(AGENPARL) - Roma, 5 Settembre 2024 - (AGENPARL) – gio 05 settembre 2024 Newsletter
Week XXXVII – XXXVIII: 9th to 20th September 2024
Contact us
@ENDesk
Jacques René
Zammit
Press Officer
Monica Pizzo
Assistant
Desk Email
Follow
@EUCourtPress
on X (formerly
Twitter)
Download our
Week XXXIV 9th to 13th September
Tuesday 10th September
Judgment in Case C-465/20 P Commission v Ireland and Others
(Competition – State aid)
Tax rulings make it possible for undertakings to apply to the tax authority for an
advance decision concerning the tax treatment to which they will be subject.
In 1991 and 2007, Ireland issued two tax rulings in relation to two companies of the
Apple Group (Apple Sales International – ASI and Apple Operations Europe – AOE),
incorporated under Irish law but not tax resident in Ireland. The rulings approved the
method by which ASI and AOE proposed to determine their chargeable profits in
Ireland deriving from the activity of their Irish branches.
In 2016, the European Commission declared incompatible with the internal market the
aid that Ireland had allegedly granted to the Apple group through two advance tax
rulings, known as ‘tax rulings’, issued in 1991 and 2007 by its tax authorities in favour
of ASI and AOE. It ordered Ireland to recover that aid (Commission Decision (EU)
2017/1283).
The tax rulings concerned the determination of the taxable profits of ASI and AOE in
Ireland, in accordance with the proposals made in this respect by representatives of
the Apple group. According to the Commission’s estimates, Ireland granted €13 billion
in illegal tax advantages to Apple.
In 2020, the General Court annulled the Commission’s decision, finding that the
Commission had not shown that there was an advantage deriving from the adoption
of the tax rulings (see judgment T-778/16, Ireland v Commission and T-892/16, Apple
Sales International and Apple Operations Europe v Commission; see also press release
No 90/20).
All times are 9:30
The Commission lodged an appeal with the Court of Justice, asking it to set aside the
unless otherwise
judgment of the General Court.
stated.
Background Documents C-465/20 P
Communications Directorate
Press and Information unit
curia.europa.eu
Newsletter
Week XXXVII – XXXVIII: 9th to 20th September 2024
Don’t forget to
There will be a press release for this case.
check the diary
on our website
for details of
other cases.
Tuesday 10th September
Judgment in Joined Cases C-29/22 P KS and KD v Council and Others and C-44/22 P
Commission v KS and Others
(External relations – Common foreign and security policy – Fundamental rights)
In 2008, the European Union set up a civilian rule of law mission, known as Eulex
Kosovo, tasked in particular with investigating crimes and people who disappeared or
were killed in Kosovo in 1999 during the conflict there.
In 2009, the EU set up a Human Rights Monitoring Commission to examine complaints
of human rights violations committed by Eulex Kosovo in the exercise of its mandate.
Following complaints lodged by KS and KD, between November 2015 and October
2016, the Control Commission concluded that several fundamental rights had been
violated.
In March 2017, the Commission closed the cases in question, while noting that the
head of Eulex Kosovo had only partially implemented the recommendations it had
made.
KS and KD have taken the Council, the European Commission and the European
External Action Service to the EU General Court.
They are seeking compensation for the damage they believe they have suffered as a
result of various acts and omissions relating, in particular, to the investigations carried
out during the Eulex Kosovo mission.
In December 2017, the Court declared itself manifestly incompetent to hear this
action.
In June 2021, KS and KD filed an application for measures of inquiry, seeking the
production of the full version of Eulex Kosovo’s plan of operation (see Order of
December 14, 2017, KS/Conseil and Others T-840/16).
In November 2021, the General Court dismissed this application, also on the grounds
that it clearly lacked jurisdiction to hear it (see Order of November 10, 2021 KS et
KD/Conseil and Others T?771/20).
The Court of Justice has been called to rule on these appeals.
Background Documents C-29/22 P and C-44/22 P
Newsletter
Week XXXVII – XXXVIII: 9th to 20th September 2024
There will be a press release for this case.
Tuesday 10th September
Judgment in Case C-351/22 Neves 77 Solutions
(External Relations – Common Foreign and Security Policy – Restrictive Measures Ukraine)
Neves 77 Solutions SRL (Neves), a Romanian company specialising in brokering
aviation products, acted as an intermediary in a transaction between a Ukrainian
company, SFTE Spetstechnoexport, and an Indian company for the sale of 32 radio
stations, 20 of which were manufactured in Russia.
In July 2019, the Romanian authorities informed Neves that the brokerage activities
related to these products were covered by the ban on providing intermediation
services related to military equipment to an operator in Russia, adopted by the
European Union in response to Russia’s actions destabilising the situation in Ukraine
(Council Decision 2014/512/CFSP and successive amendments).
In August 2019, Neves received nearly €3 million from SFTE for the provision of its
intermediation services. In May 2020, the Romanian authorities fined Neves 30,000 lei
(approximately €6,000) and confiscated the entire amount it had received from SFTE
on the grounds that the provision of its brokerage services was in breach of the
aforementioned prohibition.
The Bucharest District Court asked the Court of Justice whether that prohibition
applied to a situation where the equipment concerned had never been imported into
the European Union and whether the penalties imposed for breach of that prohibition
were compatible with the property rights of the undertaking concerned.
Background Documents C-351/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Tuesday 10th September
Judgment in Case C-48/22 P Google and Alphabet v Commission (Google
Shopping)
(Competition – Dominant position)
By decision of June 27, 2017, the Commission found that Google had favoured, on its
general search results page, the results of its own product comparator over those of
competing product comparators.
Newsletter
Week XXXVII – XXXVIII: 9th to 20th September 2024
Google presented the search results of its product comparator in the first position and
highlighted them in the “Shopping Units” with attractive visual and textual
information. In contrast, search results from competing product comparators only
appeared in a lower position, as a blue link.
The Commission concluded that Google had abused its dominant position on the
market for general Internet search services and on the market for specialised product
search services, and imposed a fine of €2,424,495,000, for which Alphabet, as Google’s
sole shareholder, was jointly and severally liable to pay €523,518,000.
Google and Alphabet challenged the Commission’s decision before the General Court
of the European Union. By judgment of November 10, 2021 (T-612/17, see also press
release No 197/21), the General Court dismissed the action and confirmed the fine.
However, the General Court found that it had not been established that Google’s
practice had had even potential anti-competitive effects on the general search market.
Consequently, it annulled the Commission’s decision insofar as it found an
infringement of the prohibition on abuse of a dominant position also in relation to
that market.
Google and Alphabet then appealed to the Court, asking the Court to set aside the
judgment of the General Court in so far as it dismissed their appeal and to annul the
Commission’s decision.
Background Documents C-48/22 P
There will be a press release for this case.
Wednesday 11th September
General Court
Judgment in Case T-494/22 NSD v Council
(External Relations – Common Foreign and Security Policy – Restrictive Measures Ukraine)
NKO AO National Settlement Depository (NSD) is a company incorporated under
Russian law as a licensed depository, providing securities archiving and custody
services as well as a central depository. It also provides financial services, in particular
as a non-bank credit institution licensed to provide bank settlement services.
In June 2022, NSD was included on the list of legal entities subject to the restrictive
measures adopted by the European Union following Russia’s aggression against
Ukraine, and its funds were frozen according to Council Decision (CFSP) 2022/883
amending Decision 2014/145/CFSP and Council Implementing Regulation (EU)
2022/878 implementing Regulation (EU) No 269/2014.
Newsletter
Week XXXVII – XXXVIII: 9th to 20th September 2024
The Council’s reasons for listing NSD state, among other things, that it is the main
custodian of Russian securities, has access to the international financial system, and is
recognised as a systemically important financial institution playing an essential role in
the functioning of the Russian financial system, hence directly or indirectly enabling
the Russian government to carry out its activities and policies and to mobilise its
resources.
By virtue of the maintenance acts adopted in March and September 2023 (Council
Decision (CFSP) 2023/572 and Council Implementing Regulation (EU) 2023/571, the
Council extended the measures taken in respect of NSD until March 15, 2024.
NSD asked the General Court of the European Union to annul the acts by which it was
included on the list of persons subject to restrictive measures.
Background Documents T-494/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Wednesday 11th September
General Court
Judgment in Case T-671/19 Qualcomm v Commission (Qualcomm – predatory
pricing)
(Competition – Dominant position)
Qualcomm is an American company founded in 1985, active in cellular and wireless
technologies. Qualcomm’s chips are sold (and its system software licensed) to
companies that use them to equip mobile phones, tablets, laptops, data modules and
other electronic consumer goods.
On June 30, 2009, the UK company Icera lodged a complaint with the European
Commission against Qualcomm, revised and updated on April 8, 2010, on the basis of
which the Commission began its investigation.
In 2012, the intervener, the US company Nvidia, which had acquired Icera in May 2011,
provided additional information, incorporating the complaint and making allegations
of predatory pricing against Qualcomm.
Between June 2010 and July 2015, the Commission sent several requests for
information to Qualcomm, Icera or Nvidia and other players in the baseband chips
sector. In the following years, the Commission completed its investigation by sending
additional requests for information, issuing statements of objections and holding
hearings.
Newsletter
Week XXXVII – XXXVIII: 9th to 20th September 2024
On July 18, 2019, the Commission adopted the contested decision imposing a fine on
July 2019).
The Commission defined the relevant market as that for stand-alone integrated
baseband chips compatible with Universal Mobile Telecommunications System (UMTS)
technology.
It found that Qualcomm held a dominant position on this market worldwide, at least
between January 1, 2009 and December 31, 2011.
It also found that Qualcomm had abused its dominant position by supplying, during
that period, certain quantities of some of its UMTS chips to two of its main customers,
Huawei and ZTE, at prices below its costs, with the aim of eliminating Icera, its main
competitor at the time.
Qualcomm asks the General Court to annul or, in the alternative, substantially reduce
the amount of the fine imposed.
Background Documents T-671/19
There will be a press release for this case.
Wednesday 11th September
General Court
Judgment in Case T-386/19 CQ v Court of Auditors
(Law governing the institutions)
CQ, as a member of the European Court of Auditors, was reimbursed for various
expenses and provided with a company car and a driver.
The European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) was informed following information obtained
by the Court of Auditors concerning a number of serious irregularities attributed to
this member, which resulted in potentially undue expenditure being charged to the EU
budget.
Following an investigation, OLAF concluded that there had been a number of abuses
of the Court of Auditors’ resources in connection with activities unrelated to the QC’s
duties, as well as the passing on of confidential information and the existence of
conflicts of interest.
Following OLAF’s investigation, the Court of Auditors adopted a decision establishing
Newsletter
Week XXXVII – XXXVIII: 9th to 20th September 2024
the existence of a claim against CQ and ordering its recovery.
CQ paid the sum demanded by the Court of Auditors, but at the same time applied to
the General Court of the European Union for annulment of the decision and for
compensation for the non-material damage suffered.
Background Documents T-386/19
There will be a press release for this case.
Wednesday 11th September
General Court
Judgment in Case T-793/22 TU v Parliament
(Staff Regulations of Officials and Conditions of Employment of other servants)
TU, an accredited parliamentary assistant at the European Parliament, reported cases
of harassment and financial irregularities involving an MEP.
After requesting protection as an informant, he was relieved of his duties. His contract
was not renewed. He challenged this decision, as well as the implicit refusal to
recognise his status as an informant and to grant him additional protection to the
measure of discharge from his duties.
TU also claimed compensation of €200,000 for breach of the rules protecting whistleblowers and the confidentiality of his identity.
The Parliament rejected these claims.
TU then brought the case before the General Court of the European Union.
Background Documents T-793/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Wednesday 11th September
General Court
Judgments in Cases T-644/22 Timchenko and Timchenko v Council and T-635/22
Fridman and Others v Council
(External Relations – Common Foreign and Security Policy – Restrictive Measures Ukraine)
Newsletter
Week XXXVII – XXXVIII: 9th to 20th September 2024
The names of Elena Timchenko and those of Gennady Timchenko, Mikhail Fridman,
Petr Aven and German Khan have been included on the lists of persons, entities and
bodies subject to restrictive measures adopted by the Council of the European Union
in the context of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
In view of the increasing complexity of the systems that make it possible to evade this
system of penalties and prevent its implementation, on July 21, 2022 the Council
adopted amending Regulation (EU) 2022/1273 laying down obligations to declare
funds and cooperate with the competent authorities. Failure to comply with these
obligations will be treated as circumventing the freezing of funds.
In practical terms, the aim is to prevent the use of complex legal and financial
arrangements which are likely to make it more difficult for the competent national
authorities to identify the funds or economic resources subject to restrictive
measures, if not easier to circumvent the measures (Judgment in Case T-644/22).
The parties concerned applied to the General Court of the European Union for the
annulment of these obligations to declare their funds or economic resources before
September 1, 2022 and to cooperate with the competent national authorities.
They consider that such obligations were not included in the penalty measures
adopted by the Council from 2014: in their view, they did not therefore constitute
measures necessary for their implementation.
In particular, they consider that the Council Regulation constitutes a misuse of powers
because the adoption of the obligations in question should fall within the
implementing powers of the Member States.
Background Documents T-644/22
Background Documents T-635/22
There will be one press release for these cases.
Thursday 12th September
Judgment in Case C-557/23 SPAR Magyarország
(Agriculture and Fisheries)
In February 2022, in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, Hungary regulated the
marketing of six basic products (certain types of sugar, wheat flour, sunflower oil, pork
and poultry meat, and milk) by government decree.
From November 2022, due to the war in Ukraine, the decree was amended and two
more products were added to the list, namely eggs and potatoes.
Newsletter
Week XXXVII – XXXVIII: 9th to 20th September 2024
The government decree remained in force until July 31, 2023.
Under the terms of the government decree, distributors who had already marketed
these products at an earlier date were required, on pain of a fine, to offer for sale a
predefined quantity – based firstly on the average daily quantity offered for sale during
a reference period and secondly on the quantity of the products in question in stock
during that reference period – at a regulated price.
In May 2023, the Hungarian authorities imposed a fine on the retailer SPAR
Magyarország, finding that, in one of its sales outlets, it had not complied with the
daily stock quantities for five products covered by the decree.
SPAR brought proceedings before the court in Szeged (Hungary) to have the
authorities’ decision annulled.
Having doubts about the compatibility of the government decree with the Common
organisation of the markets (CMO) Regulation and in particular with the principle of
free determination of selling prices for agricultural products on the basis of free
competition, the Hungarian court referred the matter to the Court of Justice.
Background Documents C-557/23
There will be a press release for this case.
Week XXXVIII 16th to 20th September
Wednesday 18th September
General Court
Judgment in Case T-334/19 Google and Alphabet v Commission (Google AdSense
for Search)
(Competition – Dominant position)
Google and its parent company Alphabet (referred to as ‘Google’) have operated an
advertising platform called AdSense since 2003. Google has developed various
services in this respect, including, in particular, an advertising intermediation service
for online searches called AdSense for Search (‘AFS’).
AFS enabled website publishers to display advertisements linked to online searches
that users could perform on websites containing an integrated search engine (‘online
search ads’). That way publishers could receive part of the revenue generated by the
display of these advertisements.
Newsletter
Week XXXVII – XXXVIII: 9th to 20th September 2024
To use AFS, publishers had the choice of either entering into an individually negotiated
‘Google Services Agreement’ (‘GSA’) with Google or a standard non-negotiable ‘online
contract’.
In 2010, a German company filed a complaint with the German Federal Cartel Office.
This complaint was transferred to the European Commission. Between 2011 and 2016,
Microsoft, Expedia, Initiative for a Competitive Online Marketplace and Deutsche
Telekom filed additional complaints.
In 2016, the Commission opened proceedings focusing on exclusivity, placement and
prior authorisation clauses. It identified a potential abuse of a dominant position.
In September 2016, Google removed certain clauses from its AFS agreements.
In March 2019, the Commission found that Google and, from October 2, 2015,
Alphabet had committed three separate infringements which together constituted a
single and continuous infringement from January 2006 to September 2016. It imposed
a fine of €1,494,459,000 on Google, including €130,135,475 jointly and severally with
Alphabet (Commission’s decision of 20 March 2019 relating to a proceeding under
Article 102 TFEU and Article 54 of the EEA Agreement (AT.40411 — Google Search
(AdSense) – see summary).
Google asked the General Court to annul (in whole or in part) the mentioned
Commission’s decision and/or to annul or reduce the fine imposed.
Background Documents T-334/19
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 19th September
Judgment in Joined Cases C-555/22 P United Kingdom v Commission and Others,
C-556/22 P ITV v Commission and Others and C-564/22 P LSEGH (Luxembourg) and
London Stock Exchange Group Holdings (Italy) v Commission and Others
(Competition – State aid)
In 2019, the European Commission found that, between 2013 and 2018, the United
Kingdom had granted unlawful state aid to certain multinational groups by conferring
tax advantages on them.
It considered that the reference framework, which is relevant for examining the
existence of a selective advantage, is limited solely to the rules applicable to controlled
foreign companies (CFCs) and that the exemptions granted constituted a derogation
from that framework.
Newsletter
Week XXXVII – XXXVIII: 9th to 20th September 2024
The United Kingdom and ITV challenged the Commission’s decision (Commission
Decision (EU) 2019/1352) before the General Court of the European Union.
In 2022, the General Court rejected their appeals, upholding the Commission’s
arguments (judgment of the General Court of 8 June 2022, Joined cases United
Kingdom and ITV v Commission T?363/19 and T?456/19).
By their respective appeals, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland
(C?555/22 P), ITV plc (C?556/22 P) and LSEGH (Luxembourg) Ltd and London Stock
Exchange Group Holdings (Italy) Ltd (together ‘LSEGH’) (C?564/22 P) seek to have the
General Court’s judgment set aside.
Background Documents C-555/22 P, C-556/22 P and C-564/22 P
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 19th September
Judgment in Case C-264/23 Booking.com and Booking.com (Deutschland)
(Competition)
Booking.com, a company incorporated under Dutch law and headquartered in
Amsterdam (Netherlands), offers a global online intermediation service for booking
accommodation.
Hotels pay Booking.com a commission for every reservation made by travellers using
the platform.
Trending
- SAISON CULTURELLE 2026/2027 – Musica, comicità e opera lirica: i prossimi appuntamenti della sezione Spectacle della Saison Culturelle 2026/2027
- L’abete di Terranova del Pollino in piazza San Pietro
- News Release – City of Toronto ushers in the 2026-2030 Toronto City Council term
- Agenzia nr. 2187 – Insediamento nuovo Procuratore Aggiunto a Brindisi. Caroli: ‘Ampia disponibilità e massima sinergia con la Commissione
- Antisemitismo, Cecchetti (Lega): Piena solidarietà a Meghnagi e Fadlun. Vili minacce che confermano la necessità della legge
- Agenzia nr. 2186 – Vurchio: “Fare impresa nella Bat deve tornare a essere un’opportunità. Serve una strategia per il territorio
- AGENDA CAMERA DI DOMANI, VENERDÌ 20 NOVEMBRE
- Agenzia nr. 2185 – JTF Taranto. Fischetti: “Altri 4 milioni di euro per la formazione e il reinserimento lavorativo
- MANOVRA Nazionale, ANCE Enna: CAMBIARE NORMA SUPERBONUS PER SALVAGUARDARE LE IMPRESE
- MILLEPROROGHE, ZANGRILLO: “AL LAVORO PER STABILIZZARE PERSONALE ASSUNTO COL PATTO PER NAPOLI, IMPORTANTE INVESTIMENTO IN CAPITALE UMANO”
