(AGENPARL) - Roma, 20 Dicembre 2023 - (AGENPARL) – mer 20 dicembre 2023 PRESS RELEASE No 197/23
Luxembourg, 20 December 2023
Judgments of the General Court in Cases T-53/21 | EVH, T-55/21 | Stadtwerke Leipzig, T-56/21 | TEAG, T58/21 | Stadtwerke Hameln Weserbergland, T-59/21 | eins energie in sachsen, T-60/21 | Naturstrom, T61/21 | EnergieVerbund Dresden, T-62/21 | GGEW, T-63/21 | Stadtwerke Frankfurt am Main, T-64/21 |
Mainova and T-65/21 | enercity v Commission
The actions of 11 German municipal authorities against the Commission’s
approval of the acquisition of the distribution and retail energy business
as well as some generation assets of Innogy by E.ON are dismissed
The Commission did not make any manifest errors in its assessment of the compatibility of that concentration,
which is part of a complex asset swap between RWE and E.ON, with EU competition law
In March 2018, the companies RWE AG and E.ON SE, both governed by German law, announced that they wanted to
engage in a complex asset swap by means of three concentration operations.
By the first concentration operation, RWE, which is active across the whole supply chain of energy provision in
several European countries, wished to acquire sole or joint control over certain generation assets of E.ON, an
electricity provider which operates in several European countries. The second concentration operation consisted in
the acquisition by E.ON of the sole control over the distribution and retail energy business, as well as some
generation assets of Innogy SE, a subsidiary of RWE. As for the third concentration operation, it concerned the
acquisition of 16.67% of E.ON’s shares by RWE.
The first and second concentration operations were reviewed by the European Commission 1, who approved them,
while the third concentration operation was reviewed by the Federal Competition Authority, Germany.
Eleven German municipal authorities challenged the Commission’s approval decisions before the General Court of
the European Union.
On 17 May 2023, the General Court dismissed the actions challenging the approval of the first operation (acquisition
of generation assets of E.ON by RWE), some on the substance and others on grounds of inadmissibility. The General
Court observed that an asset swap between independent undertakings does not constitute a ‘single concentration’.
It also held that the Commission did not make any manifest errors in its assessment of the compatibility of that first
concentration with EU competition law 2.
By its judgments of today, the General Court dismisses the actions of the municipal authorities challenging
the approval of the second operation (acquisition of the distribution and retail energy business as well as
some generation assets of Innogy by E.ON). The General Court confirms that an asset swap between independent
undertakings does not constitute a ‘single concentration’. Nor did the Commission make any manifest errors in its
assessment of the compatibility of that second concentration with EU competition law.
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
NOTE : An action for annulment seeks the annulment of acts of the institutions of the European Union that are
contrary to European Union law. The Member States, the European institutions and individuals may, under certain
conditions, bring an action for annulment before the Court of Justice or the General Court. If the action is well
founded, the act is annulled. The institution concerned must fill any legal vacuum created by the annulment of the
NOTE : An appeal, limited to points of law only, may be brought before the Court of Justice against the decision of
the General Court within two months and ten days of notification of the decision.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the General Court.
The full text of the judgments and, where applicable, the summary of the judgments (T-53/21, T-55/21, T-56/21, T58/21, T-59/21, T-60/21, T-61/21, T-62/21, T-63/21, T-64/21 and T-65/21) are published on the CURIA website on the
day of delivery.
Stay connected!
See Commission press releases IP/19/1432 and IP/19/5582.
See press releases No’s 81/23 and 82/23. Nine of municipal authorities lodged appeals against the judgments of 17 May 2023 concerning them,
namely EVH (C-464/23 P), Stadtwerke Leipzig (C-465/23 P), Stadtwerke Hameln Weserbergland (C-466/23 P), TEAG (C-467/23 P), EnergieVerbund
Dresden (C-468/23 P), eins energie in sachsen (C-469/23 P), GGEW (C-470/23 P), Mainova (C-484/23 P) and enercity (C-485/23 P). Those appeals are
pending before the Court of Justice. For an overview of all of the cases, see the table below.
Applicant municipal
authority
Appeal before the Court of
Action before the
Action before the General
Justice against the judgments
General Court
Court concerning the
of the General Court relating
concerning the first
second concentration
to the first concentration
concentration operation
operation
operation
T-312/20
C-464/23 P
T-53/21
Stadtwerke Leipzig
T-313/20
C-465/23 P
T-55/21
Stadtwerke Hameln
T-314/20
C-466/23 P
T-58/21
T-315/20
C-467/23 P
T-56/21
Naturstrom
T-316/20
T-60/21
EnergieVerbund Dresden
T-317/20
C-468/23 P
T-61/21
eins energie in sachsen
T-318/20
C-469/23 P
T-59/21
T-319/20
C-470/23 P
T-62/21
Mainova
T-320/20
C-484/23 P
T-64/21
enercity
T-321/20
C-485/23 P
T-65/21
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
Stadtwerke Frankfurt am
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
T-322/20
T-63/21
curia.europa.eu
Trending
- AGRICOLTURA, RUSSO (FdI): “INCHIESTA SU BLOCCHI TRATTORI SVELA UNA VICENDA BEN DIVERSA DA QUELLA NARRATA DALLA SINISTRA. A PAGARNE IL PREZZO I CONSUMATORI”
- Venezuela, il ministro della Difesa precisa le condizioni dell’intesa con gli USA: sovranità e comando militare restano nazionali
- L’avvocato generale Szpunar esamina la compatibilità con il diritto dell’Unione della normativa belga che rafforza la remunerazione degli editori di pubblicazioni giornalistiche, degli autori e degli artisti-interpreti per l’utilizzo dei loro contenuti online.
- CYBERSICUREZZA, PEREGO (DIFESA): M5S, NECESSARIO FARE CHIAREZZA SUGLI INVESTIMENTI. I DATI SONO PUBBLICI E VERIFICABILI
- DL SCUOLA, PIRONDINI (M5S) A FAZZOLARI: STUPISCE NO FDI A GRATUITÀ LIBRI
- Scuola, Amorese (FdI): Libri digitali a metà prezzo, svolta concreta per famiglie e studenti
- Dl Ambiente: Siracusano, ok emendamento poteri speciali per bonifica Zona Falcata Messina
- Comunicato Stampa 2037/2026 La scuola di Sanità Pubblica avvia corso sulle mutilazioni genitali femminili. Roma, “Un approccio formativo multidisciplinare che coniughi tutela dei diritti, rispetto, dialogo interculturale
- Ucraina, Formentini (Lega): sconvolgente Salvini in lista proscrizione, promuovere diplomazia non è colpa
- Covid: Girelli (Pd), appello scienziati conferma nostre preoccupazioni, Meloni fermi deriva no vax della Commissione
