(AGENPARL) - Roma, 23 Maggio 2024 - (AGENPARL) – gio 23 maggio 2024 Newsletter
Week XXII – XXIII: 27th May – 7th June 2024
Contact us
@ENDesk
Jacques René
Zammit
Press Officer
Monica Pizzo
Assistant
Desk Email
Graziella
Week XXII 27th to 31st May
Wednesday 29th May
General Court
Judgment in Cases T-200/22 and T-314/22 Poland v Commission
(Law governing the institutions)
In February 2021, the Czech Republic brought an action against Poland before the
Court of Justice alleging that the extension and prolongation of lignite extraction
activities at the Turów mine (Poland) infringed EU law (see case C-121/21 Czech
Republic v Poland (Mine de Turów)).
In the course of the proceedings, the Court ordered Poland (see Order C-121/21 R,
Schembri
May 21, 2021 – press release 89/21), by way of interim measures, to immediately
assisted in the
cease extraction activities at the mine until the delivery of the judgment closing the
preparation of
case. On September 20, 2021, since Poland had not complied, the European
this Newsletter.
Commission ordered it to pay a daily penalty of €500,000 until it complied with the
interim measure.
Follow
@EUCourtPress
on X (formerly
Poland has not paid the sums due in this respect. For this reason, in five consecutive
Twitter)
decisions, the Commission informed it that it was offsetting this debt against various
claims held by Poland against the EU. The principal amount thus recovered is
€68,500,000.
Download our
Poland asks the Court to annul the offsetting decisions. It relies, in particular, on the
amicable agreement, which it concluded in February 2022 with the Czech Republic,
resulting in the removal of the case from the Court’s register. The conclusion of this
agreement means that the pecuniary effects of the measures ordered by the Court
have ceased to apply retroactively.
The compensation paid by the Commission would therefore be unlawful.
Background Documents T-200/22
Background Documents T-314/22
Communications Directorate
Press and Information unit
curia.europa.eu
Newsletter
Weeks XXII – XXIII: 27th May – 7th June 2024
There will be one press release for these cases.
All times are 9:30
unless otherwise
stated.
Don’t forget to
Wednesday 29th May
General Court
check the diary
on our website
Judgment in Case T-58/23 Supermac’s v EUIPO – McDonald’s International
for details of
Property (BIG MAC)
other cases.
(Intellectual, industrial and commercial property – Trade marks)
Supermac’s and McDonald’s, an Irish and American fast food chain respectively,
are involved in a dispute concerning the use of the word sign BIG MAC registered
in the EU.
McDonald’s registered the word sign in 1996 to cover a number of goods and services.
In 2017, Supermac’s applied for revocation on the grounds that the mark
had not been put to genuine use in the EU for an uninterrupted period of five years.
The European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) had established the
revocation of rights in respect of certain goods and services.
However, it confirmed McDonald’s right to use the word sign BIG MAC for certain goods and
services, including meat and chicken sandwiches, as well as for services provided or
connected with the operation of restaurants and other catering establishments or
infrastructures for consumption and “drive-in”.
Supermac challenged EUIPO’s decision before the General Court.
Background Documents T-58/23
There will be a press release for this case.
Wednesday 29th May
General Court
Judgment in Case T-395/22 Hypo Vorarlberg Bank v SRB (Ex-ante contributions
2022)
(Economic and monetary policy)
The Austrian credit institution Hypo Vorarlberg Bank is challenging before the General
Court of the European Union the lawfulness of the Decision SRB/ES/2022/18 of the
Single Resolution Board (SRB) of 11 April 2022 on the calculation of the 2022 ex-ante
contributions to the Single Resolution Fund (SRF), in so far as that decision concerns
Newsletter
Weeks XXII – XXIII: 27th May – 7th June 2024
Hypo Vorarlberg Bank.
According to the Bank, that decision was unlawful because it was based on rules,
which were, in turn, unlawful.
Moreover, in the contested decision, Hypo Vorarlberg Bank states that SRB exceeded
an annual ceiling imposed by the applicable legislation, particularly Regulation (EU)
No 806/2014, establishing uniform rules and a uniform procedure for the resolution of
credit institutions and certain investment firms in the framework of a Single
Resolution Mechanism and a Single Resolution Fund.
In particular, the ex-ante contributions of all the institutions authorised in the
territories of all the Member States participating in the Single Resolution Mechanism
(SRM) are not to exceed 12.5% of the financial means that should be available in the
SRF at the end of 2023.
Background Documents T-395/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 30th May
Judgment in Joined Cases C-662/22 | Airbnb Ireland and C-667/22 | Amazon
Services Europe, Case C-663/22 | Expedia, Joined Cases C-664/22 | Google Ireland
and C-666/22 | Eg Vacation Rentals Ireland and Case C-665/22 Amazon Services
Europe
(Freedom to provide services – Internal market & Principles – Consumer protection)
In Italy, providers of intermediation services and online search engines, such as
Airbnb, Google, Amazon and Vacation Rentals, are subject to certain obligations.
In particular, they must join a register, periodically submit a document on their
economic situation, provide a series of detailed information to an administrative
authority and pay a financial contribution. Penalties are in place for failure to meet
these obligations.
The companies concerned are challenging these obligations before an Italian court.
In their view, this increase in administrative burdens is contrary to EU law, namely the
principle of freedom to provide services (see in particular Directive 2000/31/EC on
electronic commerce and Regulation (EU) 2019/1150 on promoting fairness and
transparency for business users of online intermediation services).
In addition, all these companies – except Expedia, which is established in the United
Newsletter
Weeks XXII – XXIII: 27th May – 7th June 2024
States – argue that they are primarily subject to the legal regime of the Member State
in which they are established (in this case, Ireland or Luxembourg).
As a result, they consider that Italian law cannot impose other requirements on them
relating to access to an information company services activity.
Against this background, the Italian court decided to refer the matter to the Court of
Justice.
Background Documents C-662/22 and C-667/22
Background Documents C-664/22 and C-666/22
Background Documents C-665/22
There will be one press release for these cases.
Thursday 30th May
Judgment in Case C-400/22 Conny
(Approximation of laws – Consumer protection)
In Germany, a tenant of a flat whose monthly rent exceeded the maximum authorised
limit, asked a debt collection company to reclaim overpayments of rent from his
landlord.
He placed the order via the company’s website, where, before clicking on the order
button, he ticked a box accepting the terms and conditions, which stated that the
tenant had to pay a fee of one third of the annual rent saved if the service provider’s
attempts to enforce his rights were successful.
In the ensuing dispute between the service provider and the landlord, the latter
argued that the tenant had not validly commissioned the service provider.
The order button did not contain the words “order with obligation to pay” (or similar
wording), as required by the Consumer Rights Directive (Directive 2011/83/EU).
According to the lessor, this requirement also applies where the lessee’s obligation to
pay does not arise from the order alone, but still requires the successful enforcement
of his rights.
The German court hearing this case asked the Court of Justice about this.
Background Documents C-400/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Newsletter
Weeks XXII – XXIII: 27th May – 7th June 2024
Thursday 30th May
Opinion in Case C-23/23 Commission v Malta (Derogation for research purposes)
(Environment)
In the European Union, wild finches are protected by the Birds Directive.
The primary objective of the Directive is the preservation of all bird species diversity,
meaning that the deliberate killing or capture of birds and the use of large
scale or non-selective methods to do so is forbidden.
The Directive, however, prescribes specific circumstances whereby the general
prohibition may be derogated from.
When Malta joined the EU, the relative Accession Treaty provided for a transition period
Trending
- CASSANO ALL’IONIO, CONVOCATO IL CONSIGLIO COMUNALE PER IL 24 NOVEMBRE: QUATTRO PUNTI ALL’ORDINE DEL GIORNO, TUTTI LEGATI ALLE SOMME URGENZE PER IL CICLONE HARRY E L’ESONDAZIONE DEL CRATI
- OSPFE – AUSLFE – Comunicato stampa congiunto LA RICERCA ODONTOIATRICA FERRARESE PREMIATA A SALERNO
- Festa dell’Albero, a Castiglione della Pescaia due giornate dedicate ai più piccoli e alla tutela della biodiversità
- Lunedì pomeriggio l’inaugurazione della strada comunale Spezzamadonna
- Presentazione nuovo assessore alle Attività produttive – INVITO CONFERENZA STAMPA
- Mastella: “Ignobile aggressione al dottore Parente, massima solidarietà
- Data center negli Stati Uniti, il boom dell’intelligenza artificiale si scontra con la nuova realtà politica: 300 GW di progetti e regole più severe per l’energia
- Controlli sui mezzi pesanti della Polizia Locale
- Il valore della cura”, incontro alla Biblioteca Rendella
- Musei in Musica, questa sera edizione speciale di Montecitorio a porte aperte
