(AGENPARL) - Roma, 29 Luglio 2024 - (AGENPARL) – lun 29 luglio 2024 PRESS RELEASE No 118/24
Luxembourg, 29 July 2024
Judgment of the Court in Case C-436/22 | ASCEL
The wolf cannot be designated as a huntable species at regional level when
its conservation status at national level is unfavourable
That is true even in cases where the wolf does not enjoy strict protection in the region concerned in accordance
with the Habitats Directive, since species management measures, such as hunting, must in any event be
designed to maintain or restore species at a favourable conservation status
The Habitats Directive 1 was adopted with the aim of achieving an essential objective of general interest pursued by
the European Union: the preservation, protection and improvement of the quality of the environment, contributing
to ensuring biodiversity through the conservation of natural habitats and of wild fauna and flora.
In Spain, in accordance with that directive, Iberian wolf populations are subject to separate protection regimes: the
populations situated south of the Douro River enjoy strict protection. Those situated north of that river are, for their
part, classified as an animal species of Community interest that may be subject to management measures.
Under a regional Law, the wolf was designated as a huntable species north of the Douro River in the Autonomous
Community of Castile and Leon (Spain). In 2019, the regional government approved a plan for the local exploitation
of wolves in the hunting grounds situated north of the Douro River for the 2019/2020, 2020/2021 and 2021/2022
seasons. That plan allowed a total of 339 wolves to be hunted 2 3. The Association for the Conservation and Study of
the Iberian Wolf (ASCEL) brought an action against that plan before the High Court of Justice, Castile and Leon 4.
That Spanish court has doubts as to the compatibility of the regional Law in the light of the Habitats Directive and
refers questions to the Court of Justice in that regard. According to a report for the period 2013-2018, sent by Spain
to the Commission in 2019, the wolf had an ‘unfavourable-poor’ conservation status in the three regions it occupied
in the national territory (Mediterranean, Atlantic and Alpine), the first two of those regions including Castile and
Leon.
The Court answers that the regional Law is contrary to the Habitats Directive.
Indeed, the wolf cannot be designated as a huntable species in a part of the territory of a Member State
when its conservation status at national level is unfavourable.
The fact that an animal species may be subject to management measures does not mean that its conservation
status is favourable.
The purpose of those measures must be to maintain or restore the species concerned at a favourable
conservation status. Thus, where those measures include hunting rules, they are intended to restrict
hunting, not to extend it. If it proves necessary, hunting may, therefore, even be prohibited.
Furthermore, a decision authorising the hunting of a species must be justified and based on surveillance data
concerning the conservation status of that species 5 6. Moreover, that surveillance must be undertaken with
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
particular care where that species is generally regarded as a species of Community interest. However, when drawing
up the contested plan, the Autonomous Community of Castile and Leon did not take account of the 2019 report,
according to which the conservation status of the wolf in Spain was unfavourable.
In any event, assessments of the conservation status of a species and of the appropriateness of adopting
management measures must be carried out taking into account the report drawn up by the Member States every
six years under the Habitats Directive and the most recent scientific data obtained through the surveillance
carried out by them. Those assessments must be made not only at local level, but also at the level of the
biogeographical region, and even at cross-border level 7. Where an animal species has an unfavourable
conservation status, the competent authorities must take measures in order to improve the conservation
status of the species concerned in such a way that, in future, its populations are sustainably maintained at a
favourable status. In that context, protective measures, such as the restriction or prohibition of hunting, may be
considered necessary where uncertainty remains as to the risks that exist for the maintenance of a species at a
favourable conservation status (precautionary principle).
NOTE: A reference for a preliminary ruling allows the courts and tribunals of the Member States, in disputes which
have been brought before them, to refer questions to the Court of Justice about the interpretation of EU law or the
validity of an EU act. The Court of Justice does not decide the dispute itself. It is for the national court or tribunal to
dispose of the case in accordance with the Court’s decision, which is similarly binding on other national courts or
tribunals before which a similar issue is raised.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice.
The full text and, as the case may be, an abstract of the judgment is published on the CURIA website on the day of
delivery.
Stay Connected!
Council Directive 92/43/EEC of 21 May 1992 on the conservation of natural habitats and of wild fauna and flora.
That plan is based on a regional census of wolves dating back to the years 2012 and 2013, within the framework of a national census carried out
between 2012 and 2014, as well as on annual monitoring reports, which involve less effort in terms of observation and surveillance than that
expended in the preparation of a census. Using the data available and applying a number of factors, the plan estimates the number of wolves
present north of the Douro River in Castile and Leon prior to hunting to be 1 051 specimens. The national census reported a total of 297 packs in
Spain, of which 179 would fall under the Castile and Leon census, that is to say 60.3% of the total recorded at national level. The plan concludes that
an annual mortality rate in excess of 35% would lead to a decline in the population of that species.
Since September 2021, all Spanish wolf populations are subject to a strict protection regime. However, measures for the taking and capture of
specimens, which were adopted at regional level before that date, continued to apply, provided that they complied with certain conditions and
limitations. In a judgment of 13 July 2022, the Spanish Constitutional Court declared unconstitutional the relevant provisions relating to the hunting of
wolves, contained in the Law of Castile and Leon.
ASCEL also seeks compensation for the damage caused to the wild fauna, equivalent to the economic value of each specimen killed during the
2019/2020, 2020/2021 and 2021/2022 hunting seasons, that is to say, a sum of €9 261 per wolf. According to the regional Law, the value of each wolf
hunted is € 6 000.
The Habitats Directive requires Member States to undertake surveillance of the conservation status of species and natural habitats, with particular
regard to priority natural habitat types and priority species. That surveillance is essential in order to determine the need to adopt management
measures for ensuring the maintenance of species at a favourable conservation status. This should enable the most recent data to be obtained on
the conservation status of the species concerned. That surveillance obligation is supplemented by the obligation to forward to the Commission, every
six years, a report on the implementation of that directive. That report must include the main results of the surveillance referred to, as well as, inter
alia, an assessment of the conservation status of the various species present in the territory of the Member State concerned.
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
See judgment of the Court of Justice of 10 October 2019, Luonnonsuojeluyhdistys Tapiola, C-674/17.
In the case of protected animal species which like the wolf range over wide areas, the natural range is broader than the geographical area that
presents the physical or biological factors essential to their life and reproduction (see judgment of the Court of Justice of 11 June 2020, Alian?a pentru
combaterea abuzurilor, C-88/19, as well as Press Release No 72/20). It must be observed, in that regard, that the Iberian wolf is a strictly protected
species in Portugal.
Communications Directorate
Trending
- Comunicato Stampa 2045/2026 Cultura, risorse dalla Regione a 16 Associazioni bellunesi. Assessore Bond: “Volontariato in montagna è ricchezza da sostenere
- Longi, chiude un tratto della strada provinciale 157 Tortoriciana
- SONO UN PARACADUTISTA!
- Il Canada ridisegna la propria strategia energetica: nuovo oleodotto verso il Pacifico, accordi sul gas con l’Europa e minore dipendenza dagli Stati Uniti
- L’Orto Botanico Unimore apre le porte alla creatività e alla scoperta della natura
- Messaggio del Presidente dell’Assemblea Nazionale, Zoran Stevanović, sulla Colazione Tradizionale Slovena
- ZES, CASASCO (FI): «BENE L’OBIETTIVO DEL GOVERNO IN LINEA CON TAJANI E FORZA ITALIA, SEMPLIFICAZIONI A TUTTA ITALIA. È LA RICETTA LIBERALE PER LE IMPRESE»
- Agenzia nr. 2188 – Fasano, Gioia (Prossima): “Al via il trasferimento dell’Ospedale di Comunità al 5° piano del PTA: riparte reumatologia
- Zes, Nevi (FI): “Una nostra idea diventa realtà, meno burocrazia per attrarre investimenti
- Comunicati Stampa “Iniziative giornata internaziona contro la Violenza sulle Donne” e “Giornata mondiale dell’Albero
