Szpunar esamina la compatibilità con il diritto dell’Unione della normativa belga che rafforza la remunerazione degli editori di pubblicazioni giornalistiche, degli autori e degli artisti-interpreti per l’utilizzo dei loro contenuti online.
- CYBERSICUREZZA, PEREGO (DIFESA): M5S, NECESSARIO FARE CHIAREZZA SUGLI INVESTIMENTI. I DATI SONO PUBBLICI E VERIFICABILI
- DL SCUOLA, PIRONDINI (M5S) A FAZZOLARI: STUPISCE NO FDI A GRATUITÀ LIBRI
- Scuola, Amorese (FdI): Libri digitali a metà prezzo, svolta concreta per famiglie e studenti
- Dl Ambiente: Siracusano, ok emendamento poteri speciali per bonifica Zona Falcata Messina
- Comunicato Stampa 2037/2026 La scuola di Sanità Pubblica avvia corso sulle mutilazioni genitali femminili. Roma, “Un approccio formativo multidisciplinare che coniughi tutela dei diritti, rispetto, dialogo interculturale
