(AGENPARL) - Roma, 25 Giugno 2024 - (AGENPARL) – mar 25 giugno 2024 PRESS RELEASE No 106/24
Luxembourg, 25 June 2024
Judgment of the Court in Case C-626/22 | Ilva and Others
The operation of the Ilva steelworks must be suspended if it poses serious
and significant threats to the environment and human health
It is for the Milan District Court to assess whether that is the case
The concept of ‘pollution’ within the meaning of the Directive on industrial emissions includes adverse effects on
the environment and on human health. The prior assessment of the effects of the activity of an installation such as
the Ilva steelworks in southern Italy must therefore be an integral part of the procedures for the grant and
reconsideration of the operating permit provided for by that directive. In the reconsideration procedure, it is
necessary to take account of polluting substances linked to the installation’s activity, even if those substances were
not assessed in the initial authorisation procedure. In the event of serious and significant threats to the integrity of
the environment and human health, the operation of the installation must be suspended.
The Ilva steelworks is located in Taranto, in southern Italy. It started activity in 1965. With approximately 11 000
employees and covering an area of almost 1 500 hectares, it is one of the largest steelworks in Europe.
In 2019, the European Court of Human Rights found that the steelworks had a significant negative impact on the
environment and the health of local residents 1. Measures to reduce its impact have been provided for since 2012,
but the deadlines for their implementation have been repeatedly extended.
Many residents of the area are taking action before the Milan District Court against the continued operation of the
steelworks. They submit that its emissions are damaging their health and that the installation does not comply with
the requirements of the Directive on industrial emissions 2.
The Milan District Court raises the issue of whether the Italian legislation and the special derogating rules applicable
to the Ilva steelworks in order to ensure its continuity contravene the Directive. It has therefore referred questions
to the Court of Justice in this connection.
The Court draws attention, first, to the close link between the protection of the environment and that of
human health, which constitute key objectives of EU law, guaranteed in the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the
European Union. It observes that the Directive contributes to the achievement of those objectives and to
safeguarding the right to live in an environment that is adequate for personal health and well-being.
While, according to the Italian Government, the Directive makes no mention of an Assessment of Adverse Effects on
Health, the Court observes that the concept of ‘pollution’ within the meaning of that directive includes harm both to
the environment and to human health. Thus, the prior assessment of the effects of the activity of an
installation such as the Ilva steelworks on both those aspects must be an integral part of the procedures for
granting or reconsidering the operating permit. However, according to the Milan District Court, that prerequisite
has not been observed so far as concerns the adverse effects on health. The operator must also assess those effects
throughout the period of operation of its installation.
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
Furthermore, according to the Milan District Court, the special rules applicable to the Ilva steelworks enabled it to be
granted an environmental permit and for that permit to be reconsidered without taking account of certain
pollutants or of their harmful effect on the surrounding population. The Court observes that the operator of an
installation must provide, in its initial application for a permit, information on the nature, quantity and
potential harmful effect of the emissions likely to be produced by its installation. Only the polluting
substances considered to have a negligible effect on human health and the environment may be excluded from
having to comply with the emission limit values in the operating permit.
The Court takes the view that, contrary to what Ilva and the Italian Government claim, the permit reconsideration
procedure cannot be limited to setting limit values for polluting substances the emission of which was foreseeable.
Account must also be taken of the emissions actually generated by the installation concerned during its
operation and relating to other polluting substances.
In the event of a breach of the installation operating permit conditions, the operator must immediately take
the measures necessary to ensure that the compliance of its installation with those conditions is restored
within the shortest possible time.
Where there are serious and significant threats to the integrity of the environment and human health, the
deadline for the purposes of applying the protective measures provided for by the operating permit cannot be
repeatedly extended, and the operation of the installation must be suspended.
NOTE: A reference for a preliminary ruling allows the courts and tribunals of the Member States, in disputes which
have been brought before them, to refer questions to the Court of Justice about the interpretation of European
Union law or the validity of a European Union act. The Court of Justice does not decide the dispute itself. It is for the
national court or tribunal to dispose of the case in accordance with the Court’s decision, which is similarly binding on
other national courts or tribunals before which a similar issue is raised.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice.
The full text and, as the case may be, an abstract of the judgment is published on the CURIA website on the day of
delivery.
Stay Connected!
Assessments of the Adverse Effects on Health dating from 2017, 2018 and 2021 establish that there is a causal link between the alteration of the
health of the inhabitants of the Taranto region and the emissions of the Ilva steelworks, particularly so far as concerns fine PM10 particulate matter,
and sulphur dioxide (SO2) of industrial origin. Other pollutants linked to the activity of the steelworks have been detected, such as copper, mercury
and naphthalene as well as fine PM2.5 and PM10 particulate matter. In a report of January 2002 of the Human Rights Council of the United Nations, the
agglomeration of Taranto is listed as a ‘sacrifice zone’. These are zones characterised by extreme levels of pollution and contamination by toxic
substances in which vulnerable and marginalised groups bear a disproportionate burden of the health, human rights and environmental
consequences as a result of exposure to pollution and hazardous substances.
Directive 2010/75/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 24 November 2010 on industrial emissions (integrated pollution prevention
and control).
Communications Directorate
Trending
- FBI, Trump dopo l’attacco hacker al database criminale: «Non mi piace, ma forse scopriremo cose mai sapute»
- Manovra: Mauri (PD): Governo approvi Previdenza dedicata per personale sicurezza
- Contrade, Iannelli: “Numeri civici, consulta e gas: sono state priorità di questa Amministrazione
- Agricoltura. Sviluppo rurale, 15mila aziende hanno già ricevuto pagamenti per 68 milioni di euro, oltre il 90% dell’importo liquidabile
- NOTA DI PALAZZO CHIGI: Piena solidarietà dell’Italia alla Danimarca e alla Polonia
- Reddito cittadinanza. Congedo (Fdi): Grazie a Libero per sua inchiesta su mafiosi che lo percepivano
- Rai: Braga (Pd), Prima piazzano amici, ora La Russa vuole forzare tempi per controllo governance, a tutto c’è limite
- Libano, UNIFIL prepara il passaggio delle postazioni all’esercito: Abagnara avverte sul vuoto di sicurezza
- Scuola, Latini (Lega): “La violenza non è protesta, Schlein e Pd condannino gli attacchi agli agenti
- Federmanager, dalla Sicilia tre priorità per la politica: in anteprima nazionale il documento su sicurezza, intelligenza artificiale ed etica
