(AGENPARL) - Roma, 21 Novembre 2023 - (AGENPARL) – mar 21 novembre 2023 Mercati, infrastrutture, sistemi di pagamento
(Markets, Infrastructures, Payment Systems)
Number
November 2023
Report on the payment attitudes of consumers in Italy:
results from the ECB SPACE 2022 survey
Mercati, infrastrutture, sistemi di pagamento
(Markets, Infrastructures, Payment Systems)
Report on the payment attitudes of consumers in Italy:
results from the ECB SPACE 2022 survey
Number 42 – November 2023
The papers published in the ‘Markets, Infrastructures, Payment Systems’ series provide
information and analysis on aspects regarding the institutional duties of the Bank of
Italy in relation to the monitoring of financial markets and payment systems and the
development and management of the corresponding infrastructures in order to foster
a better understanding of these issues and stimulate discussion among institutions,
economic actors and citizens.
The views expressed in the papers are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect
those of the Bank of Italy.
The series is available online at www.bancaditalia.it.
Printed copies can be requested from the Paolo Baffi Library:
Editorial Board: Stefano Siviero, Livio Tornetta, Giuseppe Zingrillo, Guerino Ardizzi,
Paolo Libri, Giuseppe Maresca, Onofrio Panzarino, Tiziana Pietraforte,
Antonio Sparacino.
Secretariat: Alessandra Rollo.
ISSN 2724-6418 (online)
ISSN 2724-640X (print)
Banca d’Italia
Via Nazionale, 91 – 00184 Rome – Italy
Designed and printing by the Printing and Publishing Division of the Bank of Italy
Report on the payment attitudes of consumers in italy:
results from the ecb space 2022 survey
Abstract
This report presents findings for Italy from the ‘Study on the payment attitudes of consumers in
the euro area (SPACE) – 2022’, conducted by the European Central Bank between the end of
2021 and the first half of 2022. The primary aim of the report is to provide updated information
on the prevailing trends in the use of payment methods in Italy. Additionally, where applicable
and useful, the report compares Italy’s results with those of the euro area and with data from
the previous run of the survey, conducted in 2019, and from the ‘Study on the use of cash by
households in the euro area’ (SUCH), conducted in 2015-16. The data show that, while cash
remains the dominant payment method at the Point of Sale (POS), especially for low-value
purchases (up to €50), its overall usage has declined in comparison with the findings of the
previous editions of the survey. In terms of value of transactions, non-cash payments have gained
importance, accounting for more than half of total expenditures at POS. Cashless payments are
increasing overall, supported also by an uptake in e-commerce purchases. Specifically, cards,
besides being the greatest competitor of cash for POS transactions, continue to be the most used
means of payment both in terms of number and value of transactions for online purchases.
JEL Classification: EL41, D12, D14.
Keywords: payment instruments, cash, payment habits, consumers’ payment behaviour.
Sintesi
Il rapporto presenta i risultati italiani dell’indagine sui comportamenti dei consumatori dell’area
dell’euro condotta dalla Banca Centrale Europea tra la fine del 2021 e la prima metà del 2022
(Study on the payment attitudes of consumers in the euro area – SPACE 2022). Lo scopo
principale del documento è fornire informazioni aggiornate sulle tendenze nell’utilizzo degli
strumenti di pagamento in Italia. Inoltre, ove possibile e utile, il rapporto confronta i risultati
italiani con quelli dell’area dell’euro e con quelli della precedente edizione, condotta nel 2019,
e dell’indagine Study on the use of cash by households in the euro area – SUCH, condotta
nel 2015-16. I dati mostrano che, sebbene il contante rimanga lo strumento di pagamento
principale presso il Punto Vendita (POS) fisico, specialmente per gli acquisti di valore ridotto
(fino a €50), il suo utilizzo è diminuito rispetto ai risultati delle indagini precedenti. In termini
di valore delle transazioni, i pagamenti con strumenti alternativi al contante hanno acquisito
maggiore importanza e rappresentano oltre la metà delle spese totali presso il POS. I pagamenti
con strumenti elettronici stanno complessivamente aumentando, supportati anche dalla crescita
del commercio elettronico. Le carte, oltre a rappresentare il principale concorrente del contante
per le transazioni al POS, continuano a essere lo strumento di pagamento più utilizzato, in
termini sia di numero sia di valore, per le transazioni relative ad acquisti online.
This report was edited by Gabriele Coletti, Alberto Di Iorio, Emanuele Pimpini and Giorgia Rocco of the
Retail Payment Instruments and Services Directorate at Banca d’Italia.
CONTENTS
Executive summary
1. Introduction
2. Methodology and data
3. Non-recurring payments
3.1 Payments at POS
3.2 Online payments
3.3 P2P payments 17
4. Recurring payments
5. Preferences for payment instruments
6. Access to cash
7. Access to non-cash means of payment
7.1 Ownership of crypto-assets
References
Appendix: Detailed Charts
Executive summary
The objective of this statistical report is to update the information on consumer payment
attitudes in Italy – already presented in the previous ‘Report on the payment attitudes
of consumers in Italy: results from ECB surveys’ – based on the new SPACE survey of
the European Central Bank (ECB). The new survey was conducted between the end of
2021 and the first half of 2022 and, in the case of Italy, it collected information from a
sample of 4,483 respondents. Whenever possible and meaningful, the Italian results are
compared with those for the euro area and with the results of previous surveys in order
to facilitate international comparisons and to identify possible trends.
The new SPACE 2022 study shows that in Italy:
cash is the most used payment instrument at the physical point of sale (POS),
although its share has declined in recent years: cash payments represent 69% of the
total payments (86% in 2016; 82% in 2019), compared to 26% of transactions with
cards (13% in 2016; 16% in 2019) and around 4% with other instruments (1% in
2016; 2% in 2019) of which 2% with mobile apps (negligible in previous surveys).
In a cross-country comparison Italy still remains one of the countries with the highest
reliance on cash in the euro area;
in terms of value of transactions, non-cash payments have increased, reaching 51%
(32% in 2016; 42% in 2019) of total purchases at the POS and narrowing the gap
with the euro area;
cash remains by far the prevailing instrument for low-value purchases (up to €50),
although with different nuances as it accounts for 76% (89% in 2016 and 2019) of
transactions up to €30 and 54% (63% in 2016; 61% in 2019) of payments between
€30 and €50. Cash ceases to be the dominant instrument for purchases between €50
and €100 accounting for 45% (51% in 2016; 54% in 2019) of all payments in this
range. Cards remain an instrument most frequently involved in high value purchases
as they are used in 53% (42% in 2016; 45% in 2019) of purchases above 100€. In the
euro area the cash at the POS is less used in all value ranges than in Italy;
the acceptance of cashless instruments at the POS has improved, as cash is the only
accepted instrument in only 26% of cash-settled transactions (40% in 2019) in line
with the euro area figures;
the share of online payments has increased significantly over time, reaching 16% of
total non-recurring payments1 (6% in 2019) and confirming the trend observed in the
whole euro area;
Non-recurring day-to-day payments refer to payments at the physical point of sale (POS), person-toperson payments (P2P) and online payments, defined as good and services ordered and paid for online.
for person-to-person transactions (P2P), cash payments has remained stable at 85%
of total P2P payments (86% in 2019), in contrast to the euro area, where cash usage
has declined particularly in favour of mobile payments;
as in the euro area, for recurring payments2, direct debit is the most used instrument,
while cash is not very used;
despite cash is still the most widely used instrument at the POS, consumers strongly
confirm their preference for cashless payment instruments if they are free to choose
how to pay in a shop without any constraint; in other words, there is still a
discrepancy between respondents’ stated preferences and their actual behaviour at
the POS, as also emerged in SPACE 2019. In a cross-country perspective, Italy is
one of the countries with the strongest preference for cashless in the euro area;
the main perceived advantages of using cards are the convenience (no need to carry
cash), as well as the security and speed of such transactions. The advantages of cash,
on the other hand, relate to the perception of better control over the amount spent and
to a higher level of acceptance by merchants. Anonymity and privacy protection are
perceived as less important in Italy than in the euro area;
77% of respondents obtain cash by withdrawing from the ATM network, compared
with 11% from their own reserves and 7% from a bank or post office counter. As in
2019, 93% of Italian respondents are satisfied with their access conditions to cash.
Italy is one of the countries in the euro area with the lowest rate of people stating the
access to cash as difficult;
the share of consumers who report the ownership of crypto-assets is stable at 2% (as
in 2019), the lowest figure in the euro area. People hold these assets mainly for
investment purposes (55%) and to a lesser extent as a means of payment (15%).
Recurring payments are made on a weekly, monthly, annual or other basis and include several categories:
rent or mortgage, utility bills, insurance, telephone or internet bills, taxes and public charges, subscriptions
(e.g. magazines, sports club, streaming TV), season tickets for transport and loans.
1. Introduction
In view of the continuing evolution in the payments’ market towards a more digital
payment landscape, the Eurosystem is committed to carefully monitoring new trends and
the nature and extent of the changes in consumers’ payment preferences.
For this purpose, since 2016 the ECB has been conducting a survey every two (or three)
years focusing on payment behaviours. The first survey was the ‘Study on the Use of
Cash by Households’ (SUCH 2016), which focused on the euro-area consumers’
payment behaviour at the point of sale (POS) and for person-to-person (P2P)
transactions. The results, deeply described in Esselink and Hernandez (2017), suggest
that cash was the most used instrument at the POS, especially for low-value
payments, but with marked heterogeneity across euro-area countries.
In 2019, the ECB launched a new survey to investigate the payment behaviour of euroarea citizens, largely reviewing the scope of the previous SUCH study to a large extent:
the Study on the Payment Attitudes of Consumers in the Euro area (SPACE 2019).
Follow-up SPACE studies have been carried out regularly to continue research on
payment trends and the new SPACE survey was conducted in 2021 and 2022.
Results from SUCH are only comparable to the SPACE studies to a limited extent,
because the survey methods were different and the output variables only partially overlap.
The results of the SPACE studies make it possible to estimate the share of different
payment instruments used by consumers at the point of sale (POS), for person-to-person
(P2P), online and recurring payments in various ways, including by demographics and
payment patterns. In addition, the survey gives an insight into consumers’ access to and
acceptance of cash and other payment instruments.
Compared to SPACE 2019, SPACE 2022 additionally looks at: (i) changes in payment
behaviour since the onset of the pandemic; (ii) recent trends in digital payments, such as
the availability and perceived cost of instant payments; (iii) crypto-assets, including
information on respondents’ ownership and usage patterns.
In this report, we focus on payment habits in Italy, using the rich and granular information
from the new SPACE 2022 survey. We describe recent trends offering a comparison,
where possible, with the previous SUCH (Rocco, 2019) and SPACE 2019 (Coletti et al.,
2022) surveys. In addition, to give an international view of consumer behaviour, we
compare the Italian results with those of the euro area (Esselink and Hernandez, 2017;
ECB, 2020; ECB, 2022). Moreover, we provide an assessment of Italians’ payment
behaviour by investigating the most relevant factors driving the payment choice in Italy
such as the socio-demographic characteristics of the respondents, as well as a number of
transaction-related features, such as the amount of the transaction, the adoption of
technology, etc, as found in Di Iorio and Rocco (2022).
The report is structured as follows: Section 2 briefly summarises the methodology of the
ECB consumer payment surveys and describes the data; Section 3 analyses non-recurring
diaries, while Section 4 describes recurring payments; Section 5 assesses consumers’
payment preferences; Section 6 explores access to cash, while Section 7 describes access
to alternative instruments and the ownership of crypto-assets. Finally, the report also
includes a list of charts in the Appendix that complement the view on the phenomena
described in Sections 3 to 7.
2. Methodology and data
The SPACE 2022 survey largely confirms the methodology of the previous SPACE 2019
study. A sample of euro-area residents older than 18 years was asked to fill in three
payment diaries and a questionnaire on their behaviour and attitudes towards cash and
cashless payment instruments. The diaries cover non-recurring payments, namely (i) POS
and P2P payments and (ii) online payments, for which a one-day diary is used as in
SPACE 2019, and (iii) recurring payments, for which respondents have to report a
selection of bill payments made in the last 30 days, rather than the last 7 days in the
previous edition. Compared to its predecessor, the questionnaire has been expanded to
include, for example, questions on the ownership of certain financial instruments and a
module on the impact of the pandemic on payment habits.
As in the previous ECB payment consumers surveys (SUCH and SPACE 2019), the
SPACE 2022 sample covers 17 of the 19 euro-area countries,3 with the exception of
Germany and the Netherlands. Indeed, the Deutsche Bundesbank (DBB) and De
Nederlandsche Bank (DNB) and the Dutch Payments Association (DPA) carry out their
own surveys on payment behaviour and their data have been integrated in the ECB reports
where possible.
Data for all countries, except Germany and the Netherlands, are collected using an
identical questionnaire translated into the national language. In order to prevent panel
bias, half interviews are conducted online (computer?assisted web interviewing – CAWI)
and half over the telephone (computer?assisted telephone interviewing – CATI) using a
mix of mobile and fixed lines. For both sub-samples, quotas are set for country, age,
gender and day of the week. To capture the potential seasonality in consumers’ payment
behaviour, interviews are conducted in two waves: the first one in Q4 2021 and the second
between mid-March and early-June 2022.
The total sample size achieved in Italy is 4,483 individuals out of a total of 39,765 in the
17 euro-area countries. Overall, Italian payment diaries data, that refer to non-recurring
payments, consist of 9,376 transactions for POS, 383 for P2P and 1,948 for online
shopping. On the other hand, recurring payments, consisting of a selection of bill
payments made in the 30 days prior to the interview date, amount to 12,120.
At the time of the survey (2022) Croatia was not yet a member of the euro area.
3. Non-recurring payments
Non-recurring day-to-day payments refer to payments made to purchase goods and
services at the physical point of sale (POS), person-to-person payments (P2P) not
connected to the purchase of goods and services, and online payments, defined as good
and services ordered and paid for online.4
Figure 1
Non-recurring payments by payment situation
(a) Number of payments
(b) Value of payments
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE 2019 and SPACE 2022 data.
The share of online payments in consumers’ non-recurring purchases has increased
considerably since 2019, while the share of payments at the POS has declined. The
incidence of P2P payments has remained modest. Data show a sharp increase in the
share of online payments in day-to-day transactions in Italy in 2022 (Fig. 1), reaching
16% in terms of number (6% in 2019). In terms of value, the share of online payments
reaches 26% (16% in 2019), indicating that online payments are more frequently used for
larger payment amounts. This trend is in line with the euro area, where online transactions
account for 17% in terms of number (6% in 2019), and 28% in terms of value (14% in
2019). Interestingly, the share of Italian respondents who have made at least one online
transaction has almost tripled in recent years, reaching 26% in 2022 (9% in 2019).
Furthermore, the breakdown of online payments by purpose and location has changed
with a strong increase in food purchases accounting for 21% of total online purchases
(9% in 2019), mainly at the expenses of durable goods having the largest contraction at
27% (40% in 2019).
In Italy, POS payments still represent the bulk of the daily retail payments market, albeit
decreasing compared to the previous survey, accounting for 81% of total non-recurring
purchases in terms of number (90% in 2019) and 69% in terms of value (76% in 2019).
Italian figures are in line with the euro area: of all day-to-day payments, 80% are made at
Differently from SPACE 2019, in SPACE 2022 the transactions ordered online but paid at the point of
sale (e.g. paying a courier at the door) are not considered as online transactions; therefore, cash is not among
means of payment available for online transactions.
the POS in 2022 (88% in 2019) accounting for 68% in terms of value (79% in 2019). This
evidence suggests that POS payments are, on average, made for low-value purchases. The
data show no relevant changes in the breakdown of POS payments by purpose and
location, in contrast to online purchases.
Finally, the incidence of P2P transactions has remained stable at 3% of all non-recurring
transactions (as in 2019), but has declined to 5% in terms of value (8% in 2019). In the
euro area, the share of P2P transactions in the number non-recurring payments has
decreased slightly to 4% (5% in 2019), while the incidence of P2P payments in terms of
value has declined a little more, to 5% (7% in 2019).
The increase in online purchases has been mainly at the expense of POS purchases,
reflecting potential new consumption habits as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, as
well as some mobility constraints present in late 2021 and early 2022. The shift towards
online shopping is also confirmed by the direct questions on changes in payment
behaviour since the onset of the pandemic with 41% of consumers buying goods online
more often than before the pandemic.
Payments at POS
The data confirm a downward trend in the use of cash at the POS, which is coupled
with an increasing use of cards. However, cash remains the most frequently used
method. In terms of number of transactions, the share of cash payments at the POS in
Italy has decreased significantly in recent years, falling to 69% in 2022 (86% in 2016; 82
in 2019), while the share of card payments has reached 26% (13% in 2016; 16% in 2019)
of total POS transactions (Fig. 2a). A similar trend has occurred in the euro area, where
cash payments account for 59% of total POS payments (79% in 2016; 72% in 2019) and
card payments account for 34% (19% in 2016; 25% in 2019). However, in a cross-country
comparison Italy still remains one of the countries with the highest reliance on cash.
In terms of value of transactions (Fig. 2b), for the first time since ECB surveys have been
conducted, in Italy the share of non-cash payments at the POS (51%) is higher than those
in cash (49%). The reduction in the share of cash payments (-19 p.p. between 2016 and
2022) and the concomitant increase in the share of card payments over time have been
more pronounced in Italy (+14 p.p. between 2016 and 2022) than in the euro area (-12
and +7 p.p., for cash and cards, respectively). As a result, the gap with the euro area in
the use of non-cash instruments has narrowed.
Mobile payments, although on the rise, are still not very popular at the POS, with a small
share of payments (around 2% in terms of both number and value of transactions) as in
the euro area (around 3% in terms of both number and value of transactions).
Figure 2
Share of payment instruments used at the POS
(a) Number of payments
(b) Value of payments
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SUCH (2016), SPACE 2019 and SPACE 2022 data.
Notes: Other includes mobile payments, bank cheques, credit transfers, loyalty points, vouchers and gift cards and
other payment instruments.
These changes in payment habits have largely occured over the last three years as
the pandemic has accelerated the substitution of cash for non-cash payments.5 A key
issue is whether this behaviour may prove temporary once the pandemic is over.
Interestingly, when asked specifically about the impact of the pandemic, 57% of
respondents declared to have not changed their use of cash at the POS, while 27% said
that they use it less often than before the pandemic. People using cash less frequently also
indicated, from a given list, some prevailing reasons for this change, pointing first to the
increased convenience of electronic payments (46%), followed by government
recommendations to use cashless instruments (39%).
The choice of payment instrument at the POS is significantly influenced by the value
of the transaction: cash is most frequently used for small payments, while as the
value of transactions grows, cards and other means of payment become more
competitive. Both for Italy and the euro area, cash usage at the POS is decreasing over
time for both high and low-value payments; however, some differences still persist. In
Italy (Fig. 3a and 3b), cash remains by far the dominant instrument for payments up to
€30 accounting for 76% of these transactions (89% in 2016 and 2019); cards play only a
minor role. This also contributes to the understanding of the overall dominant role of cash
in POS payments, as small value payments account for 75% of all POS transactions.
When considering transactions between €30 and €50, the weight of cash decreases to 54%
(63% in 2016; 61% in 2019) and the weight of cards becomes non-negligible, accounting
for 41% of all the transactions in this value range (35% in 2016; 38% in 2019).
See Ardizzi et al. (2020, 2021) for empiricial analysis regarding the effects of the pandemic on payment
habits in Italy using high-frequency transaction data from clearing and processing systems.
Differently from previous surveys, cash is no longer the most used instrument for
transactions between €50 and €100, accounting for 45% of all payments in this range
(54% in 2019; 51% in 2016).
Finally, for payments over €100, cash plays a progressively smaller role, in favour of
cards, accounting only for 35% of payments (40 % in 2019; 46 % in 2016).
In the euro area (Fig. 3c and 3d) the cash at the POS is less used compared to Italy in all
value ranges. In particular, despite being the most used payment instrument for
transactions up to €30, the share of cash payments is lower if compared to Italy.
Furthermore, the threshold for which cash is no longer the dominant instrument (€30) is
lower than in the Italian case. However, Italy is experiencing an ongoing process of
convergence of the share of cash used at the POS with the euro area. In fact, even if some
differences persist for small payments, the gaps in all value ranges greater than €30 are
narrowing.
Figure 3
POS payments by value range and payment instrument
(a) Italy: distribution of transaction value
(b) Italy: payment instrument breakdown
(c) Euro area: distribution of transaction value
(d) Euro area: payment instrument breakdown
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SUCH 2016, SPACE 2019 and SPACE 2022 data.
Notes: Other includes bank cheques, credit transfers, mobile payments, loyalty points, vouchers and gift cards and
other payment instruments.
Heterogeneity in the use of means of payments has decreased at regional level,
especially in terms of value of transactions. Although the estimates should be treated
with caution, as the sample design is not conceived to capture regional differences
properly, the use of cash, but also of other instruments, appears to have become more
homogenous across Italian regions in recent years. In terms of number of transactions,
the use of different payment instruments appears to be quite similar across regions, with
the North using slightly less cash (around 69%) and more cards (around 28%) than the
South (cash around 71%; cards around 24%). This evidence is in line with findings from
SPACE 2019, where the regional heterogeneity in terms of volume was rather small,
although more pronounced than in SPACE 2022.
The use of different payment instruments in terms of value also appears to be rather
homogeneous across regions, with northern regions showing a share of cash in POS
transactions of around 49% and southern regions just over 50%. The largest difference is
observed between Lombardy (48%) and Puglia-Basilicata-Calabria (55%). However, the
north-south differences has significantly attenuated from 2019. The picture is similar for
cards.
Differences in payment habits among different population groups has attenuated,
both in terms of volume and value. Since 2019, the gender gap has narrowed, with
women and men broadly reporting the same incidence of cash and card payments. Older
people continue to show a high fraction of cash payments (73% and 51% in terms of
number and value of transactions, respectively), while younger people show a decreased
share of cash payments, now in line with other age groups, in contrast to the 2019 data.
In addition, people aged 18-39 use instruments other than cards and cash more often than
others. Significant differences remains when looking at the level of education and income
distribution with less educated and low-income people relying more on cash at the POS
(the share of POS payments stands around 70% for the former and more than 73% for the
latter in terms of number of transactions; around 50% and 55% in terms of value of
transactions).
Payment habits differ considerably across locations and for different purposes. In
terms of value of transactions, cash is largely used for charity (80%), for purchases on the
street (75%) and at vending machines (68%), for household services (59%) and for food
(65%), which together accounts for about 25% of total POS expenditure. The value of
card payments overtakes cash ones for travel purposes (68%), for purchase of durable
goods (55%) and for services (56%), which combined accounts for 27% of total POS
expenditures.
According to respondents’ perception, the acceptance of cashless payment
instruments at the POS has improved. Cash is the only accepted instrument in 26% of
the all cash-settled transactions (40% in 2019), similarly to the euro area. Supermarkets
and petrol stations has the highest rate of non-cash instruments acceptance (around 90%)
immediately followed by durable goods shops (81%). On the opposite, the acceptance is
the lowest in charity transactions (24%).
Online payments
For online payments, cards continue to be the most widely used payment method
both in terms of number and value of transactions. In terms of number (Fig. 4a), the
share of card payments has declined slightly to 50% of total online payments (54% in
2019), in line with the 51% of the euro area (54% in 2019). The incidence of e-payment
solutions, which includes PayPal and other online or mobile payment methods, has also
slightly declined to 27% (29% in 2019), while the proportion of credit transfers has nearly
doubled at 5% (3% in 2019). Over the last years the use of other online payment methods
– such as direct debits, loyalty points, vouchers and gift cards, crypto assets, and other
method not identified in the questionnaire – has increased to some extent, reaching 17%
of total online payments. Overall, this picture is confirmed also in terms of value of
transactions (Fig. 4b).
The average value of transactions differs considerably across the means of payment,
standing at €148 for credit transfers, € 61 for card transactions and and € 46 for epayments, thus confirming that credit transfers are mainly used for high-value payments.
Figure 4
Share of payment instruments used for online purchases
(a) Number of payments
(b) Value of payments
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE 2019 and SPACE 2022 data.
Payment cards are the most commonly used instrument across all the different
purchase purposes, while the importance of non-card instruments varies. The share
of payment cards varies widely across purchase purposes; in terms of volumes it ranges
from 37% for charity transactions to 61% for food transactions. Credit transfers are
generally little used, but have a non-negligible share of use more for charity (24%) and
travel (13%) transactions, while e-payments, which are generally the most widely used
instruments after cards, are used in more than one in three payments for all purchase
purposes except for food (15%) and charity (20%).
P2P payments
For P2P payments, cash continues to be the dominant payment instrument; unlike
the euro area, there is no significant use of mobile instruments. Cash payments have
remained stable at 85% of total P2P payments (86% in 2019), higher than 73% of the euro
area, which has experienced a decline (86% in 2019). In terms of value, these trends are
confirmed even if the share of cash is around 60% both for Italy and the euro area, thus
confirming that also for P2P transactions cash is mainly used for low-value payments.
Cards play a minor role, as private individuals rarely have the opportunity to accept card
payments. The share of mobile payments, both in terms of volume and value, stands at
3%, thus showing low usage in Italy compared to 10% in the euro area.
Recurring payments
In addition to day-to-day payments, consumers make recurring payments on a weekly,
monthly, annual or other basis. Specifically, recurring payments are most frequently used
for telephone and internet bills and utilities (50% of the overall recurring payments),
followed by subscriptions (12%), rent or mortgage (10%), insurance (9%), taxes and
public charges (7%), tickets for transport (6%), paying back debt or consumer loans (6%).
Cash is not very used in recurring payments. Direct debit is the most frequently used
instrument (51% of reported payments), followed by cards (22%) and credit transfer
(12%). Cash plays a minor role (10%). In particular, direct debits are widely used to pay
utilities (60%), telephone bills (66%) and rents or mortgages (51%). Cards show an
above-the-average share, for subscriptions (39%) and tickets for transport (47%). In terms
of value of transactions, the picture remains broadly unchanged. However, credit transfer
payments represent 23% of total recurring transactions, thus confirming also in this case
that this instrument is primarily used for high value transactions. On the opposite, cards
(16%) and cash (7%) are used for low-value payments. In the euro area, the direct debit
is confirmed as the most widely used instrument, while, unlike in Italy, the credit transfer
weighs more, both in terms of volume and value.
5. Preferences for payment instruments
In Italy people prefer to pay with cashless payment instruments. As in 2019, Italians
strongly confirm their preference for cashless payment instruments. In fact, the majority
of respondents report that they would pay with cards or other cashless methods (58%;
Fig. 5a) if they were free to choose how to pay in a shop without any constraint; being
one of the countries with the strongest preference for cashless in the euro area (55%).
Cash is the preferred means of payment for only 18% of Italian respondents, a little lower
than in the euro area (22%).
Asked on the perceived main advantages of cash and cards, Italian respondents report that
the main advantages of using cash are that it gives a clear overview of expenses (41%)
and that it is widely accepted (32%), similary to the euro area (Fig. 5b). However, only a
limited number of respondents in Italy report anonimity and privacy protection among
advantages (22%) compared to the euro area (40%). On the other hand, the main reasons
for using cards are related to convenience (respondents do not need to carry cash with
them; 66%), fast use (40%) and safety (31%).
Figure 5
Preferences for payment instruments
(a) Preferences at the POS
(b) Perceived advantages of payment
instruments
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE 2022 data.
Preferences for different payment instruments exhibit small variability at territorial
level, while some relevant differences among population groups remain. The
preference for cashless instruments is lower in the South (around 50%) than in the North
(more than 60%). Both younger and older people report a share of preference for cash
(26% and 21%, respectively) slightly above the national average as well as low-educated
and low-income groups (20% and 34%, respectively).
Taken together, there is still a discrepancy between respondents’ stated preferences and
their actual behaviour at the POS, as also emerged in SPACE 2019. In a recent paper, Di
Iorio and Rocco (2022) found that an important explanatory factor is the lack of
acceptance of alternative instruments by merchants, especially for low-value transactions.
6. Access to cash
In Italy, access to cash remains largely satisfactory and still dependent on the ATM
network. People obtain cash from various sources, with ATMs representing the main
channel (77%) similarly to the euro area (74%), followed by their own reserves (11%)
and bank counters (7%). Cash provision in physical shops and from retailers, such as
cashback and cash-in-shop services, are still not common neither in Italy and in the euro
area (below 3%; Fig. 6a).
In Italy, 93% of respondents perceive access to the cash withdrawals as very or fairly easy
(Fig 6b) while only 6% of them report difficulty in access to cash, being one of the
countries in the euro area with the lowest rate of people stating the access to cash as
difficult. Moreover, compared to a worsening trend in the difficulty of obtaining cash
from ATMs in some countries, for Italy, perceived ease of access has remained stable
since 2019.
Replies to a specific question on the use of cash as a store of value suggest that 40% of
respondents keep cash at home for precautionary reasons. This figure is more pronounced
for younger people (54%) and students (55%). Almost all respondents hold less than
€1,000 euros for precautionary purposes.
Figure 6
Sources and access to cash
(a) Cash sources
(b) Access to cash
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE 2022 data.
7. Access to non-cash means of payment
Access to non-cash means of payment is widespread. The survey also investigates
consumers’ access to an account for payments and access to non-cash means of payment,
which are relevant for financial inclusion considerations. The possession of an account
for payments is widespread in Italy (86%; Fig. 7a), although slightly lower than in the
euro area (91%). The gap narrows when looking at the possession of a payment card (92%
and 94%, respectively).
Figure 7
Indicators of access to cashless payment instruments
(a) Ownership of cards, accounts and cryptoassets
(b) Instant payments
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE 2022 data.
The north-south gap in payment card ownership has narrowed. In the northern
regions, the proportion of inhabitants with at least one payment card is 93% (91% in
2019), while in the southern regions it is 90% (85% in 2019). When looking at
socio?demographic characteristics, low-income people report the lowest rate of card
possession (82%), followed by young people, housepersons and the unemployed (about
88%).
More than one in two respondents report to have access to instant payments. The
SEPA Instant Credit Transfer (SCT Inst) enables pan-European credit transfers with the
funds made available on the account of the recipient in less than ten seconds, 24 hours a
day, 365 days a year. According to the survey, instant payments are available to 57% of
respondents in Italy, compared to 51% in the euro area (Fig. 7b). However, 38% of Italian
respondents report to pay a higher fee for instant credit transfers than for credit transfers
(20% in the euro area).
7.1 Ownership of crypto-assets
The ownership of crypto-assets is not widespread in Italy. Notwithstanding the
increased attention paid to crypto-assets by policy makers, uptake among the general
population in Italy has remained stable at 2% (as in 2019), slighlty below the 4% of the
euro area (as in 2019), being the country with the lowest share. Those who reported
holding crypto-assets were also asked whether they used them for payments, investment
purposes or both. Overall, significance is clearly placed on holdings for investment
purposes (55% ) and a only to a limited extent for payments (15%).
The possession of crypto-assets is more pronounced among the inhabitants of the northern
regions (about 3%), males (4%) and students (5%). Older people tend to hold such assets
less than youngers, while possession increases with the education level and income. In
addition, the percentage of crypto-asset ownership almost doubles among those who own
other financial investments (5%). Where comparable, these results are consistent with
those reported in Bank of Italy (2023).
References
Ardizzi, G., A. Nobili and G. Rocco (2020), A game changer in payment habits: evidence
from daily data during a pandemic, Bank of Italy Occasional Papers no. 591, December
2020.
Ardizzi, G., A. Gambini, A. Nobili, E. Pimpini and G. Rocco (2021), L’impatto della
pandemia sull’uso degli strumenti di pagamento in Italia, Bank of Italy
Markets, Infrastructures, Payment Systems, no. 8, July 2021.
Bank of Italy (2023), Economic Bulletin n. 1-2023, January 2023.
Coletti, G., A. Di Iorio, E. Pimpini and G. Rocco (2022), Report on the payment attitudes
of consumers in Italy: results from ECB surveys, Bank of Italy Markets, Infrastructures,
Payment Systems, Institutional Issues no. 21, March 2022.
Di Iorio, A. and G. Rocco (2022), Easier said than done: why Italians pay in cash while
preferring cashless, Bank of Italy Occasional Papers no. 731, November 2022.
Esselink, H. and L. Hernandez (2017), The use of cash by households in the euro area,
ECB Occasional Paper Series no. 201, November 2017.
European Central Bank (2020), Study on the payment attitudes of consumers in the euro
area (SPACE), December 2020.
European Central Bank (2022), Study on the payment attitudes of consumers in the euro
area (SPACE), December 2022.
Rocco, G. (2019), The use of cash in Italy: evidence from the ECB Study on the use of
cash by households, Bank of Italy Occasional Papers no. 481, January 2019.
Appendix: Detailed Charts
This part of the paper is aimed at providing the reader with a comprehensive set of
graphs in order to draw a detailed outline of Italians’ payment habits.
Following the same path as Sections 3 to 7 of the main text, the sequence of the
figures starts from the use of payment instruments in Italy in POS payments (Section A1)
and then continues dealing with online payments and P2P transactions (Sections A2 and
A3, respectively). A picture of recurring payments is outlined afterwards (Section A4),
followed by an overview of consumers’ payment preferences (Section A5). Access to
cash in Italy is the core of the following part (Section A6). The appendix concludes with
a focus on the access to payment instruments such as cards or crypto-assets (Section A7).
Note to the reader:
? percentages may not add up to 100 per cent due to rounding,
? the subdivision into macro-regions is aimed to achieve representativeness of the
population of the sample.
List of Charts
A1. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Point of sale (POS) ……………………………………………….. 25
Fig. A1.1. Share of payment instruments in POS transactions ………………………………………………… 25
Fig. A1.2. Frequency distribution of POS transaction value by payment instrument ……………….. 26
Fig. A1.3. Use of payment instruments by regional macro-area: number of transactions …………. 27
Fig. A1.4. Use of payment instruments by regional macro-area: value of transactions …………….. 27
Fig. A1.5. Use of payment instruments by demographic: number of transactions ……………………. 28
Fig. A1.6. Use of payment instruments by demographic: value of transactions ……………………….. 28
Fig. A1.7. Use of payment instruments by occupation: number of transactions ……………………….. 29
Fig. A1.8 Use of payment instruments by occupation: value of transactions ……………………………. 29
Fig. A1.9. Use of payment instruments by income group: number of transactions …………………… 30
Fig. A1.10. Use of payment instruments by income group: value of transactions …………………….. 30
Fig. A1.11. Payments by place of purchase (left panel) and by place of purchase and instrument
(right panel): number of transactions ……………………………………………………………………………………… 31
Fig. A1.12. Payments by place of purchase (left panel) and by place of purchase and instrument
(right panel): value of transactions ………………………………………………………………………………………… 31
Fig. A1.13. Payment instruments by place of purchase: acceptance of alternative instruments for
cash-settled transactions and average transaction value ………………………………………………………….. 32
Fig. A1.14. Frequency of cash usage compared to before the pandemic in Italy ………………………. 32
Fig. A1.15. Reasons why making cash payments less often than before the pandemic in Italy …. 33
A2. Use of payment instruments in Italy – online payments ……………………………………………………. 34
Fig. A2.1. Average value of transactions per payment instrument …………………………………………… 34
Fig. A2.2. Frequency of online payments compared to before the pandemic in Italy ……………….. 34
Fig. A2.3. Payments by product type (left panel) and by product type and instrument (right panel):
number of transactions ………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 35
Fig. A2.4. Payments by product type (left panel) and by product type and instrument (right panel):
value of transactions ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 35
A3. Use of payment instruments in Italy – P2P payments ………………………………………………………. 36
Fig. A3.1. Share of payment instruments in P2P transactions …………………………………………………. 36
A4. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Recurring payments ………………………………………………. 37
Fig. A4.1. Share of payment instruments ……………………………………………………………………………….. 37
Fig. A4.2. Payments by type of bill (left panel) and breakdown by payment instrument (right panel):
number of transactions ………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 38
Fig. A4.3. Payments by type of bill (left panel) and breakdown by payment instrument (right panel):
value of transactions ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 38
A5. Consumers’ payment preferences in Italy ………………………………………………………………………. 39
Fig. A5.1. Preferred payment instrument by regional macro-area ……………………………………………. 39
Fig. A5.2. Preferred payment instrument by demographic ………………………………………………………. 39
Fig. A5.3. Preferred payment instrument by occupation …………………………………………………………. 40
Fig. A5.4. Preferred payment instrument by income group …………………………………………………….. 40
A6. Access to cash in Italy………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 41
Fig. A6.1.Ease of access to cash withdrawals at an ATM or a bank in Italy: 2019 vs 2022 data . 41
Fig. A6.2.Ease of access to cash withdrawals at an ATM or a bank by regional macro -area ……. 41
Fig. A6.3.Ease of access to cash withdrawals at an ATM or a bank by demographic ………………. 42
Fig. A6.4. Ease of access to cash withdrawals at an ATM or a bank by occupation …………………. 42
Fig. A6.5. Ease of access to cash withdrawals at an ATM or a bank by income group …………….. 43
Fig. A6.6. Share of respondents storing cash at home by regional macro -area and at national level
…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 44
Fig. A6.7. Share of respondents storing cash at home by demographic …………………………………… 44
Fig. A6.8. Share of respondents storing cash at home by occupation ………………………………………. 45
Fig. A6.9. Share of respondents storing cash at home by income group ………………………………….. 45
Fig. A6.10. Amount of extra cash held by those who reported storing cash at home by regional
macro-area and at national level ……………………………………………………………………………………………. 46
Fig. A6.11. The importance of having the option to pay with cash by regional macro -area and at
national level ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 46
Fig. A6.12. The importance of having the option to pay with cash by demographic ………………… 47
Fig. A6.13. The importance of having the option to pay with cash by occupation ……………………. 47
Fig. A6.14. The importance of having the option to pay with cash by income group ……………….. 48
A7. Access to payment instruments in Italy …………………………………………………………………………… 49
Fig. A7.1. Access to non-cash payment instruments – card possession by regional macro-area and
at national level …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 49
Fig. A7.2. Access to non-cash payment instruments – card possession by demographic ………….. 49
Fig. A7.3. Access to non-cash payment instruments – card possession by occupation ……………… 50
Fig. A7.4. Access to non-cash payment instruments – card possession by income group …………. 50
Fig. A7.5. Access to non-cash payment instruments – crypto users by regional macro-area and at
national level ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 51
Fig. A7.6. Access to non-cash payment instruments – crypto users by demographic ……………….. 51
Fig. A7.7. Access to non-cash payment instruments – crypto users by occupation ………………….. 52
Fig. A7.8. Access to non-cash payment instruments – crypto users by income group ………………. 52
A1. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Point of sale (POS)
Fig. A1.1
Share of payment instruments in POS transactions
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
A1. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Point of sale (POS)
Fig. A1.2
Frequency distribution of POS transaction value by payment instrument
(percentages, euro)
(a) Cash
(b) Cards
(c) Mobile
(d) Others
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
A1. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Point of sale (POS)
Fig. A1.3
Use of payment instruments by regional macro-area
(number of transactions, percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
Fig. A1.4
Use of payment instruments by regional macro-area
(value of transactions, percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
A1. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Point of sale (POS)
Fig. A1.5
Use of payment instruments by demographic
(number of transactions)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
Fig. A1.6
Use of payment instruments by demographic
(value of transactions)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
A1. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Point of sale (POS)
Fig. A1.7
Use of payment instruments by occupation
(number of transactions)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
Fig. A1.8
Use of payment instruments by occupation
(value of transactions)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
A1. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Point of sale (POS)
Fig. A1.9
Use of payment instruments by income group
(number of transactions)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
Fig. A1.10
Use of payment instruments by income group
(value of transactions)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
A1. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Point of sale (POS)
Fig. A1.11
Payments by place of purchase (left panel) and
by place of purchase and instrument (right panel)
(number of transactions, percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
Fig. A1.12
Payments by place of purchase (left panel) and
by place of purchase and instrument (right panel)
(value of transactions, percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
A1. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Point of sale (POS)
Fig. A1.13
Payment instruments by place of purchase
(a) Acceptance of alternative instruments
for cash-settled transactions
(percentages)
(b) Average transaction value
(euro)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Fig. A1.14
Frequency of cash usage compared to before the pandemic in Italy
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
A1. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Point of sale (POS)
Fig. A1.15
Reasons why making cash payments less often than before the pandemic in Italy
(percentages)
paying electronically has been made more convenient
the government recommended the use of cashless payments
the fear of being infected by the virus
the places where I buy goods or services strongly advise not to
other reasons
I discovered other means of payment
I cannot withdraw cash as easily as before the pandemic
the places where I buy goods or services no longer accept cash
don’t know
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
A2. Use of payment instruments in Italy – online payments
Fig. A2.1
Average value of transactions per payment instrument
(euro)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes bank cheques and other payment methods.
Fig. A2.2
Frequency of online payments compared to before the pandemic in Italy
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
A2. Use of payment instruments in Italy – online payments
Fig. A2.3
Payments by product type (left panel) and by product type and instrument (right panel)
(number of transactions, percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022). Percentages may not add up to 100% due to rounding.
Note: The ‘E-payment solutions’ cathegory includes PayPal and other online or mobile payment method (e.g. Klarna). The ‘Others’
cathegory includes direct debits, bank cheques, loyalty points, vouchers and gift cards, crypto assets and other payment instruments.
Fig. A2.4
Payments by product type (left panel) and by product type and instrument (right panel)
(value of transactions, percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022). Percentages may not add up to 100% due to rounding.
Note: The ‘E-payment solutions’ cathegory includes PayPal and other online or mobile payment method (e.g. Klarna). The ‘Others’
cathegory includes direct debits, bank cheques, loyalty points, vouchers and gift cards, crypto assets and other payment instruments.
A3. Use of payment instruments in Italy – P2P payments
Fig. A3.1
Share of payment instruments in P2P transactions
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes credit transfers, bank cheques and direct debits.
A4. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Recurring payments
Fig. A4.1
Share of payment instruments
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes bank cheques and mobile phone payments.
A4. Use of payment instruments in Italy – Recurring payments
Fig. A4.2
Payments by type of bill (left panel) and breakdown by payment instrument (right panel)
(number of transactions, percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes bank cheques and mobile phone payments.
Fig. A4.3
Payments by type of bill (left panel) and breakdown by payment instrument (right panel)
(value of transactions, percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022). Percentages may not add up to 100% due to rounding.
Note: the ‘Others’ cathegory includes bank cheques and mobile phone payments.
A5. Consumers’ payment preferences in Italy
Fig. A5.1
Preferred payment instrument by regional macro-area
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Fig. A5.2
Preferred payment instrument by demographic
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
A5. Consumers’ payment preferences in Italy
Fig. A5.3
Preferred payment instrument by occupation
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Fig. A5.4
Preferred payment instrument by income group
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
A6. Access to cash in Italy
Fig. A6.1
Ease of access to cash withdrawals at an ATM or a bank in Italy: 2019 vs 2022 data
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
Fig. A6.2
Ease of access to cash withdrawals at an ATM or a bank by regional macro-area
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
A6. Access to cash in Italy
Fig. A6.3
Ease of access to cash withdrawals at an ATM or a bank by demographic
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Fig. A6.4
Ease of access to cash withdrawals at an ATM or a bank by occupation
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
A6. Access to cash in Italy
Fig. A6.5
Ease of access to cash withdrawals at an ATM or a bank by income group
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
A6. Access to cash in Italy
Fig. A6.6
Share of respondents storing cash at home by regional macro-area and at national level
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
Fig. A6.7
Share of respondents storing cash at home by demographic
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
A6. Access to cash in Italy
Fig. A6.8
Share of respondents storing cash at home by occupation
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
Fig. A6.9
Share of respondents storing cash at home by income group
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
A6. Access to cash in Italy
Fig. A6.10
Amount of extra cash held by those who reported storing cash at home
by regional macro-area and at national level
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Note: the category “Up to EUR 500” is not shown in the graph, as it would be out of scale.
Fig. A6.11
The importance of having the option to pay with cash by regional macro-area and at national level
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE data (2022).
A6. Access to cash in Italy
Fig. A6.12
The importance of having the option to pay with cash by demographic
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
Fig. A6.13
The importance of having the option to pay with cash by occupation
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
A6. Access to cash in Italy
Fig. A6.14
The importance of having the option to pay with cash by income group
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2022).
A7. Access to payment instruments in Italy
Fig. A7.1
Access to non-cash payment instruments
Card possession by regional macro-area and at national level
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
Fig. A7.2
Access to non-cash payment instruments – card possession by demographic
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
A7. Access to payment instruments in Italy
Fig. A7.3
Access to non-cash payment instruments
Card possession by occupation
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
Fig. A7.4
Access to non-cash payment instruments
Card possession by income group
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
A7. Access to payment instruments in Italy
Fig. A7.5
Access to non-cash payment instruments
Crypto users by regional macro-area and at national level
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
Fig. A7.6
Access to non-cash payment instruments
Crypto users by demographic
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
A7. Access to payment instruments in Italy
Fig. A7.7
Access to non-cash payment instruments
Crypto users by occupation
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
Fig. A7.8
Access to non-cash payment instruments
Crypto users by income group
(percentages)
Source: authors’ calculations based on ECB SPACE survey data (2019 and 2022).
Papers published in the ‘Markets, Infrastructures, Payment Systems’ series
n. 1
TIPS – TARGET Instant Payment Settlement – The Pan-European Infrastructure for the
Settlement of Instant Paymentsi, by Massimiliano Renzetti, Serena Bernardini, Giuseppe
Marino, Luca Mibelli, Laura Ricciardi and Giovanni M. Sabelli (Institutional Issues)
n. 2
Real-Time Gross Settlement systems: breaking the wall of scalability and high availability,
by Mauro Arcese, Domenico Di Giulio and Vitangelo Lasorella (Research Papers)
n. 3
Green Bonds: the Sovereign Issuers’ Perspective, by Raffaele Doronzo, Vittorio Siracusa and
Stefano Antonelli (Research Papers)
n. 4
T2S – TARGET2-Securities – The pan-European platform for the settlement of securities in
central bank money, by Cristina Mastropasqua, Alessandro Intonti, Michael Jennings, Clara
Mandolini, Massimo Maniero, Stefano Vespucci and Diego Toma (Institutional Issues)
n. 5
The carbon footprint of the Target Instant Payment Settlement (TIPS) system: a comparative
analysis with Bitcoin and other infrastructures, by Pietro Tiberi (Research Papers)
n. 6
Proposal for a common categorisation of IT incidents, by Autorité de Contrôle Prudentiel et
de Résolution, Banca d’Italia, Commissione Nazionale per le Società e la Borsa, Deutsche
Bundesbank, European Central Bank, Federal Reserve Board, Financial Conduct Authority,
Ministero dell’Economia e delle Finanze, Prudential Regulation Authority, U.S. Treasury
(Institutional Issues)
n. 7
Inside the black box: tools for understanding cash circulation, by Luca Baldo, Elisa Bonifacio,
Marco Brandi, Michelina Lo Russo, Gianluca Maddaloni, Andrea Nobili, Giorgia Rocco,
Gabriele Sene and Massimo Valentini (Research Papers)
n. 8
The impact of the pandemic on the use of payment instruments in Italy, by Guerino Ardizzi,
Alessandro Gambini, Andrea Nobili, Emanuele Pimpini and Giorgia Rocco (Research Papers)
(in Italian)
n. 9
TARGET2 – The European system for large-value payments settlement, by Paolo Bramini,
Matteo Coletti, Francesco Di Stasio, Pierfrancesco Molina, Vittorio Schina and Massimo
Valentini (Institutional Issues) (in Italian)
n. 10
A digital euro: a contribution to the discussion on technical design choices, by Emanuele
Urbinati, Alessia Belsito, Daniele Cani, Angela Caporrini, Marco Capotosto, Simone Folino,
Giuseppe Galano, Giancarlo Goretti, Gabriele Marcelli, Pietro Tiberi and Alessia Vita
(Institutional Issues)
n. 11
From SMP to PEPP: a further look at the risk endogeneity of the Central Bank, by Marco
Fruzzetti, Giulio Gariano, Gerardo Palazzo and Antonio Scalia (Research Papers)
n. 12
TLTROs and collateral availability in Italy, by Annino Agnes, Paola Antilici and Gianluca
Mosconi (Research Papers) (in Italian)
n. 13
Overview of central banks’ in-house credit assessment systems in the euro area, by Laura
Auria, Markus Bingmer, Carlos Mateo Caicedo Graciano, Clémence Charavel, Sergio Gavilá,
Alessandra Iannamorelli, Aviram Levy, Alfredo Maldonado, Florian Resch, Anna Maria Rossi
and Stephan Sauer (Institutional Issues)
n. 14
The strategic allocation and sustainability of central banks’ investment, by Davide Di Zio,
Marco Fanari, Simone Letta, Tommaso Perez and Giovanni Secondin (Research Papers) (in
Italian)
n. 15
Climate and environmental risks: measuring the exposure of investments, by Ivan Faiella,
Enrico Bernardini, Johnny Di Giampaolo, Marco Fruzzetti, Simone Letta, Raffaele Loffredo
and Davide Nasti (Research Papers)
n. 16
Cross-Currency Settlement of Instant Payments in a Multi-Currency Clearing and Settlement
Mechanism, by Massimiliano Renzetti, Fabrizio Dinacci and Ann Börestam (Research Papers)
n. 17
What’s ahead for euro money market benchmarks?, by Daniela Della Gatta (Institutional
Issues) (in Italian)
n. 18
Cyber resilience per la continuità di servizio del sistema finanziario, by Boris Giannetto
and Antonino Fazio (Institutional Issues) (in Italian)
n. 19
Cross-Currency Settlement of Instant Payments in a Cross-Platform Context: a Proof of
Concept, by Massimiliano Renzetti, Andrea Dimartina, Riccardo Mancini, Giovanni Sabelli,
Francesco Di Stasio, Carlo Palmers, Faisal Alhijawi, Erol Kaya, Christophe Piccarelle, Stuart
Butler, Jwallant Vasani, Giancarlo Esposito, Alberto Tiberino and Manfredi Caracausi
(Research Papers)
n. 20
Flash crashes on sovereign bond markets – EU evidence, by Antoine Bouveret, Martin
Haferkorn, Gaetano Marseglia and Onofrio Panzarino (Research Papers)
n. 21 Report on the payment attitudes of consumers in Italy: results from ECB surveys,
by Gabriele Coletti, Alberto Di Iorio, Emanuele Pimpini and Giorgia Rocco (Institutional
Issues)
n. 22
When financial innovation and sustainable finance meet: Sustainability-Linked Bonds,
by Paola Antilici, Gianluca Mosconi and Luigi Russo (Institutional Issues) (in Italian)
n. 23
Business models and pricing strategies in the market for ATM withdrawals, by Guerino
Ardizzi and Massimiliano Cologgi (Research Papers)
n. 24
Press news and social media in credit risk assessment: the experience of Banca d’Italia’s
In?house Credit Assessment System, by Giulio Gariano and Gianluca Viggiano (Research
Papers)
n. 25
The bonfire of banknotes, by Michele Manna (Research Papers)
n. 26
Integrating DLTs with market infrastructures: analysis and proof-of-concept for secure DvP
between TIPS and DLT platforms, by Rosario La Rocca, Riccardo Mancini, Marco Benedetti,
Matteo Caruso, Stefano Cossu, Giuseppe Galano, Simone Mancini, Gabriele Marcelli, Piero
Martella, Matteo Nardelli and Ciro Oliviero (Research Papers)
n. 27
Statistical and forecasting use of electronic payment transactions: collaboration between
Bank of Italy and Istat, by Guerino Ardizzi and Alessandra Righi (Institutional Issues) (in
Italian)
n. 28
TIPS: a zero-downtime platform powered by automation, by Gianluca Caricato, Marco
Capotosto, Silvio Orsini and Pietro Tiberi (Research Papers)
n. 29
TARGET2 analytical tools for regulatory compliance, by Marc Glowka, Alexander Müller,
Livia Polo Friz, Sara Testi, Massimo Valentini and Stefano Vespucci (Institutional Issues)
n. 30
The security of retail payment instruments: evidence from supervisory data, by Massimiliano
Cologgi (Research Papers)
n. 31
Open Banking in the payment system: infrastructural evolution, innovation and security,
supervisory and oversight practices, by Roberto Pellitteri, Ravenio Parrini, Carlo Cafarotti
and Benedetto Andrea De Vendictis (Institutional Issues) (in Italian)
n. 32
Banks’ liquidity transformation rate: determinants and impact on lending, by Raffaele Lenzi,
Stefano Nobili, Filippo Perazzoli and Rosario Romeo (Research Papers)
n. 33
Investor behavior under market stress: evidence from the Italian sovereign bond market, by
Onofrio Panzarino (Research Papers)
n. 34
Siamese neural networks for detecting banknote printing defects, by Katia Boria, Andrea
Luciani, Sabina Marchetti and Marco Viticoli (Research Papers) (in Italian)
n. 35
Quantum safe payment systems, by Elena Bucciol and Pietro Tiberi
n. 36
Investigating the determinants of corporate bond credit spreads in the euro area, by Simone
Letta and Pasquale Mirante
n. 37
Smart Derivative Contracts in DatalogMTL, by Andrea Colombo, Luigi Bellomarini, Stefano
Ceri and Eleonora Laurenza
n. 38
Making it through the (crypto) winter: facts, figures and policy issues, by Guerino Ardizzi,
Marco Bevilacqua, Emanuela Cerrato and Alberto Di Iorio
n. 39
The Emissions Trading System of the European Union (EU ETS), by Mauro Bufano, Fabio
Capasso, Johnny Di Giampaolo and Nicola Pellegrini (in Italian)
n. 40
Banknote migration and the estimation of circulation in euro area countries: the italian
case, by Claudio Doria, Gianluca Maddaloni, Giuseppina Marocchi, Ferdinando Sasso,
Luca Serrai and Simonetta Zappa (in Italian)
n. 41
Assessing credit risk sensitivity to climate and energy shocks, by Stefano Di Virgilio, Ivan
Faiella, Alessandro Mistretta and Simone Narizzano
Trending
- CORRI LIBERA, RAUTI: LA DIFESA PER LA CULTURA DEL RISPETTO DONNE
- LUCA ZINGARETTI IN VISITA ALLA MOSTRA DI PALAZZO DEI DIAMANTI. UN RITORNO NELLA CITTÀ DEL SUO ESORDIO AL CINEMA. L’ATTORE IN QUESTI GIORNI A FERRARA PER “MARCO POLO E LE CITTÀ INVISIBILI”, IN SCENA AL TEATRO COMUNALE
- MANOVRA: BERGAMINI, “FORZA ITALIA LAVORA PER MIGLIORARLA, IL CAMPO LARGO PENSA A NUOVE TASSE
- GIORNATA VITTIME STRADA. DE CORATO (FDI): SICUREZZA È PRIORITÀ PER GOVERNO MELONI
- Le Commissioni consiliari di lunedì 16 novembre
- Emergenza abitativa, lunedì a Forlì il convegno sul Piano Casa. Tassinari «Più garanzie ai proprietari per rimettere in affitto le case sfitte»
- FERRARA, FABBRI SECONDO TRA I SINDACI DEI COMUNI TRA 120MILA E 260MILA ABITANTI CON IL 58,5% DI GRADIMENTO SECONDO IL SONDAGGIO LAB21. SINDACO: “UN RISULTATO CHE MI RENDE FELICE. IL CONSENSO VA CONQUISTATO OGNI GIORNO
- Domenica ecologica, oltre mille alberi e piantine donati ai cittadini al Parco San Giuliano
- MANIFESTAZIONI A PARMA, RUSSO (FDI): GRAZIE A FORZE DELL’ORDINE, SMENTITA LA NARRAZIONE DI UN GOVERNO CHE REPRIME IL DISSENSO
- NEWS RELEASE: Six months on, accessing hard-to-reach communities key to halting Ebola outbreak