(AGENPARL) - Roma, 23 Novembre 2023 - (AGENPARL) – gio 23 novembre 2023 The cost of not issuing a digital euro
Speech by Fabio Panetta
Governor of Banca d’Italia
CEPR-ECB Conference
The macroeconomic implications of central bank digital currencies
Frankfurt am Main, 23 November 2023
It is a pleasure to be with you today to discuss the implications of central bank digital
currencies (CBDCs) from a macroeconomic and policy perspective.
I am sure there will be a lot of discussion at the conference about what we can expect
if CBDCs are issued. So let me focus on the counterfactual – the consequences of not
issuing CBDCs – using the digital euro as a case study. Therefore today I will highlight the
costs of not issuing a digital euro.1
Throughout history, monetary transformations have been the result of a dynamic
interplay between technological progress, changing human preferences and institutional
evolution.
In the early Renaissance, commerce and financial innovation flourished in the Italian
city-states. The introduction of letters of exchange and correspondent banking freed
merchants from the perils of transporting cumbersome gold and silver coins and
promoted secure methods of payment which, in turn, facilitated international trade. The
substantial wealth of the Italian city-states could then be used as the foundation for the
splendour of the Italian Renaissance.2
Today, we are once again at a pivotal point in the evolution of money. The economic
landscape is changing in unprecedented ways. Digital innovation has ushered in a new
age with the potential to unlock enormous opportunities. These changes inevitably affect
payments and money, which are becoming as digital as our economies.
Central banks around the world are preparing for this new digital era, recognising both
the opportunities and the challenges it brings. They are actively exploring the potential
This counterfactual approach was famously employed in the Cecchini report, which made the case
for the Single Market by assessing the ‘cost of non-Europe’, defined as the untapped potential of the
European internal market due to its incomplete integration. See Cecchini, P., Catinat, M., Jacquemin, A.
(1988). ‘The Benefits of a Single Market’, Wildwood House.
Ferguson, N. (2009), ‘The Ascent of Money: A Financial History of the World’, 10th Anniversary Edition.
of issuing a digital payment instrument alongside cash as a logical next step in the
evolution of central bank money. According to a BIS survey3, in 2022, out of a pool of 86
surveyed central banks, 80 (or 93 per cent) engaged in some form of CBDC work, ranging
from research and proof of concept to pilots and also live CBDCs. The European Central
Bank is one of these, as the Governing Council of the ECB has recently decided to launch
the preparation phase of the digital euro project.4
Central banks have long provided reliable means of payment as a public good and an
anchor of stability for the financial and monetary system. Why should they not do the
same in the digital age and be the only ones not to offer a digital version of their product?
But there are sceptics today who claim that issuing CBDCs would be fruitless. Some
believe that a digital euro may not be successful enough; many ask what specific benefits
it could offer that existing payment methods do not already provide. At the same time,
others fear that a digital euro could be too successful and create instability by potentially
challenging traditional bank deposits.
These opposing concerns deserve close attention, and clear responses.
A digital euro would be a digital form of cash that could be used for all digital payments
throughout the euro area, free of charge, both online and offline. It would offer the
highest level of privacy by default and allow users to settle payments instantly in central
bank money. It could be used for person-to-person (P2P), point-of-sale, e-commerce and
government payments. No existing digital payment instrument offers all these features.
The digital euro would fill this gap. And its design features would prevent its introduction
from triggering financial tensions and provide appropriate incentives for all parties
involved. It would contribute to financial inclusion while fostering integration, innovation
and resilience in the European payments market.
But above all, the concerns that are sometimes expressed also tend to overlook a crucial
consideration.
Assessing the prospective advantages and disadvantages of CBDCs on the assumption
that the payments landscape will not change in the future can be misleading. To do
so would be to ignore the fact that our 21st century economies are in a state of flux, as
evidenced by the multiple technological shocks hitting many sectors of the economy
– think of the rise of generative artificial intelligence, to take one recent example. And
the financial services sector is certainly not exempt from the inexorable progress of
the digital revolution. The use of cash is expected to continue to decline, while large
technology companies have already begun to expand into the payments market and
are increasingly setting their sights on other financial services, thanks to their very
large customer base and global operations. It is against this backdrop that we need
to assess the merits of a digital euro.
Kosse, A., & Mattei, I. (2023). Making headway-Results of the 2022 BIS survey on central bank digital
currencies and crypto. BIS Papers.
https://www.ecb.europa.eu/press/pr/date/2023/html/ecb.pr231018~111a014ae7.en.html.
Today I will first examine the most important current shortcomings of the European digital
payments market and the risk that these shortcomings will be exacerbated by the quest
for dominance of technology platforms in a counterfactual scenario where a digital euro is
not issued. I will then argue that the digital euro would offer clear advantages in ensuring
a competitive, innovative, open and secure digital payment system, while maintaining
the highest standards of privacy protection. I will also discuss how potential risks to the
financial sector can be effectively mitigated through the careful design of safeguards.
The counterfactual: technology firms’ quest for dominance
The rapid digitisation of payments is a prevailing trend that was accelerated by the
Covid-19 pandemic. The share of payments made via mobile applications and the share
of consumer online payments tripled in the euro area between 2019 and 2022.5
Consumers are clearly embracing the efficiency and convenience of digital payments.
However, this transformation is associated with a number of challenges for the European
payments market.
While pan-European credit transfers and direct debits work thanks to European payment
schemes and infrastructures,6 this is not the case for cards and certain types of online
payments – whose use is growing disproportionately. This means that, as digitalisation
progresses, pan-European payments are in the hands of international players, increasing
our dependence on the payment rails they provide.
A handful of international companies dominate domestic and cross-border card and online
payments. International card schemes operate payment networks that are exclusively
compatible with their point-of-sale terminals. This situation raises barriers to entry and
expansion and discourages potential competitors from setting up new payment networks.
The situation remains largely unchanged despite regulatory initiative and competition
law enforcement.7 The decision of European banks to abandon their plans for a
continent-wide card scheme is a stark illustration of the dominant position held by
these firms.8 It is also striking that the average cost of card payments in the EU has
been reported to be higher now than in 2015, when the Interchange Fee Regulation
came into force.9 And the scheme fees applied by international card schemes almost
doubled between 2016 and 2021 in the EU.10
https://www.ecb.europa.eu/stats/ecb_surveys/space/html/ecb.spacereport202212~783ffdf46e.en.html.
https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w26604/w26604.pdf.
SEPA payment instruments – which are the result of a public-private partnership. See Fabio Panetta’s
speech at the European Payments Council: https://www.ecb.europa.eu/press/key/date/2022/html/ecb.
sp220616~9f8d1e277b.en.html.
https://www.finextra.com/newsarticle/39907/epi-abandons-plan-for-visa-and-mastercard-rival-asmember-banks-quit.
https://www.eurocommerce.eu/2020/12/benefit-of-interchange-fee-regulation-now-nullified-by-feeincreases/.
Rising from around 0.08 per cent to 0.15 per cent. See https://www.bargeldlosblog.de/wp-content/
uploads/CMSPI-Zephyre-Scheme-Fee-Study-V3-1.pdf.
As a result, and given the difficulty of using cash in e-commerce, consumers are faced
with prevailing payment solutions that work well, but may not be sufficiently tailored to
their needs and preferences in terms, for example, of privacy11 and pan-European reach.
This situation leads to unnecessary complexity and costs, as consumers are forced to rely
on a variety of payment methods depending on the specific transaction and counterpart
involved. Surveys show that consumers value the possibility of benefiting from a
universally accepted payment method across online and physical stores in Europe.12
In essence, the current state of digital payment markets already justifies the introduction
of a truly public and openly accessible payment solution to safeguard competition, better
meet user needs and preserve European autonomy. This is likely to become even more
critical in the future, as further expansion of large technology companies into payments
would make the concerns I have outlined even stronger and more pressing.
Three challenges deserve careful consideration.
The first is the drive for dominance of technology platforms. These companies are
increasingly entering the financial sector and reshaping financial markets. The logic of
platforms revolves around bundling various activities, including financial ones, with the
aim of expanding their customer base and enhancing network effects. By creating closed
ecosystems, or ‘walled gardens’, they reduce competition.13
This is not far-fetched fiction. Concerns about platforms favouring their own products
have already been at the forefront of antitrust cases. In as far back as 2010, the landmark
European antitrust case known as the ‘browser wars’ exposed the ability of companies
to restrict competition. More recently, the European Commission took issue with Apple’s
decision to prevent app developers of rival mobile payment wallets from accessing the
necessary hardware and software on its devices. This was done to favour its own solution,
Apple Pay.14
It is inevitable that technology platforms, armed with their large customer base and big
data processing capabilities, will expand their reach into financial services to attract new
customers – at the risk of reducing competition. In China, big tech companies such as
Payment data are often used for purposes other than those strictly related to payment execution. For
example, payment providers may work with private credit scoring companies that inform landlords,
creditors and service providers about the individual trust score of their prospective clients. Data obtained
from the payment process are also used by merchants in tailoring their offering, using profiling techniques
to understand a payer‘s spending capacity or their preferences to increase the effectiveness of certain
marketing campaigns. https://edps.europa.eu/data-protection/our-work/publications/techdispatch/
techdispatch-22021-card-based-payments_en.
See https://www.ecb.europa.eu/press/pr/date/2022/html/ecb.pr220330~309dbc7098.en.html and
https://www.ecb.europa.eu/press/pr/date/2023/html/ecb.pr230424_1_annex~93abdb80da.en.pdf.
By adopting the commercial practices of bundling and price discrimination, suppliers can replicate
monopoly pricing and extract consumer surplus from their customers. See Adams, W. and Yellen, J.,
‘Commodity bundling and the burden of monopoly’, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 90, No. 3
(August 1976). See also Jullien, B. and Sand-Zantman, W., ‘The Economics of Platforms: A Theory Guide
for Competition Policy’ (July 2020). CEPR Discussion Paper No. DP15071; Brunnermeier and Payne, 2022
https://economics.princeton.edu/working-papers/platforms-tokens-and-interoperability/.
https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/es/ip_22_2764.
AntFinancial and Tencent have overtaken the digital payment and e-commerce sectors,
and are expanding into financial intermediation.15 As a result, between 2020 and 2021,
big tech credit in China grew at an average annual rate of 37 per cent, outpacing the
growth rate of bank credit by more than 20 percentage points.16
Western technology companies are also increasingly challenging financial institutions,
seeking to compete with traditional banks as financial service providers.17 In the United
States, Apple’s new savings account, linked to its payment solutions, offers interest at
more than 10 times the national average rate,18 and has attracted more than 10 billion
dollars in user deposits since its launch in April.19 And X (formerly Twitter) is reportedly
planning to offer a full range of payment and financial services.20 Amazon offers
buy-now-pay-later services to its customers worldwide.
This brings us to the second concern about the dominance of technology platforms,
Trending
- CORRI LIBERA, RAUTI: LA DIFESA PER LA CULTURA DEL RISPETTO DONNE
- LUCA ZINGARETTI IN VISITA ALLA MOSTRA DI PALAZZO DEI DIAMANTI. UN RITORNO NELLA CITTÀ DEL SUO ESORDIO AL CINEMA. L’ATTORE IN QUESTI GIORNI A FERRARA PER “MARCO POLO E LE CITTÀ INVISIBILI”, IN SCENA AL TEATRO COMUNALE
- MANOVRA: BERGAMINI, “FORZA ITALIA LAVORA PER MIGLIORARLA, IL CAMPO LARGO PENSA A NUOVE TASSE
- GIORNATA VITTIME STRADA. DE CORATO (FDI): SICUREZZA È PRIORITÀ PER GOVERNO MELONI
- Le Commissioni consiliari di lunedì 16 novembre
- Emergenza abitativa, lunedì a Forlì il convegno sul Piano Casa. Tassinari «Più garanzie ai proprietari per rimettere in affitto le case sfitte»
- FERRARA, FABBRI SECONDO TRA I SINDACI DEI COMUNI TRA 120MILA E 260MILA ABITANTI CON IL 58,5% DI GRADIMENTO SECONDO IL SONDAGGIO LAB21. SINDACO: “UN RISULTATO CHE MI RENDE FELICE. IL CONSENSO VA CONQUISTATO OGNI GIORNO
- Domenica ecologica, oltre mille alberi e piantine donati ai cittadini al Parco San Giuliano
- MANIFESTAZIONI A PARMA, RUSSO (FDI): GRAZIE A FORZE DELL’ORDINE, SMENTITA LA NARRAZIONE DI UN GOVERNO CHE REPRIME IL DISSENSO
- NEWS RELEASE: Six months on, accessing hard-to-reach communities key to halting Ebola outbreak