(AGENPARL) - Roma, 5 Settembre 2024 - (AGENPARL) – gio 05 settembre 2024 PRESS RELEASE No 131/24
Luxembourg, 5 September 2024
Judgment of the Court in Joined Cases C-498/22 to C-500/22 | Novo Banco and Others
A failure to publish reorganisation measures in respect of a credit
institution does not lead to those measures being invalid or their effects
being unenforceable in another Member State
In August 2014, the Bank of Portugal adopted resolution measures in respect of the Portuguese credit institution
Banco Espírito Santo SA (BES), which was experiencing serious financial difficulties. In that context, the bridge bank
Novo Banco was set up. The assets, liabilities and other off-balance sheet items of BES were transferred to Novo
Banco. Certain liabilities were nevertheless excluded from that transfer and remained part of the assets and
liabilities of BES.
In October 2014, the Bank of Spain published information about the transfer in part of the business of BES to Novo
Banco in so far as concerned Spain. It stated that Novo Banco would continue the ordinary business of BES without
interruption and that the measure in question was deemed to be a reorganisation measure within the meaning of
the directive on the reorganisation and winding up of credit institutions 1.
In December 2015, the Bank of Portugal adopted two decisions to amend and clarify its decision of August 2014 in
relation to the liabilities of BES that had not been transferred to Novo Banco.
A number of customers of Novo Banco’s Spanish branch took the view that Novo Banco had assumed the
responsibilities associated with various contracts for financial products and services that they had concluded
previously with BES Spain 2. In response to Novo Banco’s refusal to assume those responsibilities, the customers
brought legal proceedings.
In that context, the Spanish Supreme Court is uncertain about the obligation on the Spanish courts to recognise the
effects of the reorganisation measures adopted by the Bank of Portugal, because those measures were not
published as provided for in the directive. The Supreme Court has referred a number of questions to the Court of
Justice for a preliminary ruling in that regard.
In its judgment, the Court answers that such a failure to publish by the authorities of the home Member State
(Portugal) does not lead to the measures being invalid or its effects being unenforceable in the host Member
State (Spain).
Where the measures are not published, the law of the home Member State must enable the persons affected in the
host Member State to lodge an appeal against the reorganisation measures within a reasonable period from the
time at which they were notified of those measures or at which they became aware of or should reasonably have
become aware of them.
Last, the recognition in Spain of the effects of the reorganisation measures adopted in Portugal, which provide that
the obligation to pay sums payable as a result of pre-contractual or contractual liability is retained in the liabilities of
BES, does not appear to infringe the principle of legal certainty, the right to property or the principle of
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
consumer protection. In that regard, the Court notes in particular that those measures meet the general
interest objective of ensuring the stability of the banking system and preventing a systemic risk, which is
also pursued by the European Union.
NOTE: A reference for a preliminary ruling allows the courts and tribunals of the Member States, in disputes which
have been brought before them, to refer questions to the Court of Justice about the interpretation of European
Union law or the validity of a European Union act. The Court of Justice does not decide the dispute itself. It is for the
national court or tribunal to dispose of the case in accordance with the Court’s decision, which is similarly binding on
other national courts or tribunals before which a similar issue is raised.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice.
The full text and, as the case may be, the abstract of the judgment are published on the CURIA website on the day of
delivery.
Stay Connected!
Directive 2001/24/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 4 April 2001 on the reorganisation and winding up of credit institutions.
These were: a loan contract secured by way of a mortgage containing a ‘floor’ clause, specifying a minimum interest rate of 2% (Case C-498/22); an
atypical financial contract, which was a high risk, complex financial product with a variable interest rate indexed to the shares of other credit
institutions (Case C-499/22); and a €100 000 senior bond, issued by BES. At the time it was acquired by the customer, that bond formed part of the
assets and liabilities of Novo Banco, to which the related liability had been transferred pursuant to the August 2014 decision (Case C-500/22).
Communications Directorate
Trending
- SAISON CULTURELLE 2026/2027 – Musica, comicità e opera lirica: i prossimi appuntamenti della sezione Spectacle della Saison Culturelle 2026/2027
- L’abete di Terranova del Pollino in piazza San Pietro
- News Release – City of Toronto ushers in the 2026-2030 Toronto City Council term
- Agenzia nr. 2187 – Insediamento nuovo Procuratore Aggiunto a Brindisi. Caroli: ‘Ampia disponibilità e massima sinergia con la Commissione
- Antisemitismo, Cecchetti (Lega): Piena solidarietà a Meghnagi e Fadlun. Vili minacce che confermano la necessità della legge
- Agenzia nr. 2186 – Vurchio: “Fare impresa nella Bat deve tornare a essere un’opportunità. Serve una strategia per il territorio
- AGENDA CAMERA DI DOMANI, VENERDÌ 20 NOVEMBRE
- Agenzia nr. 2185 – JTF Taranto. Fischetti: “Altri 4 milioni di euro per la formazione e il reinserimento lavorativo
- MANOVRA Nazionale, ANCE Enna: CAMBIARE NORMA SUPERBONUS PER SALVAGUARDARE LE IMPRESE
- MILLEPROROGHE, ZANGRILLO: “AL LAVORO PER STABILIZZARE PERSONALE ASSUNTO COL PATTO PER NAPOLI, IMPORTANTE INVESTIMENTO IN CAPITALE UMANO”
