(AGENPARL) - Roma, 30 Aprile 2024 - (AGENPARL) – mar 30 aprile 2024 PRESS RELEASE No 77/24
Luxembourg, 30 April 2024
Judgment of the Court in Case C-670/22 | M.N. (EncroChat)
EncroChat: the Court of Justice clarifies the conditions for the transmission
and use of evidence in criminal cases with a cross-border dimension
In the context of criminal proceedings in Germany concerning illegal drug trafficking involving the use of the
encrypted telecommunications service EncroChat, the Court of Justice clarifies certain conditions for the
transmission and use of evidence under the Directive regarding the European Investigation Order (EIO) in criminal
matters.
Thus, an EIO for the transmission of evidence already gathered by another Member State may, under certain
conditions, be issued by a public prosecutor. The conditions applicable to the gathering of evidence in the issuing
State do not need to have been satisfied in order for the EIO to be issued. It must, however, be possible for
compliance with the fundamental rights of the persons concerned to be judicially reviewed subsequently. Moreover,
an interception measure carried out by one Member State on the territory of another Member State must be
notified in good time to that other Member State. Information and evidence obtained in breach of the directive
must, under certain conditions, be disregarded by the criminal courts.
The French police were able, with the assistance of Dutch experts and the authorisation of a French court, to
infiltrate the encrypted telecommunications service EncroChat. The service was being used worldwide on encrypted
mobile phones for the purpose of illegal drug trafficking. The German Federal Criminal Police Office was able, via a
Europol server, to retrieve the intercepted data relating to EncroChat users in Germany.
Acting on the EIOs issued by the German public prosecutor’s office, the French court authorised the transmission of
those data and their use in criminal proceedings in Germany.
The Regional Court of Berlin, before which criminal proceedings were brought, queries the lawfulness of those EIOs.
It therefore submitted to the Court of Justice a series of questions for a preliminary ruling on the Directive regarding
the European Investigation Order in criminal matters 1.
The reply given by the Court of Justice is that an EIO for the transmission of evidence already in the possession
of the competent authorities of the executing State (in this case, France) does not necessarily need to be
issued by a judge. It may be issued by a public prosecutor if he or she is competent, in a purely domestic case, to
order the transmission of evidence that has already been gathered.
Furthermore, the issuing of such an EIO is subject to the same substantive conditions as those that apply to
the transmission of similar evidence in a purely domestic situation. It does not, however, need to satisfy the
same substantive conditions as those that apply to the gathering of evidence. The fact that, in this case, the
French authorities gathered the evidence in Germany and in the interest of their German counterparts is, in that
respect, in principle irrelevant. However, a court before which an action against that EIO is brought must be
able to review compliance with the fundamental rights of the persons concerned.
The Court of Justice also makes clear that a measure entailing the infiltration of terminal devices for the
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
purpose of gathering traffic, location and communication data of an internet-based communication service must be
notified to the Member State in which the subject of that measure is located (in this case, Germany). The
competent authority of that Member State then has the right to indicate that that interception of
telecommunications may not be carried out or must be terminated, if it would not be authorised in a similar
domestic case. Those rights and obligations are intended not only to guarantee respect for the sovereignty of the
notified Member State but also to protect the rights of the persons concerned.
Information and evidence obtained in breach of the directive must be disregarded by the national criminal
courts if the person concerned is not in a position to comment on that information and on that evidence
and the said information and evidence are likely to have a preponderant influence on the findings of fact.
NOTE: A reference for a preliminary ruling allows the courts and tribunals of the Member States, in disputes which
have been brought before them, to refer questions to the Court of Justice about the interpretation of EU law or the
validity of an EU act. The Court of Justice does not decide the dispute itself. It is for the national court or tribunal to
dispose of the case in accordance with the Court’s decision, which is similarly binding on other national courts or
tribunals before which a similar issue is raised.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice.
The full text and, as the case may be, an abstract of the judgment is published on the CURIA website on the day of
delivery.
Stay Connected!
Directive 2014/41/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 3 April 2014 regarding the European Investigation Order in criminal matters.
Communications Directorate
Trending
- Caso De Gennaro e Commissione Antimafia, Marinella Pacifico: «Tragico epilogo di un tentativo fallito di riscrivere la Storia. Resta il peso morale di cotanta spregiudicatezza»
- Dl Scuola: Costa, solo FI fa battaglie liberali, senza di noi non si vince
- Comunicato Stampa 2063/2026 Sanità. Il plauso del presidente Stefani per la prima donazione a cuore fermo all’Ospedale di Piove di Sacco (PD)
- DECRETO CORTEI, BONELLI (AVS): “DELMASTRO VUOLE TOGLIERE LE BORSE DI STUDIO AGLI STUDENTI INDAGATI? ALLORA SI TOLGA LO STIPENDIO A LUI, CHE È CONDANNATO
- Incontro pazienti-medici sui linfomi
- Com. stampa n. 793 (Stop alle sedute operatorie in ospedale, il sindaco controreplica alla Corsi: “Commovente il racconto del Direttore Sanitario dell’Ast”) + foto
- POLIZIA DI STATO-Cordoglio Capo della Polizia Prefetto Pisani
- [Comune Palermo] Piscina comunale. Consegnati lavori vasche
- DE GENNARO. ROTONDI (FDI): ‘HA RAGIONE CASINI,OGGI LA MAFIA BRINDA
- De Gennaro: Ronzulli (FI), pensiero a famiglia, basta processi mediatici
