(AGENPARL) - Roma, 2 Maggio 2024 - (AGENPARL) – gio 02 maggio 2024 Newsletter
Week XIX – XX: 6th – 17th May 2024
Contact us
@ENDesk
Jacques René
Zammit
Press Officer
Week XIX 6th to 10th May
Tuesday 7th May
Judgment in Case C-115/22 NADA and Others
(Principles, objectives and tasks of the Treaties – Data protection)
Monica Pizzo
A professional athlete was found guilty of violating Austrian anti-doping rules between
Assistant
1998 and 2015. The Austrian Anti-Doping Commission (ÖADR) declared all results
obtained by the athlete during the period in question invalid, and hence revoked any
participation rights and/or bonuses and banned her from taking part in any type of
Desk Email
sporting competition for four years.
Graziella
Schembri
assisted in the
preparation of
This decision was confirmed by the ÖADR and the Austrian Independent Arbitration
Commission (USK). The Austrian Independent Anti-Doping Agency (NADA) also
published the name of the athlete, her anti-doping rule violations and the period of
suspension in a table of suspended athletes on its publicly accessible website.
this Newsletter.
The athlete applied to USK for a review of this decision. In particular, this body is
questioning the publication of the personal data of a doping professional on NADA’s
website and its compatibility with the GDPR (Regulation (EU) 2016/679).
Follow
@EUCourtPress
on X (formerly
Twitter)
Download our
In proceedings concerning the applicant’s request that her personal data not be
disclosed on NADA’s website, the USK decided to stay the proceedings and refer
questions to the Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling, including the following ones:
1) Does the GDPR preclude a national law allowing the disclosure of the details of
a person subject to a decision of the USK, including that person’s name, the
duration of their ban and the reason behind such a ban, when it is not possible
to infer any health data of the person concerned from the data disclosed?
2) Does the GDPR, prior to the disclosure, require a balancing of interests
between the personal interests of the person affected by the disclosure, on
the one hand, and the interest of the general public to be informed of the antidoping violation committed by an athlete, on the other?
3) Does the disclosure of the information that a certain person has committed a
Communications Directorate
Press and Information unit
curia.europa.eu
Newsletter
Weeks XIX – XX: 6th – 17th May 2024
specific doping violation, as a result of which that person has been banned
All times are 9:30
from taking part in both national and international competitions, constitute
unless otherwise
the processing of personal data relating to criminal convictions and offences?
stated.
Don’t forget to
check the diary
on our website
Background Documents C-115/22
There will be a press release for this case.
for details of
other cases.
Tuesday 7th May
Opinion in Case C-4/23 Mirin
(Citizenship of the Union – Right of entry and residence)
A Romanian citizen was registered as female at birth in Romania.
After moving to the United Kingdom (UK), she acquired British nationality. In 2016,
before Brexit, she began the process of changing her name and gender in the UK.
In 2020, the citizen obtained full legal recognition of his male gender. However,
Romania asked him to start the process all over again following a national regulation
that required him to follow a new legal procedure.
In his view, the regulation violated his right to move and reside freely within the
territory of the European Union (Article 21 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the
European Union and Article 45 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European
Union).
In this case, the Romanian referring court asked the Court of Justice whether a
Member State’s refusal to recognise changes in the identity of a European Union
citizen obtained in the UK, when EU law was still applicable, complies with EU law. It
also asks for clarification of the consequences of the United Kingdom’s withdrawal
from the EU in this respect.
Background Documents C-4/23
There will be a press release for this case.
Wednesday 8th May
Judgment in Case C-53/23 Asocia?ia “Forumul Judec?torilor din România”
(Associations of magistrates)
(Principles, objectives and tasks of the Treaties – Accession – Fundamental rights)
A professional association of Romanian magistrates has challenged the appointment
Newsletter
Weeks XIX – XX: 6th – 17th May 2024
of certain prosecutors responsible for prosecuting corruption cases in Romania. They
believe that the national regulations that led to these appointments violate European
Union law and should be annulled.
The Pite?ti Court of Appeal in Romania, before which this case was brought, asked the
Court of Justice whether the Romanian procedural rules limiting the remedies
available to magistrates’ associations complied with EU law – Article 2 and Article 19
Treaty on European Union, read in the light of Article 12 and Article 47 of the Charter
of Fundamental Rights of the European Union.
Those rules make the admissibility of such an action subject to the existence of a
legitimate private interest. The Romanian court also raises questions about the
compatibility of these rules with EU law and with Romania’s commitments in the fight
against corruption.
Background Documents C-53/23
There will be a press release for this case.
Wednesday 8th May
General Court
Judgment in Case T-28/22 Ryanair v Commission (Condor; restructuring aid)
(Competition – State aid)
By decision State aid SA.63203 (2021/N) – Germany – Restructuring aid for Condor of
26 July 2021, the Commission authorised, without opening a formal investigation,
restructuring aid amounting to €321 million, which Germany intended to grant to the
German charter airline Condor.
The aid was intended to support the restructuring and continuation of Condor’s
activities, remedying the difficulties Condor was facing because of the bankruptcy of
its former parent company, Thomas Cook. In the context of that bankruptcy, Condor
had already benefited from rescue aid, which the Commission had approved by
decision of 14 October 2019 (see the press release by the Commission). Ryanair’s
appeal against that decision was dismissed by the General Court by judgment T577/20 Ryanair v Commission (Condor; rescue aid) of 18 May 2022 – see also press
release No 87/22.
Ryanair had not appealed against this judgment to the Court of Justice, but challenged
the decision of 26 July 2021 before the General Court of the European Union, stating,
inter alia:
the contested State aid falls outside the material scope of the Rescue and
Newsletter
Weeks XIX – XX: 6th – 17th May 2024
Restructuring Guidelines,
the contested decision does not establish the appropriateness, nor the
proportionality of the State aid to the damage caused by the COVID-19 crisis,
the contested decision violates the general principles of non-discrimination
and free provision of services that have underpinned the liberalisation of air
transport in the EU since the late 1980s conveyed in the sector through
Regulation (EC) No 1008/2008.
Background Documents T-28/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Wednesday 8th May
General Court
Judgment in Case T-375/22 Izuzquiza and Others v Parliament
(Provisions governing the institutions – Access to documents)
Luisa Izuzquiza, Arne Semsrott, Stefan Wehrmeyer, all from Berlin, requested access to
documents relating to a Member of the European Parliament, in accordance with
Article 15 of the Treaty of the Functioning of the European Union and Regulation (EC)
No 1049/2001.
The above-mentioned treaty article gives EU citizens, residents and businesses the
right of access to documents of the EU institutions, bodies, offices and agencies
subject to certain principles and conditions. The regulation lays down the general
principles and limits on access. Access can be requested to all documents drawn up or
received by an institution, in all areas of EU activities.
The European Parliament refused to give access to the documents in its final decision,
dated 8 April 2022, justifying the full and/or partial non-disclosure of the requested
documents by invoking the exceptions listed under Article 4 of the above mentioned
regulation:
a) Article 4(1)(b) states: “The institutions shall refuse access to a document where
Trending
- Incontro pazienti-medici sui linfomi
- Com. stampa n. 793 (Stop alle sedute operatorie in ospedale, il sindaco controreplica alla Corsi: “Commovente il racconto del Direttore Sanitario dell’Ast”) + foto
- POLIZIA DI STATO-Cordoglio Capo della Polizia Prefetto Pisani
- [Comune Palermo] Piscina comunale. Consegnati lavori vasche
- DE GENNARO. ROTONDI (FDI): ‘HA RAGIONE CASINI,OGGI LA MAFIA BRINDA
- De Gennaro: Ronzulli (FI), pensiero a famiglia, basta processi mediatici
- Comunicato Stampa 2055/2026 Domegge, altri 190.000 euro dal Fondo Comuni confinanti per gli impianti di atletica. Bond: “Finanziamento sale a 1,69 mln. Previsti tribune coperte, spogliatoi, locali di servizio
- Manovra, Bonelli (AVS): «Pagano pensionati e famiglie, ci guadagnano le lobby e l’industria delle armi»
- PINETA GRANDE, ZINZI (LEGA): “BENE ACCORDO CHE SCONGIURA CHIUSURA PRONTO SOCCORSO, MA FICO NON SCAMBI UNA TOPPA PER LA SOLUZIONE
- COMUNICATO STAMPA – Pesca: Battistoni (FI), patrimonio economico del Paese
