(AGENPARL) - Roma, 19 Dicembre 2024 - (AGENPARL) – gio 19 dicembre 2024 PRESS RELEASE No 205/24
Luxembourg, 19 December 2024
Judgment of the Court in Case C-664/23 | Caisse d’allocations familiales des Hauts-de-Seine
A Member State cannot exclude from the benefit of family allowances a
foreign worker whose children, born in a third country, cannot prove that
they have entered its territory lawfully
Third-country nationals who have been admitted to a Member State for the purpose of working there lawfully
must enjoy equal treatment with nationals of that Member State
In 2008, an Armenian national entered the French territory unlawfully, with his wife and two minor children born in
Armenia. In 2011, the couple gave birth to a third child in France. In 2014, the father applied for family benefits for
his three children. Although he held a temporary residence permit authorising him to work, the Caisse d’allocations
familiales des Hauts-de-Seine (Hauts-de-Seine Family Allowance Fund, France) (CAF) refused his application in
respect of his two children born outside of France.
That refusal, which he challenged before the Tribunal des affaires de sécurité sociale de Nanterre (Social Security
Court, Nanterre, France), was based on the lack of documents proving the children’s lawful entry into France.
After
a favourable judgment, the Cour d’appel de Versailles (Court of Appeal, Versailles, France) confirmed the refusal. The
Cour de cassation (Court of Cassation, France), however, overturned the judgment in 2022, emphasising that the
Cour d’appel had not responded to the Armenian national’s arguments regarding the Single Permit Directive,
which ensures equal treatment between workers who are nationals of third countries and EU citizens. The case was
referred back to the Cour d’appel, which decided to refer the matter to the Court of Justice of the European Union. It
wishes to know whether a Member State may refuse to take into account children born in a third country and
dependent on a single permit holder where they have not entered the territory under a family reunification
procedure or where the parent has not provided documents proving the lawfulness of their entry into the territory.
The Court responds that it is contrary to EU law to subject the right to family benefits of third-country nationals
legally residing in France to an additional requirement, consisting in the proof that the children in respect of
whom the family benefits have been applied for have entered the French territory lawfully. The Court considers that
imposing such a requirement provides third-country nationals with less favourable treatment than that enjoyed
by nationals of the host Member State.
It recalls that EU law provides for equal treatment between third-country nationals residing lawfully in the territory
of the Member States and nationals of those Member States.
Where the lawful residence of the third-country national in a Member State is established, it is for the Member
States to ensure equal treatment between those workers residing in their territory and their own nationals by
strictly limiting derogations from that right.
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
NOTE: A reference for a preliminary ruling allows the courts and tribunals of the Member States, in disputes which
have been brought before them, to refer questions to the Court of Justice about the interpretation of EU law or the
validity of an EU act. The Court of Justice does not decide the dispute itself. It is for the national court or tribunal to
dispose of the case in accordance with the Court’s decision, which is similarly binding on other national courts or
tribunals before which a similar issue is raised.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice.
The full text and, as the case may be, an abstract of the judgment is published on the CURIA website on the day of
delivery.
Stay Connected!
In this case, it was necessary to produce either a prefectural certificate stating that the child had entered France at the latest at the same time as
one of his or her parents admitted to stay, or a medical certificate issued under a family reunification procedure.
Directive 2011/98/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 December 2011 on a single application procedure for a single permit for
third-country nationals to reside and work in the territory of a Member State and on a common set of rights for third -country workers legally residing
in a Member State.
Communications Directorate
Trending
- Funzioni locali, Ministro Zangrillo: “Restituire centralità alle persone per una PA più moderna ed efficiente”
- Comunicato Stampa 2035/2026 GdF di Padova sequestra finti centri massaggi cinesi. Assessore Roma, “Una donna già entrata nella rete di protezione regionale offerta dal progetto antitratta NAVIGARe
- EX ILVA, TURCO (M5S): ACCORDO DI PROGRAMMA PER RICONVERTIRE TARANTO
- SARDEGNA, MURA (FDI): GOVERNO VALUTI COMMISSARIAMENTO DELLA GESTIONE REGIONALE DEI COLLEGAMENTI AEREI IN CONTINUITÀ TERRITORIALE
- Tribunale Islamico a Padova, Lega: bloccato tentativo di esportare Sharia con nostra interrogazione
- Nota di Palazzo Chigi
- Etiopia ed Eritrea, tensioni al confine. ACLED riferisce del ritorno delle truppe eritree a Badme
- Consulta dei Giovani e Centro Donna: sottoscritto un protocollo di collaborazione tra le due realtà
- Caltanissetta, emergenza lavoro: occupazione al 41,7%, precarietà diffusa e giovani in fuga. Il divario con il resto d’Italia resta profondo
- Ruotolo: Il futuro della scuola deve essere deciso da insegnati e studenti, non dagli algoritmi
