(AGENPARL) - Roma, 26 Giugno 2024 - (AGENPARL) – mer 26 giugno 2024 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
MANITOBA PROSECUTION SERVICE
CLEAR STATEMENT
Overview
On June 15, 2023, at 11:32 a.m., a Quality Care Transit bus was travelling southbound on
Highway 5 as it approached the intersection of Highway 5 and Highway 1. The bus driver, a
61-year-old male and the owner of the bus, stopped at the stop sign to allow westbound traffic
on Highway 1 to clear. The bus driver then crossed the westbound lanes and drove slowly
through the median controlled by a yield sign and crossed the eastbound lanes directly in front
of an oncoming semi-truck. The semi-truck driver attempted to stop and steer to his right but
could not avoid the collision. The extent of the collision was life altering for all of the survivors
and claimed the lives of 17 people.
This Clear Statement provides a summary of the evidence gathered during the investigation
and the applicable legal principles. These are provided to assist in understanding the Manitoba
Prosecution Service’s (MPS) decision to not approve charges against the driver of the bus. Not
all relevant evidence, facts, case law, nor legal principles that were considered in reaching this
conclusion are discussed in this summary. The charge assessment was conducted by Crown
counsel with no prior or current connection to the driver of the bus or any of the victims of the
collision.
Charge Assessment
MPS guidelines for assessing allegations against any individual involved in a fatal collision are
conducted using our standard for laying charges and follow our fatality protocol for driving
related incidents
(www.gov.mb.ca/justice/crown/prosecutions/pubs/laying_and_staying_of_charges.pdf).
The MPS applies a two-part test to determine whether charges will be approved and a
prosecution initiated. Crown counsel must independently, objectively and fairly measure all
available evidence to determine:
1. Whether there is a reasonable likelihood of conviction; and if so,
2. Whether the public interest requires a prosecution.
The first arm of this test requires prosecutors to bring all of their professional skills to bear on
making a determination of whether a conviction to the criminal law standard of beyond a
reasonable doubt is the more likely outcome if the matter was to proceed to trial. The second
arm requires prosecutors to recognize that many societal values impact the criminal justice
system. Prosecutions advance the important societal interest in the deterrence, denunciation
and punishment of criminal conduct.
Prosecutors are expected to exercise their professional judgment to consider these and other
societal interests in determining whether a prosecution is in the public interest, recognizing that
the more serious the offence and the more dangerous the offender the more likely that the
value in prosecution will outweigh other public interest concerns.
…2/
-2Charges Considered
The potential charges considered in this case were dangerous operation of a motor vehicle causing
death and dangerous operation of a motor vehicle causing bodily harm (s. 320.13, Criminal Code of
Canada).
Timeframe for Assessment
The Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) first submitted this file for charge assessment on Jan.
3, 2024. The assessment of this matter was delayed by factors including ongoing investigative steps
by the RCMP and substantial additional information provided to Crown counsel during the review
period, factual complexity, and legal complexity.
Relevant Law
Dangerous operation of a motor vehicle is made out when a person drives in a manner that is
dangerous to the public, having regard to all the circumstances, and the driving constitutes a marked
departure from the standard of a reasonable person in the driver’s circumstances. In a case involving
a bus driver, the driving would entail a marked departure from the standard of a reasonable bus driver
with that drivers’ experience and training.
Momentary inattention does not constitute dangerous driving. 1 The act of dangerous operation of a
motor vehicle is driving in a manner dangerous to the public in all of the circumstances. The focus
must be on the risks created by the driver’s manner of driving, not the consequences of the driving. 2
Circumstances
On June 15, 2023, the driver of the bus (bus driver), employed by Quality Care Transit, was
transporting 24 passengers from Dauphin to the Sand Hills Casino near Carberry. 17 passengers
died due to the collision. The bus driver was hospitalized with a traumatic brain injury.
At 11:32 a.m. on June 15, 2023, the bus driver was travelling southbound on Highway 5. As he
approached the intersection of Highway 1, he came to a stop at the stop sign to allow westbound
traffic to pass. He then proceeded across the westbound lanes of Highway 1, into the median that
had a yield sign. He continued across the eastbound lanes of Highway 1, driving across the path of
the oncoming semi-truck.
The semi-truck had dash cam video. The video was consistent with the description provided by the
semi-truck driver. He attempted to avoid the collision but the bus driver did not appear to see the
semi-truck. The semi-truck driver was not speeding or driving erratically and clearly had the right of
way. Transport Canada and the RCMP collision reconstructionist conducted investigations into the
collision and determined that the bus driver would have had three separate blind spots that
contributed to the bus driver not seeing the semi-truck. The 10 second video obtained from the semitruck, along with the scene evidence and examination of the bus, demonstrated that the right-front
corner of the bus passenger cabin clearly played a significant role in the collision.
…3/
R. v. Beatty, [2008] 1 S.C.R. 49.
R. v. Roy, [2012] 1 S.C.R. 60, and R. v. Chung, 2020 SCC 8.
-3Specifically, the bus left the stop sign to cross the westbound lanes of Highway 1 10.5 seconds prior
to the collision. At this time, the semi-truck was 318 metres west of the impact location and
completely within the area obscured by the structure between the passenger loading door and the
small right window.
The bus passed the yield sign in the centre median approximately 3.5 seconds prior to impact. At this
point the truck was approximately 100 metres west of the impact location and remained hidden in the
same obscured area between the passenger loading door and the small right window.
The bus traversed the solid yellow line on the left side of the eastbound through lanes approximately
2 seconds prior to impact when the truck was approximately 52 metres west of the impact location.
Visibility of the truck remained in the same obscured area.
The RCMP collision analyst confirmed the information that there were blind spots, and that the bus
had only been in operation with Quality Care transit for a month prior to the collision. There were no
mechanical defects with the bus.
One witness on the bus said that the bus driver was on his cell phone prior to the collision. RCMP
investigators obtained search warrants for the phone and determined that the phone was not in use at
the time of the collision. The last outgoing phone call from the bus driver to his dispatcher was at
11:27:52 a.m. While there had been calls to his dispatch prior to the collision, there is no evidence
that the phone was in use at the time of the collision or just prior to the collision.
In terms of the medical evidence related to the bus driver, RCMP obtained medical records shortly
after the offence, and in the spring of 2024 after lengthy treatment and hospitalization of the bus
driver. Those records confirmed that the bus driver had a major brain injury, underwent substantial
rehabilitation and remains unable to care for himself or function without assistance in the community.
He is not in a position to make his own decisions regarding his personal care or finances and his
condition is unlikely to improve based on the medical evidence obtained.
Analysis
The RCMP requested a Crown opinion regarding any charges that may flow from this collision.
Dangerous Operation
To make out the offence of dangerous operation of a motor vehicle, the Crown would have to show
that the bus driver’s actions were a marked departure from the standard of a reasonable person in
similar circumstances. At the time of the collision, it is apparent from all of the evidence that the driver,
due to the blind spots in the vehicle, did not see the semi-truck travelling eastbound. He did not hit the
brakes, nor did he speed up to avoid the semi-truck.
In the present circumstances, the bus driver stopped at the stop sign as he approached the
westbound lanes of Highway 1. He then proceeded into the median where there was a yield sign and
continued through the eastbound lanes of traffic. It is apparent, from the dash cam video of the semitruck, that the bus driver did not see an oncoming vehicle in a matter of seconds.
…4/
-4The Crown would not be able to prove that the momentary inattention of the bus driver, or failure to
see the semi-truck combined with the blind spots in the vehicle, constituted a marked departure from
the standard of care of a reasonable bus driver in these circumstances.
The available evidence would support the conclusion that the bus driver’s conduct was not a marked
departure from the standard of care in the circumstances. As there is no reasonable likelihood of
conviction, there are no grounds to lay a criminal offence, or an offence under the Highway Traffic Act.
Conclusion
No charges have been approved in relation to the bus driver’s involvement in this collision. Even if
there were a basis to proceed under the Highway Traffic Act for proceeding when unsafe to do so, the
public interest does not militate in favour of any charge.
The bus driver involved in this incident has suffered a traumatic brain injury that requires assisted
living. He has no recollection of the incident, making it impossible to interview him. While the Crown is
certainly aware of the consequences of this mass casualty and the tragedy that the families have and
continue to deal with, there is no public interest in proceeding against the bus driver.
Trending
- Rai: Braga (Pd), Prima piazzano amici, ora La Russa vuole forzare tempi per controllo governance, a tutto c’è limite
- Libano, UNIFIL prepara il passaggio delle postazioni all’esercito: Abagnara avverte sul vuoto di sicurezza
- Scuola, Latini (Lega): “La violenza non è protesta, Schlein e Pd condannino gli attacchi agli agenti
- Federmanager, dalla Sicilia tre priorità per la politica: in anteprima nazionale il documento su sicurezza, intelligenza artificiale ed etica
- Comunicato Stampa 2062/2026 Rovigo, presidente Stefani: “Una legge speciale per il Polesine da scrivere insieme ai cittadini entro il 2027
- Agenzia regionale 1240.26 Miglietta Stanziamento 40 mln di euro per borse di studio ADISU
- La forza oltre le discipline”: domani all’Hilton Rome Airport arriva il Convegno internazionale della FIPE Strength Academy
- Maltempo, codice arancio per mareggiate su costa centro-nord
- Borgo Pineto, una Santa Messa per festeggiare il compleanno di un giovane: la gioia della vita nel segno della fede
- Agenzia nr. 2217 – Giornata internazionale dei diritti dell’infanzia e dell’adolescenza, in Consiglio regionale “DisaGital”: istituzioni, scuola e professionisti insieme per prevenire il disagio giovanile e promuovere l’educazione digitale