(AGENPARL) - Roma, 27 Giugno 2024 - (AGENPARL) – gio 27 giugno 2024 Newsletter
Week XXVII – XXVIII: 1st to 12th July 2024
Contact us
@ENDesk
Jacques René
Zammit
Press Officer
Monica Pizzo
Week XXVII 1st to 5th July
Thursday 4th July
Judgment in Case C-450/22 Caixabank and Others (Monitoring transparency in
collective action)
(Consumer protection)
Assistant
‘Floor clauses’ are standard terms contained in variable rate mortgage loan
agreements concluded between consumers and a significant number of financial
institutions in Spain. These types of clauses set a threshold (or ‘floor’) below which the
Desk Email
variable interest rate could not fall, even if the reference rate (generally the Euribor)
fell below it.
When the reference rates fell significantly below that threshold, the consumers
Graziella
realised they could not benefit from that decrease and still had to pay the minimum
Schembri
interest rate (usually between two and five percent), despite having a variable rate
assisted in the
mortgage. Individual consumers and consumer associations have filed several
preparation of
this Newsletter.
Follow
@EUCourtPress
on X (formerly
Twitter)
Download our
thousands of lawsuits in Spain claiming the illegality of ‘floor clauses’ in light of the
Directive on unfair terms in consumer contracts, as well as the restitution of the
overpaid interest (see Judgment joined cases C-154/15, C-307/15 and C-308/15 and
Press Release No 144/16).
The Spanish Association of Users of Banks, Savings Banks and Insurance (ADICAE)
brought a collective action against 101 financial institutions operating in Spain. ADICAE
aims at stopping the use of ‘the floor clauses’ (‘action for an injunction’) by those
institutions and at obtaining the reimbursement of the payments made under them
(‘action for recovery’). Following calls in the national media, 820 consumers supported
the collective action.
Having lost the case twice, the banks appealed to the Spanish Supreme Court. That
court has doubts about the suitability of the collective proceedings to carry out a
review of the transparency of the ‘floor clauses’ in order to ascertain whether they are
unfair, especially given the large number of consumers and financial institutions
involved.
The Spanish High Court asked the Court of Justice for guidance on the interpretation
of the Directive on unfair terms in consumer contracts and its compatibility with the
Spanish system of collective actions brought by a consumers’ association against floor
Communications Directorate
Press and Information unit
curia.europa.eu
Newsletter
Week XXVII – XXVIII: 1st to 12th July 2024
clauses in mortgage loan contracts concluded with consumers, which are used by all
All times are 9:30
unless otherwise
stated.
Don’t forget to
check the diary
the defendant banks.
Background Documents C-450/22
There will be a press release for this case.
on our website
for details of
other cases.
Week XXVIII 8th to 12th July
Thursday 11th July
Judgment in Joined Cases C-554/21 HANN-INVEST, C-622/21 MINERAL-SEKULINE
and C-727/21 UDRUGA KHL MEDVEŠ?AK ZAGREB
(Principles of Community law – Charter of Fundamental Rights)
The Commercial Court of Appeal, Croatia asks the Court of Justice guidance on the
interpretation of Article 19 of the TEU and Article 47 of the Charter of Fundamental
Rights in relation to three appeals concerning the recovery of costs for the conduct of
bankruptcy proceedings.
Appeals against orders in three different insolvency proceedings were finally and
unanimously dismissed by three-judge panels. The decisions were forwarded to the
registry in accordance with the established rules.
However, the judge in this department refused to register the three decisions. He
referred them back to the respective panels, stating that he did not agree with the
solutions adopted in these decisions. He referred in particular to compliance with a
“legal position” on how to decide cases of this type, which, according to internal
procedural practice, had previously been adopted by a sectional meeting of the court.
“Legal positions” interpret the law in the light of specific cases, and are binding on all
chambers or judges of the court.
In these circumstances, the referring court seeks to ascertain whether such an internal
mechanism for finalising judicial decisions is compatible with the fundamental
principle of effective judicial protection.
Background Documents C-554/21
There will be a press release for these cases.
Newsletter
Week XXVII – XXVIII: 1st to 12th July 2024
Thursday 11th July
Judgment in case C-601/22 WWF Österreich and Others
(Environment)
A number of animal and environmental protection organisations are challenging
before the Regional Administrative Court of Tyrol (Austria) the fact that the
government of the Land of Tyrol has temporarily authorised the slaughter of a wolf.
The wolf had previously killed around 20 sheep on pastureland.
Under the Habitats Directive, wolves are strictly protected, meaning that in principle it
is forbidden to hunt them. However, given the development of the wolf population in
Austria and the fact that some Member States benefit from exceptions, the Tyrol
Regional Administrative Court doubted the validity of this ban.
It therefore referred the matter to the Court of Justice. In the event that it were to
consider the ban valid, it asked the Court to specify the conditions for derogating from
it and thus authorising the killing of a specimen.
Background Documents C-601/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 11th July
Judgment in case C-196/23 Plamaro
(Social policy)
The reference for a preliminary ruling was made in the context of a dispute concerning
dismissal between eight employees (the “employees concerned”) and their employer’s
universal heir (the “defendant”).
An entrepreneur retired. His departure resulted in the termination of 54 employment
contracts in his company’s 8 establishments. 8 employees challenged the unlawful
dismissal to which they felt they had been subjected. Their appeal was rejected.
The Spanish court hearing the appeal must determine the validity of the termination
of the employment contracts.
Spanish law provides for a procedure for consulting workers’ representatives in the
event of collective redundancies. However, that procedure does not apply in cases
Newsletter
Week XXVII – XXVIII: 1st to 12th July 2024
where the terminations were caused by the retirement of the individual employer.
The Spanish court wonders, however, whether that exclusion complied with the EU
Council Directive 98/59/EC of 20 July 1998 on the approximation of the laws of the
Member States relating to collective redundancies. It therefore referred the case to
the Court.
Background Documents C-196/23
There will be a press release for this case.
HEARINGS OF NOTE*
Court of Justice
Tuesday 02nd July 2024: 09:30 – Case C-492/23 Russmedia Digital and Inform Media Press
(Freedom to provide services – Data protection) (streamed on Curia)
Thursday 04nd July 2024: 09:30 – Case C-414/23 Metsä Fibre (Environment – Pollution)
Monday 08th July 2024: 14:30 – Case C-453/23 Prezydent Miasta Mielca (State aid)
(streamed on Curia)
Tuesday 09th July 2024: 09:30 – Case C-452/23 Fastned Deutschland and Tesla Germany
(Freedom of establishment – Freedom to provide services) (streamed on Curia)
Thursday 11th July 2024: 14:30 – Case C-613/23 Herdijk (Taxation)
General Court
Monday 01st July 2024: 09:30 – Cases T-270/23 Rosbank v Council and
T-275/23 Tinkoff Bank v Council (Restrictive measures – Ukraine)
Wednesday 03rd July 2024: 09:30 – Joined cases T-830/22 and T-156/23
Poland v Commission (Law governing the institutions)
Wednesday 03rd July 2024: 09:30 – Case T-193/23 MegaFon v Council
(Restrictive measures – Ukraine)
Tuesday 09th July 2024: 09:30 – Case T-271/22 Melnichenko v Council and
14:30 Case T-498/22 Melnichenko v Council (Restrictive measures – Ukraine)
Tuesday 09th July 2024: 09:00 – Case T-498/19 Banco Cooperativo Español v SRB
(2019 ex-ante contributions) and 14:00 Case T-406/18 de Volksbank v SRB
(2018 ex-ante contributions) (Economic policy)
Newsletter
Week XXVII – XXVIII: 1st to 12th July 2024
* This is a non-exhaustive list and does not include all the hearings over the next two
weeks.
Trending
- Scuola, Latini (Lega): “La violenza non è protesta, Schlein e Pd condannino gli attacchi agli agenti
- Federmanager, dalla Sicilia tre priorità per la politica: in anteprima nazionale il documento su sicurezza, intelligenza artificiale ed etica
- Comunicato Stampa 2062/2026 Rovigo, presidente Stefani: “Una legge speciale per il Polesine da scrivere insieme ai cittadini entro il 2027
- Agenzia regionale 1240.26 Miglietta Stanziamento 40 mln di euro per borse di studio ADISU
- La forza oltre le discipline”: domani all’Hilton Rome Airport arriva il Convegno internazionale della FIPE Strength Academy
- Maltempo, codice arancio per mareggiate su costa centro-nord
- Borgo Pineto, una Santa Messa per festeggiare il compleanno di un giovane: la gioia della vita nel segno della fede
- Agenzia nr. 2217 – Giornata internazionale dei diritti dell’infanzia e dell’adolescenza, in Consiglio regionale “DisaGital”: istituzioni, scuola e professionisti insieme per prevenire il disagio giovanile e promuovere l’educazione digitale
- Manovra, Nevi (FI): “Il centrosinistra emblema del ‘tassa e spendi’, assume posizioni antieuropeiste
- Agenzia nr. 2218 – Agorà del Consiglio regionale
