(AGENPARL) - Roma, 1 Febbraio 2024 - (AGENPARL) – gio 01 febbraio 2024 Newsletter
Week VI – VII: 5th – 16th February 2024
Contact us
@ENDesk
Jacques René
Zammit
Press Officer
Monica Pizzo
Assistant
Desk Email
Week VI – 5th to 9th February
Wednesday 7th February
General Court
Judgment in Case T-146/22 Ryanair v Commission (KLM II; COVID-19)
(State aid)
In 2020, the European Commission approved Dutch state aid to KLM, consisting of a
state guarantee for a bank loan and a state loan. The total aid budget was €3.4 billion.
The aim of the measure was to provide KLM with temporary liquidity in the context of
the COVID 19 pandemic.
Sorchadh
Higgins & Olivia
Moore assisted
in the
preparation of
this Newsletter.
However, in 2021, the General Court of the European Union annulled the
Commission’s decision for lack of reasoning as regards to the determination of the
beneficiary of the measure in question (T-643/20). It also decided to suspend the
effects of the annulment until the Commission adopted a new decision.
Thus, on July 16, 2021, the Commission adopted a new decision, in which it considered
that the State aid was compatible with the internal market and that KLM and its
Follow
@EUCourtPress
on X (formerly
subsidiaries were the only beneficiaries of the aid, to the exclusion of the other
Twitter)
Ryanair referred to the General Court to have the matter decided.
Download our
companies in the Air France-KLM group.
Background Documents T-146/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 8th February
Opinion in Case C-633/22 Real Madrid Club de Fútbol
(Area of Freedom, Security and Justice – Judicial cooperation in civil matters)
Communications Directorate
Press and Information unit
curia.europa.eu
Newsletter
Weeks VI – VII: 5th – 16th February 2024
On December 7, 2006, the digital edition of the French newspaper Le Monde published
an article, entitled “Le Real Madrid et le Barça liés au docteur Fuentès” (“Real Madrid and
Barça linked to Dr Fuentès”). The following day, the article appeared in the print
All times are 9:30
unless otherwise
stated.
edition, accompanied by an interview with the doctor in question. An extract from the
article appeared on the front page, along with a drawing captioned “Dopage: le football
après le cyclisme” (“Doping: first cycling, now football”).
Don’t forget to
The newspaper claimed that Real Madrid Club de Fútbol had retained the services of
check the diary
Dr. Fuentès, the head of a blood-doping ring previously uncovered in the cycling
on our website
world.
for details of
other cases.
Many media outlets, Spanish ones in particular, shared the article.
The club and a member of its medical team brought actions before the Spanish courts
against the newspaper company, Société Éditrice du Monde, and the author of the
article for damage to their reputation.
By a judgment of February 27, 2009, the Court of First Instance, Madrid, Spain ordered
Société Éditrice du Monde and the article author to pay €300,000 to the club and
€30,000 to the member of the medical team. The court also ordered that its decision
be published on the inside pages of Le Monde and on the front page and given the
same level of prominence as that used to publish the material at issue – in addition to
publication in a Spanish newspaper.
Following different judicial steps in the courts of both Spain and France, by its
judgment of September 15, 2020, the Court of Appeal in Paris held that the Spanish
decisions should not be enforced in France because they were clearly contrary to
French international public policy.
The French Court of Appeal concluded that the orders to pay an exceptional amount
made against a journalist and a media organisation have a deterrent effect and curtail
the media’s ability to perform its information and monitoring role, hence interfering
with freedom of expression and, therefore, international public policy.
It then lodged a request for preliminary ruling to the Court.
The referring Court wonders whether a financial penalty imposed for harm caused to
the reputation of a sports club and of a member of its medical team by the publication
of a story in a newspaper can be deemed to be contrary to freedom of expression,
and therefore constitute grounds for refusing to recognise and enforce a judgment.
Background Documents C-633/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Newsletter
Weeks VI – VII: 5th – 16th February 2024
Thursday 8th February
Judgment in Case C-216/22 Bundesrepublik Deutschland (Admissibility of a
subsequent application)
(Area of Freedom, Security and Justice – Border checks)
A Syrian who had left Syria in 2012, and claimed that he feared being called up for
military service or arrested if he refused to fulfill his military obligations, was granted
subsidiary protection in Germany in 2017. However, he was refused refugee status
according to the common standards for qualification laid down in Directive
2011/95/EU.
Following a ruling by the Court of Justice on the situation of Syrian conscientious
objectors (C-238/19), he again applied for asylum (the so-called “subsequent
application”). He argued that this ruling constituted a change in the legal situation in
his favour. However, the subsequent application was rejected as inadmissible, i.e.
without examining whether the conditions required to claim for refugee status had
been met.
The applicant challenged this refusal before a German court.
The referring court, asked the Court whether it is compatible with European Union law
to consider that, in principle, only a change in the applicable rules, and not a judicial
decision, can constitute a change in the legal situation justifying, where appropriate, a
full examination of the subsequent application.
Background Documents C-216/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 8th February
Judgments in Cases C-750/21 P and C-256/22 P Pilatus Bank plc v ECB
(Economic and monetary policy)
Pilatus Bank appealed in Court two decisions of the General Court.
In Case C-750/21 P, Pilatus Bank appealed against the Order of the General Court in
Case T-139/19. In September 2021, the General Court had dismissed Pilatus Bank’s
action for annulment of a decision of the European Central Bank (ECB) as manifestly
lacking any foundation in law. By decision of December 21, 2018, the ECB had
informed Pilatus Bank, by way of e-mail, that it was no longer competent to carry out
its direct prudential supervision and to take measures concerning it.
Newsletter
Weeks VI – VII: 5th – 16th February 2024
In Case C-256/22 P, Pilatus Bank sought an annulment of the judgment of the General
Court in Case T-27/19. In that judgment, the General Court dismissed the action by
Pilatus Bank seeking an annulment of the decision of the ECB of November 2, 2018,
withdrawing its authorisation for access to the business of credit institution.
The Court has now to decide on the two appeals.
Background documents C-750/21 P
Background documents C-256/22 P
There will be an Info Rapide for the case (available on request).
Week VII – 12th to 16th February
The Court will be in recess from the 12th to the 16th February inclusive.
HEARINGS OF NOTE*
Court of Justice
Wednesday 7th February: 09:30 – Case C-60/23 Digital Charging Solutions (Taxation)
Thursday 8th February: 09:30 – Case C-446/21 Schrems (Communicating data to the
general public) (Principles, objectives and tasks of the Treaties)
General Court
Tuesday 6th February: 09:30 – Case T-520/22 Kari? v Council (Restrictive measures –
Belarus)
Tuesday 6th February: 14:30 – Case T-742/22 Mazepin v Council (Restrictive measures –
Ukraine)
Wednesday 7th February: 09:30 – Cases T-396/22 Landesbank Baden-Württemberg
v SRB, C-397/22 Bayerische Landesbank v SRB, T-398/22 Deutsche Bank v SRB, T399/22 Landesbank Hessen-Thüringen Girozentrale v SRB, T-400/22 Berlin Hyp v SRB,
T-401/22 DZ Bank v SRB, T-402/22 DZ Hyp v SRB, T-403/22 DZ Bank v SRB, T-404/22
Deutsche Kreditbank v SRB, T-405/22 UniCredit Bank v SRB, T-407/22 Norddeutsche
Landesbank – Girozentrale v SRB, T-430/22 Nordea Bank v SRB, T-431/22 Nordea
Kiinnitysluottopankki v SRB, T-432/22 Nordea Rahoitus Suomi v SRB (Economic policy)
Wednesday 7th February: 09:30 – Case T-738/22 Rotenberg v Council (Restrictive
Newsletter
Weeks VI – VII: 5th – 16th February 2024
measures – Ukraine)
Thursday 8th February: 09:30 – Cases T-391/22 Société générale and Others v SRB, T392/22 Confédération nationale du Crédit mutuel and Others v SRB, T-393/22 BPCE
and Others v SRB, T-394/22 Banque postale v SRB, T-395/22 Hypo Vorarlberg Bank v
SRB, T-406/22 Volkskreditbank v SRB, T-410/22 Crédit agricole and Others v SRB, T411/22 Dexia v SRB, T-420/22 BNP Paribas v SRB, T-599/22 Hypo Vorarlberg Bank v
SRB, T-641/22 Portigon v SRB (Economic policy)
* This is a non-exhaustive list and does not include all the hearings over the next two
weeks.
Trending
- Pistoia Capitale Italiana del Libro: lunedì 23 novembre alla Biblioteca San Giorgio un incontro dedicato alla memoria delle vittime del lavoro e alla cultura della prevenzione
- Ausl Pc | “I gesti più belli partono dal cuore” , presentazione dell’iniziativa benefica di Conad Centro Nord per Pediatria
- BASKET IN CARROZZINA, TORNA IN CAMPO LA SERIE A CON LA QUARTA GIORNATA
- OSPFE – AUSLFE – Comunicato stampa congiunto GIORNATA DELL’ALBERO 2026: IL VERDE COME STRUMENTO DI SALUTE E CURA NELLE AZIENDE SANITARIE FERRARESI
- Antitrust – Comunicato Stampa – Antitrust: Il Presidente Valentino partecipa al DG Meeting dell’European Competition Network
- [Comune Palermo] Giaconia: “Trasporto pubblico locale, in diversi quartieri attese fino a due ore: disservizi gravi e sistematici su almeno nove linee AMAT
- Consiglio comunale, lunedì 23 novembre nuova seduta
- Concorso per 8 Guardie particolari giurate – Comunicato stampa
- POLIZIA DI STATO – BARI – Svolta nelle indagini sul cold case dell’omicidio di Maria Rita Valerio, avvenuto a Capurso il 17.12.2003
- Come difendersi dalle truffe: secondo incontro
