(AGENPARL) - Roma, 25 Aprile 2024 - (AGENPARL) – gio 25 aprile 2024 PRESS RELEASE No 72/24
Luxembourg, 25 April 2024
Judgment of the Court in Joined Cases C-420/22 | NW and C-528/22| PQ (Classified information)
Citizenship of the European Union: the withdrawal, on the basis of
classified information, of the residence permit of a third-country national
bringing up a child who is a Union citizen must be subject to an effective
remedy
Two third-country nationals, of Turkish and Nigerian nationality respectively, have been residing legally in Hungary
for several years. One of them is married to a Hungarian national, with whom he is bringing up their child of
Hungarian nationality. The other lives with his Hungarian partner and their two children, who also have Hungarian
nationality.
In 2020 and 2021, the Hungarian Constitutional Protection Office declared, by two non-reasoned opinions, that the
presence of those persons in Hungary was contrary to national security. That office also categorised as confidential
the information on which it relied in order to give those opinions.
Consequently, the national immigration police authority was required to withdraw its permanent residence card
from the first person while ordering him to leave Hungarian territory. It also had to reject an application for a
national settlement permit submitted by the second person. Neither that authority nor the persons concerned had
access to the confidential information on which the initial opinions were based.
Hearing actions brought by each of the two persons against the respective decisions of the national immigration
police authority, the court in Szeged (Hungary) asks the Court of Justice whether the Hungarian legislation is
compatible with EU law.
First of all, the Court notes that the authorities of a Member State may not withdraw a residence permit from a
family member of a Union citizen or refuse to issue such a permit to such a family member without first
examining whether there exists a relationship of dependency between that family member and the Union
citizen which would oblige the latter to leave the territory of the European Union in order to accompany his or her
family member to a third country.
Next, the Court considers that EU law precludes legislation requiring national authorities to withdraw a residence
permit from a family member of a Union citizen or to refuse to issue such a permit to such a family member on
grounds of national security based on a non-reasoned opinion of a specialist authority, without those national
authorities being able to examine carefully the relevant individual circumstances and the proportionality of
their decision.
Lastly, a national law is contrary to EU law where it prevents a Union citizen’s family member who, on the basis
of confidential information, has had his or her residence permit withdrawn, or has been refused such a permit, from
being informed even of the substance of the grounds forming the basis of those decisions and, in any event,
from using such information for the purposes of an administrative procedure or judicial proceedings.
However, EU law does not require that a court with jurisdiction in matters relating to residence should be able to
verify the lawfulness of the categorisation of information or to authorise access to classified information.
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
NOTE: A reference for a preliminary ruling allows the courts and tribunals of the Member States, in disputes which
have been brought before them, to refer questions to the Court of Justice about the interpretation of EU law or the
validity of an EU act. The Court of Justice does not decide the dispute itself. It is for the national court or tribunal to
dispose of the case in accordance with the Court’s decision, which is similarly binding on other national courts or
tribunals before which a similar issue is raised.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice.
The full text and, as the case may be, an abstract of the judgment is published on the CURIA website on the day of
delivery.
Stay Connected!
Communications Directorate
Trending
- FI: Craxi, Piemonte è straordinario bacino di dirigenti e consensi
- COMUNICATO STAMPA – Carabinieri: Battistoni (FI), riconoscenza per loro missione
- DE GENNARO, COSTA (FI): “LA MACELLERIA MEDIATICA HA FATTO UN’ALTRA VITTIMA
- Cortei: Miele (Lega), Andrea esempio di coraggio. Violenza non è libertà, difendere istituzioni è scelta di valore
- “Mia madre, mia figlia, mia sorella”, il programma di mercoledì 25 Incontro al PalaRinaldi sulle madri costituenti, “Amore e psiche” al museo
- Caso De Gennaro e Commissione Antimafia, Marinella Pacifico: «Tragico epilogo di un tentativo fallito di riscrivere la Storia. Resta il peso morale di cotanta spregiudicatezza»
- Dl Scuola: Costa, solo FI fa battaglie liberali, senza di noi non si vince
- Comunicato Stampa 2063/2026 Sanità. Il plauso del presidente Stefani per la prima donazione a cuore fermo all’Ospedale di Piove di Sacco (PD)
- DECRETO CORTEI, BONELLI (AVS): “DELMASTRO VUOLE TOGLIERE LE BORSE DI STUDIO AGLI STUDENTI INDAGATI? ALLORA SI TOLGA LO STIPENDIO A LUI, CHE È CONDANNATO
- Incontro pazienti-medici sui linfomi
