(AGENPARL) - Roma, 26 Settembre 2024 - (AGENPARL) – gio 26 settembre 2024 Newsletter
Week XL – XLI: 30th September to 11th October 2024
Contact us
@ENDesk
Jacques René
Zammit
Press Officer
Monica Pizzo
Assistant
Desk Email
Follow
@EUCourtPress
on X (formerly
Twitter)
Download our
Week XL: 30th September to 4th October
Wednesday 2nd October
General Court
Judgments in Cases T-797/22 Ordre néerlandais des avocats du barreau de
Bruxelles and Others v Council, T-798/22 Ordre des avocats à la cour de Paris and
Couturier v Council and T-828/22 ACE v Council
(External relations – Common foreign and security policy – Restrictive measures – Ukraine)
In 2022, in response to Russia’s escalating aggression against Ukraine, the Council of
the European Union adopted a series of restrictive measures designed to put pressure
on Russia to end its war of aggression. The measures include a ban on the provision of
legal advice.
Subject to certain exceptions and exemptions, these acts prohibit any person who
may provide legal advice (including those practising within the EU) from providing such
services to the Russian government and to legal persons, entities or bodies
established in Russia. The prohibition is intended to make it more difficult for the
Russian Government and Russian companies to obtain goods and services or capital in
the EU, by depriving them of the technical and legal assistance necessary for such
operations.
The Dutch Bar Association of the Brussels Bar, the Paris Bar Association and Julie
Couturier (a lawyer registered with the Bar Association), as well as the trade
association Avocats Ensemble (ACE), applied to the General Court of the European
Union for the ban to be annulled.
In their view, the ban lacked a statement of reasons and infringed their fundamental
rights (access to legal advice from a lawyer and interference with professional secrecy)
as well as the principle of proportionality.
All times are 9:30
Furthermore, such a ban would infringe the right of lawyers to provide legal advice
unless otherwise
without any particular restrictions.
stated.
Background Documents T-797/22
Communications Directorate
Press and Information unit
curia.europa.eu
Newsletter
Week XL – XLI: 30th September to 11th October 2024
Don’t forget to
Background Documents T-798/22
check the diary
Background Documents T-828/22
on our website
for details of
other cases.
There will be one press release for these cases.
Friday 4th October
Judgments in Joined Cases C-541/20 to C-555/20 Lithuania, Bulgaria, Romania,
Cyprus, Hungary, Malta and Poland v Parliament and Council (Mobility Package)
(Transport)
Lithuania, Bulgaria, Romania, the Republic of Cyprus, Hungary, Malta and Poland have
brought actions before the Court of Justice for annulment of the ‘Mobility Package’,
which was adopted by the EU legislature, i.e. the Parliament and the Council, in 2020.
The package encompasses several pieces of legislation:
1) Regulation (EU) 2020/1054 amending Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 as regards
minimum requirements on maximum daily and weekly driving times,
minimum breaks and daily and weekly rest periods and Regulation (EU) No
165/2014 as regards positioning by means of tachographs;
2) Regulation (EU) 2020/1055 amending Regulations (EC) No 1071/2009, (EC) No
1072/2009 and (EU) No 1024/2012 with a view to adapting them to
developments in the road transport sector;
3) Directive (EU) 2020/1057 laying down specific rules with respect to Directive
96/71/EC and Directive 2014/67/EU for posting drivers in the road transport
sector and amending Directive 2006/22/EC as regards enforcement
requirements and Regulation (EU) No 1024/2012.
In particular, these Member States are challenging:
the ban on drivers taking the normal weekly rest period or compensatory rest
period on board the vehicle;
the obligation for transport undertakings to organise their drivers’ work in
such a way that drivers are able to return, during working time, every three or
four weeks to the undertaking’s operational centre or to their place of
residence, in order to start or spend at least their normal or compensatory
weekly rest period there;
bringing forward the date of entry into force of the obligation to install secondgeneration intelligent tachographs and, in general, the date of entry into force
of Regulation 2020/1054 providing for the prohibition and obligations
mentioned above;
the obligation, for vehicles used for international transport, to return to an
operational centre located in the Member State of establishment of the
transport undertaking concerned every eight weeks;
the obligation for transport undertakings to have at their disposal on a regular
Newsletter
Week XL – XLI: 30th September to 11th October 2024
and continuous basis a number of vehicles and drivers who are normally
attached to an operational centre in their Member State of establishment, in
both cases in proportion to the number of transport operations they carry out;
the four-day waiting period during which, following a cabotage round in a host
Member State, (non-resident) hauliers are not authorised to carry out
cabotage operations with the same vehicle in the same Member State;
the qualification of drivers of posted workers, so that they benefit from the
working and employment conditions, in particular as regards pay, in the host
Member State, in principle when they carry out cabotage operations, transport
operations from one country to another, none of which is the Member State of
establishment, or certain combined transport operations.
Background Documents C-541/20
Background Documents C-542/20
Background Documents C-543/20
Background Documents C-544/20
Background Documents C-545/20
Background Documents C-546/20
Background Documents C-547/20
Background Documents C-548/20
Background Documents C-549/20
Background Documents C-550/20
Background Documents C-551/20
Background Documents C-552/20
Background Documents C-553/20
Background Documents C-554/20
Background Documents C-555/20
There will be a press release for these cases.
Friday 4th October
Judgment in Case C-581/22 P thyssenkrupp v Commission
(Competition)
Thyssenkrupp, a German industrial group, and Tata Steel, a company headquartered
in India, are active in the manufacture and supply of flat carbon steel and magnetic
steel products. Their production centres are located in Germany, the United Kingdom
and the Netherlands respectively. The companies also have finishing plants in other
Member States.
On September 25, 2018, the two companies notified the Commission under the
Merger Regulation of their plans to acquire joint control of a newly created joint
venture. The project mainly concerned metal-coated and rolled steel products for
Newsletter
Week XL – XLI: 30th September to 11th October 2024
packaging and hot-dip galvanised steel products used in the automotive sector.
Following discussions with the companies involved and requests for information from
a number of market participants, including competitors and customers, the
Commission declared the transaction incompatible with the internal market and the
European Economic Area by decision of June 11, 2019 (see summary of the decision).
Thyssenkrupp brought an action for annulment of the Commission’s decision before
the General Court of the European Union. In its judgment of June 22, 2022, the
General Court rejected all the arguments put forward by the company and confirmed
the Commission’s decision (T-584/19, see also press release 110/22).
Thyssenkrupp then appealed to the Court of Justice against the judgment of the
General Court.
Background Documents C-581/22 P
There will be a press release for this case.
Friday 4th October
Judgments in Joined Cases C-29/23 P Ferriera Valsabbia and Valsabbia
Investimenti v Commission and C-30/23 P Alfa Acciai v Commission and Case C31/23 P Ferriere Nord v Commission
(Competition)
In 2002, the European Commission fined eight companies and an association of
companies for an anti-competitive cartel on the Italian concrete reinforcing bar market
between December 1989 and July 2000 (see Commission Decision of 17 December
2002).
In 2007, the General Court annulled this decision on the grounds that its legal basis
was no longer in force at the time of its adoption, the ECSC Treaty having expired on
July 23, 2002 (see judgments October 25, 2007, SP and Others v Commission: joint
cases T-27/03, T-46/03, T-58/03, T-79/03, T-80/03, T-97/03, T-98/03, as well as T-45/03,
T-77/03 and T-94/03 – press release n. 78/07).
Subsequently, on September 30, 2009, the Commission adopted a new decision,
addressed to the same undertakings as those referred to in the 2002 decision and
essentially repeating its content and conclusions. In particular, the fines imposed
remained unchanged.
Confirmed in principle by the General Court (see judgments of December 9, 2014 T472/09 and T-55/10, T-69/10, T-70/10, T-83/10, T-85/10, T-90/10, T-91/10, T-92/10, T4
Newsletter
Week XL – XLI: 30th September to 11th October 2024
489/09, T-490/09 and T-56/10), the 2009 decision was annulled by the Court of Justice
in respect of five undertakings because of irregularities in the administrative
procedure leading to its adoption (see Judgments September 21, 2017, Ferriera
Valsabbia and Others v Commission, C-85/15 P, C-86/15 P, C-87/15 P, C-88/15 P and C89/15 P).
Once this procedure had been resumed, on July 4, 2019 the Commission adopted a
decision re-establishing the infringement that was the subject of the 2009 decision
(see summary).
This decision was addressed to the five undertakings for which the 2009 decision had
been annulled. In view of the length of the procedure, the fines were reduced by 50%.
In September 2019, three of these companies – Ferriera Valsabbia SpA and Valsabia
investimenti SpA, Alfa Acciai SpA and Ferriere Nord SpA – appealed to have the 2019
decision annulled.
Having been unsuccessful before the General Court (see judgments Ferriera Valsabbia
and Valsabbia Investimenti v Commission T-655/19, Alfa Acciai/Commission T-656/19
and Ferriere Nord/Commission T-667/19), they have appealed to the Court of Justice.
Background Documents C-29/23 P and C-30/23 P
Background Documents C-31/23 P
There will be one press release for these cases.
Friday 4th October
Judgment in Case C-240/23 Herbaria Kräuterparadies II
(Agriculture and Fisheries)
The request for a preliminary ruling of the Federal Administrative Court, Germany
concerns the interpretation of different articles of Regulation (EU) 2018/848 on organic
production and labelling of organic products as well as of Article 20 of the Charter of
Fundamental Rights of the European Union.
This reference for a preliminary ruling is made in proceedings between Herbaria
Kräuterparadies GmbH, a company incorporated under German law (‘Herbaria’), and
the Land of Bavaria, Germany, concerning the possibility of using the organic
production method in the labelling, advertising and marketing of a mixture of fruit
juices and herbal extracts.
Herbaria is the manufacturer of ‘Blutquick’, a blend of fruit juices and herbal extracts
containing, in addition to organic plant products, non-organic vitamins and iron
Newsletter
Week XL – XLI: 30th September to 11th October 2024
gluconate. Blutquick is presented and marketed as a food supplement. Its packaging
contains the organic production logo of the European Union, the national organic label
and a reference to the origin of the ingredients from ‘controlled organic cultivation’.
Since 2012, Herbaria has disputed the decision of the Land of Bavaria prohibiting it
from using the reference to the organic production method in the labelling,
advertising and marketing of a mixture of fruit juice and herb extracts which contains,
in addition to the organic products, non-plant vitamins and ferrous gluconate not
coming from organic farming.
A first judgment of the Court of Justice confirmed the Land of Bavaria’s interpretation
that the organic production logo of the European Union and any reference to organic
production could not be used in such a situation (C-137/13).
Herbaria accepted that decision and relies on a breach of equality between its product
and a similar American product to which non-organic non-plant vitamins and ferrous
gluconate are added, but which is recognised as originating from organic production
in the United States of America and which, on that basis, may be marketed on the
territory of the European Union with the organic production logo of the European
Union by reason of the recognition of the United States as a non-EU country whose
rules on production and control are equivalent.
The request by the referring court will allow the Court to clarify the use that must be
made of the organic production logo of the European Union in the event of imports of
products originating from organic farming.
Background Documents C-240/23
There will be a press release for this case.
Friday 4th October
Judgment in Case C-4/23 Mirin
(Citizenship of the Union)
A Romanian citizen was registered as female at birth in Romania.
After moving to the United Kingdom (UK), he acquired British nationality while
retaining his Romanian nationality. It was in this country that, in 2017, he changed his
first name and civil title from female to male and, in 2020, obtained legal recognition
of his male gender identity.
In May 2021, on the basis of two documents obtained in the UK attesting to these
changes, this citizen asked the Romanian administrative authorities to enter in his
birth certificate the particulars relating to his change of forename, sex and personal
Newsletter
Week XL – XLI: 30th September to 11th October 2024
identification number so that it corresponded to the male sex.
He also asked them to issue him with a new birth certificate containing these new
details. However, the Romanian authorities refused his requests while inviting him to
follow a new legal procedure in Romania, aimed directly at obtaining approval for the
change of sex.
Relying on his right to move and reside freely within the territory of the European
Union, the citizen concerned asked a Bucharest court to order that his birth certificate
be brought into line with his new forename and his gender identity, which had been
definitively recognised in the UK.
The court asked the Court of Justice whether the national legislation on which the
Romanian authorities’ refusal was based complied with EU law and whether Brexit
had any impact on the case.
Background Documents C-4/23
There will be a press release for this case.
Friday 4th October
Judgment in Case C-650/22 FIFA
(Freedom of movement for persons)
A former professional footballer is challenging the rules governing contractual
relations between players and clubs. The rules in question, entitled ‘Regulations on the
Status and Transfer of Players’ (RSTP), were adopted by the Fédération Internationale
de Football Association (FIFA) – an association responsible for organising football
competitions at world level.
These rules that are implemented both by FIFA and by its member national football
associations apply, among other things, to a situation where there is a dispute
between a player and a club as to a termination of a contract without just cause. In
such cases, that player and any club wishing to employ him are jointly and severally
liable for any compensation due to his former club.
The player and the new club are also liable to sporting and financial sanctions in case
of non-compliance. Furthermore, the association to which the player’s former club
belongs may refuse to deliver an International Transfer Certificate to the new
association where the player’s new club is registered as long as the dispute with the
former club is standing.
The professional football player had signed for the Russian football club Lokomotiv
Newsletter
Week XL – XLI: 30th September to 11th October 2024
Moscow only to see that contract terminated by this club one year later for an alleged
breach “and termination of contract without just cause”.
Lokomotiv Moscow applied to the FIFA Dispute Resolution Chamber for compensation
and the player submitted a counterclaim seeking compensation of unpaid wages. The
player claims that the search for a new club proved to be difficult because, under the
RSTP, any new club would be held jointly and severally liable with himself to pay any
compensation due to Lokomotiv Moscow.
He claims that a potential deal with Belgian club Sporting du Pays de Charleroi fell
through because of the RSTP conditions and he sued FIFA and URBSFA (the governing
body for Belgian football) before a Belgian court for damages and loss of earnings of
€6 million.
Background Documents C-650/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Friday 4th October
Judgment in Case C-446/21 Schrems (Communication of data to the general
public)
(Principles, objectives and tasks of the Treaties – Data protection)
Maximilian Schrems is challenging Meta Platforms Ireland’s unlawful processing of his
Trending
- Governo: Toccalini (Lega): Schlein fa fantapolitica, si inventa crisi che esistono solo nella sua immaginazione
- Revolut, Melchiorre (FdI): acquisire gli atti della Procura di Milano prima di definire il calendario delle nuove audizioni
- CIRCHI: M5S, GOVERNO TRADISCE LEGGE E ANIMALI, SERVE RICONVERSIONE NON PROROGARE SFRUTTAMENTO (1)
- PEREGO (DIFESA): PARTECIPAZIONE AL SECONDO ROUND TABLE ITALIA-GERMANIA
- Russia e Cina, Putin propone di ampliare la cooperazione sulla rotta artica
- Bardi: fondi per la ricerca in Basilicata
- DL SCUOLA, BUCALO (FDI): STRUTTURALE RECLUTAMENTO DALLE GPS PER POSTI COMUNI E SOSTEGNO
- TAXI E NCC, FDSE ALLA FIRMA E RENT OPERATIVO: IL MIT AL LAVORO SUL CARO CARBURANTI
- Cybersicurezza, Lisei (FdI): per governo Meloni è priorità
- Ronzulli (FI), sinistra vorrebbe sicurezza nazionale a costo zero
