(AGENPARL) - Roma, 18 Gennaio 2024 - (AGENPARL) – gio 18 gennaio 2024 Newsletter
Week IV – V: 22nd January – 2nd February 2024
Contact us
@ENDesk
Info Update: Streaming on CVRIA website
Reminder: Streaming of Grand Chamber Hearings
Jacques René
Hearings in Grand Chamber Cases will generally be delay-streamed on the CVRIA
Zammit
website. These hearings generally take place on Tuesdays.
Press Officer
and the stream will remain available until midnight of the same day.
Monica Pizzo
Hearings that last one morning are streamed in the afternoon of the same day
Hearings that last the full day will be streamed on the next day and will remain
available until midnight.
Assistant
New: Streaming of Judgments and Opinions delivered on Thursdays
We are pleased to announce that, as of this week, all Thursday morning readings of
Desk Email
Sorchadh
Higgins & Olivia
Moore assisted
in the
preparation of
this Newsletter.
judgments and opinions will be broadcast live on the CVRIA website. This concerns all
judgments and opinions of the Court (all chambers) scheduled for delivery on
Thursday morning.
Link: CVRIA website
All streaming, whether delayed or live, is accessible here.
Week IV – 22nd to 26th January
Wednesday 24th January
Follow
@EUCourtPress
on X (formerly
Judgment in Case T-562/22 Noah Clothing / EUIPO – Noah (NOAH)
Twitter)
(Intellectual, Industrial and Commercial Property – Trade marks)
In 2008, Mr Yannick Noah, a former French tennis player, registered the following figurative sign
Download our
with the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) as a European Union trademark:
This registration concerned, in particular, leather and imitation leather goods, clothing –
Communications Directorate
Press and Information unit
curia.europa.eu
Newsletter
Weeks IV – V: 22nd January – 2 February 2024
including polo shirts and sweaters – as well as games and toys.
In 2019, Noah Clothing LLC, a New York-based company that markets clothing, filed an
application for revocation of this trademark with the EUIPO, on the grounds that it had not been
All times are 9:30
put to genuine use in the European Union for an uninterrupted period of five years for all the
unless otherwise
goods concerned.
stated.
In July 2022, the EUIPO declared the revocation of the contested trademark for all the goods
Don’t forget to
concerned, with the exception of “polo shirts” and “sweaters”.
check the diary
on our website
Noah Clothing LLC asks the Court of the European Union to annul the EUIPO’s decision insofar
for details of
as it did not also declare the revocation of the contested mark for “polo shirts” and “sweaters”.
other cases.
Background Documents T-562/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Wednesday 24th January
Judgment in Case T-537/22 Delta-Sport Handelskontor / EUIPO – Lego (Building
block for a construction toy box)
(Intellectual, Industrial and Commercial Property – Designs)
Lego is the owner of the following EU design, registered on February 2, 2010, for “construction
elements of a construction toy box”:
In a ruling on May 30, 2022,, the Board of Appeal of the European Union Intellectual Property
Office (EUIPO) rejected an application for a declaration of invalidity filed by Delta Sport
Handelskontor. It held that the contested Lego toy brick design could not be declared invalid, as
it benefited from an exception protecting modular systems.
Delta Sport Handelskontor is asking the General Court to annul the EUIPO’s decision insofar as
it wrongly concluded that the design benefited from an exception under EU law protecting
modular systems.
Background Documents T-537/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 25th January
Newsletter
Weeks IV – V: 22nd January – 2 February 2024
Judgment in Cases C-474/22 Laudamotion (Renouncing a late flight) and C-54/23
Laudamotion et Ryanair
(Transport)
The two requests for a preliminary ruling by the Bundesgerichtshof (Federal Court of
Justice, Germany), both focus on the interpretation of Regulation (EC) No. 261/2004,
establishing common rules on compensation and assistance to passengers in the
event of denied boarding and of cancellation or long delay of flights.
The case C-54/23 Laudamotion and Ryanair relates to a dispute between WY, an air
passenger, and Laudamotion GmbH and Ryanair DAC, concerning the refusal of these
two air carriers to compensate the passenger for a delay in the arrival of a flight for
which he had booked.
WY booked a return flight with Ryanair from Düsseldorf (Germany) to Palma de
Mallorca (Spain), scheduled for October 31, 2019. Having been informed by
Laudamotion, the operating air carrier, that the departure of the outbound flight
(hereinafter the “original flight”) would be delayed by six hours, this passenger booked
himself a replacement flight to honour a business appointment to be held in Palma de
Majorca.
Thanks to this alternative flight, he finally arrived at his destination less than three
hours later than the scheduled arrival time of the initial flight, three hours or
more after the scheduled arrival time being the minimum to seek flat-rate
compensation from the airline (Joined cases C-402/07 and C-432/07). The passenger,
who stated that he had checked in on time for the initial flight, claimed compensation
of €250 from Laudamotion under Regulation 261/2004. The passenger also asked
Ryanair for information on the amount of unabsorbed taxes and their payment.
The case C-474/22 Laudamotion v flightright deals with a preliminary ruling in a dispute
between Laudamotion GmbH, an air carrier, and flightright GmbH, a legal assistance
company to which an air passenger had assigned his rights against Laudamotion,
concerning compensation claimed as a result of the long delay of a flight for which the
passenger had a confirmed reservation.
The air passenger had a confirmed reservation with Laudamotion for a flight from
Düsseldorf (Germany) to Palma de Mallorca (Spain), scheduled for June 26, 2018.
Believing that the announced delay of this flight would cause him to miss a business
appointment, this passenger decided not to board the flight, which arrived at its
destination 3 hours and 32 minutes late.
Flightright, to which the passenger had assigned his rights, brought an action for
compensation in the sum of €250, on the basis of Regulation 261/2004.
Newsletter
Weeks IV – V: 22nd January – 2 February 2024
Background Documents C-474/22
Background Documents C-54/23
There will be one press release for these cases.
Thursday 25th January
Opinion in Case C-753/22 Bundesrepublik Deutschland (Effect of refugee status
decision)
(Area of Freedom, Security and Justice – Border checks)
The Bundesverwaltungsgericht (Federal Administrative Court, Germany) has made a
request for a preliminary ruling in proceedings between QY – a Syrian national who
was granted refugee status in Greece – and the Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge
(Federal Office for Migration and Refugees; ‘the Federal Office’) concerning the latter’s
decision to reject QY’s application for recognition of that status.
Germany, as the Member State to which the application for refugee status has been
made (‘the second Member State’) cannot return QY to Greece, the Member State that
first granted her such status (‘the first Member State’). That would expose her to a
serious risk of being subject to inhuman or degrading treatment within the meaning of
Article 4 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (‘the Charter’),
because of the living conditions for refugees in that Member State.
The referring court asks whether EU primary law (Article 78 TFEU) and the relevant
rules of three acts adopted in the field of EU refugee law: the Dublin III Regulation, the
Procedures Directive and the Qualification Directive bind the second Member State to
recognise the refugee status granted by the first Member State, without further
examining the material conditions necessary to qualify for refugee status.
The present case raises the question of whether there may be mutual recognition of
decisions granting refugee status between the Member States and, if so, whether that
recognition continues to exist when mutual trust can no longer be presumed.
Similar questions are currently the subject of three further cases pending before the
Court of Justice: El Baheer (C-288/23), Cassen (C-551/23), and opinion of Advocate
General Richard de la Tour in Generalstaatsanwaltschaft Hamm (Request for the
extradition of a refugee to Türkiye) (C-352/22).
Background Documents C-753/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Newsletter
Weeks IV – V: 22nd January – 2 February 2024
Thursday 25th January
Judgment in Case C-334/22 Audi (Emblem support on a front grille)
(Intellectual, industrial and commercial property – Trade marks)
The automobile manufacturer Audi is the owner of the following European Union
figurative trademark :
This is registered, inter alia, for vehicles, spare parts and automotive accessories.
This mark is reproduced and used as the Audi emblem. A Polish retailer offers for sale,
by advertising on its website, non-original grilles adapted for older Audi models. These
radiator grilles include a component similar or identical in shape to this trademark,
designed to hold the Audi emblem.
Audi took legal action against the dealer. It wants to prohibit non-original grilles
bearing a sign identical or similar to the AudiI trademark from marketing. The
company asked the Court of Justice to determine whether the marketing of car parts,
such as the grilles in question, constitutes “use of a sign in the course of trade” liable
to impair the functions of the Audi trademark under EU law. It also questioned
whether the owner of that trademark can prohibit a third party from such use.
Background Documents C-334/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 25th January
Judgment in Case C-481/22 Commission v Ireland (Trihalomethanes in drinking
water)
(Public health)
Trihalomethanes (known as ‘THMs’) are chemical compounds often found in drinking
water, especially in water treatment systems that use chlorine to remove bacteria and
contaminants. They are dangerous to both human health and to the environment.
Since January 1, 2014, Irish Water, which provides public water management services
in Ireland, has ensured that the quality of drinking water meets the standards
established by Directive 98/83 on the quality of water intended for human
consumption, as well as by the national rules transposing the directive into the Irish
Newsletter
Weeks IV – V: 22nd January – 2 February 2024
In December 2014 and January 2015, the Commission asked the Irish authorities to
provide information on the implementation of Directive 98/83 in Ireland. Following an
examination of the information provided, the Commission informed the Irish
authorities on May 11, 2015 that the situation described did not comply with Directive
98/83.
After investigating three progress reports from Irish authorities, the Commission sent
a letter of formal notice to Ireland on July 20, 2018. On October 19, 2018, Ireland
responded, detailing the progress already made and indicating its full compliance with
the requirements of Directive 98/83 by the end of 2021.
On May 15, 2020, the Commission sent a reasoned opinion, considering that Ireland
had failed to fulfil its obligations under Directive 98/83. It had failed to adopt the
necessary measures to ensure that water intended for human consumption met the
minimum requirement relating to the presence of THMs. It also had not taken into
account the extent to which the parametric value of THMs had been exceeded,
endangering public health.
The Commission ordered Ireland to comply with its obligations by September 15,
2020. Dissatisfied with the subsequent responses and information provided by Ireland
between September 2020 and June 2021, the Commission decided to bring the
present action for infringement.
Background Documents C-481/22
There will be an Info Rapide for the case (available on request).
Week V – 29th January to 2nd February
Tuesday 30th January
Judgment in Case C-560/20 Landeshauptmann von Wien (Family reunification
with a refugee minor)
(Area of Freedom, Security and Justice – Asylum policy)
After an unaccompanied Syrian minor was granted refugee status in Austria, his
parents and his adult sister applied for residence permits so that they could join him.
The Austrian authorities rejected these applications on the grounds that, in the
interim, the young Syrian had become an adult. Their subsequent applications for
family reunification were rejected on the grounds that they had not been submitted
within three months of the young Syrian’s refugee status being recognised.
Newsletter
Weeks IV – V: 22nd January – 2 February 2024
The parents and sister challenged this latest refusal before the Vienna Administrative
Court.
The Austrian referring court asked the Court of Justice to interpret the directive on the
right to family reunification. It stated, among other things, that due to a serious illness,
the sister was totally and permanently dependent on the assistance of her parents, so
that they could not leave her alone in Syria.
Background Documents C-560/20
There will be a press release for this case.
Tuesday 30th January
Judgment in Case C-118/22 Direktor na Glavna direktsia „Natsionalna politsia“
pri MVR – Sofia
(Area of Freedom, Security and Justice – Judicial cooperation in civil matters)
Varhoven administrativen sad (Supreme Administrative Court, Bulgaria)referred
questions concerning the interpretation of Directive (EU) 2016/680, the data
protection law enforcement directive (the ‘LED Directive’). The directive ensures
the protection of personal data of individuals involved in criminal proceedings, be it as
witnesses, victims or suspects.
The request was made in the context of a dispute between NG and the Director of the
General Directorate “National Police” at the Ministry of the Interior, Bulgaria (“the
DGPN”). The DGPN had rejected NG’s request to be removed from the police national
register, in which the Bulgarian police authorities enter persons prosecuted for an
intentional criminal offence subject to public prosecution.
The request was based on NG’s rehabilitation/pardon granted on March 14, 2020,
following his final criminal conviction for perjury on December 2, 2016, for which NG
had been sentenced to a one-year probationary term. The DGPN rejected the request,
considering that a final criminal conviction, even in the event of a pardon, is not one of
the grounds for removal from the police register.
The referring court asked the Court whether the interpretation of the LED Directive
precludes national legislative measures that would lead to a virtually unlimited right to
the processing of personal data by the competent authorities for the purposes of the
prevention and detection of criminal offences, investigation and prosecution of
criminal offences, or the execution of criminal penalties.
Background Documents C-118/22
Newsletter
Weeks IV – V: 22nd January – 2 February 2024
There will be a press release for this case.
Tuesday 30th January
Judgment in Case C-442/22 Dyrektor Izby Administracji Skarbowej w Lublinie
(Employee fraud)
(Taxation)
The Polish Supreme Administrative Court submitted a reference for a preliminary
ruling concerning the interpretation of the VAT Directive (Council Directive
2006/112/EC).
Between January 2010 and April 2014, an employee of the company based in Poland
issued 1,679 invoices that did not reflect actual sales of goods, for a total value
equivalent to around €320,000. The company was named as the issuer of these
fraudulent invoices, even though they were issued without the consent or knowledge
of its management; nor were they accounted for in the company’s tax returns. The
invoices were used to obtain undue VAT refunds from their recipients, without the
corresponding tax having been paid into the State budget.
Following an audit, the Polish tax authorities issued a ruling determining the amount
of VAT owed by the company. According to the tax authorities, the fraudulent actions
of the employee in question were possible due to the lack of supervision and proper
organisation within the company.
The company contested this decision before the national court, which in turn referred
the matter to the Court of Justice. The referring court wishes the Court of Justice to
clarify who, in the present circumstances, is the person who mentions the VAT on the
invoice, within the meaning of the VAT Directive and is therefore liable for VAT: the
company whose data was used illegally on the invoice, or the employee who used this
data to issue false invoices.
Background Documents C-442/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Wednesday 31th January
Judgment in Case T-56/22 United Kingdom v Commission
(Agriculture and fisheries – European Agricultural Guidance and Guarantee Fund (EAGGF))
The United Kingdom (UK) seeks the annulment of Commission Implementing Decision
Newsletter
Weeks IV – V: 22nd January – 2 February 2024
(EU) 2021/2020, on the exclusion from EU financing of some expenditure incurred by
the Member States under the European Agricultural Guarantee Fund (EAGF) and the
European Agricultural Fund for Rural Development (EAFRD) at the General Court.
The decision was adopted on November 17, 2021, and the annulment sought
concerns the expenditure allegedly incurred by the UK in 2017 amounting to
€2,686,358.72.
In March 2018, the Commission had opened an inquiry into the UK’s handling of EAGF
and EAFRD funds to UK farmers to verify the conformity of UK’s control of those grant
funds with the EU legislation in the years 2015-2019, according to rules laid down in
the EU’s common agricultural policy (CAP), Regulation (EU) No 1306/2013.
On December 22, 2020, before the date of the end of Brexit transition period, the
Commission sent their final conclusions to the UK, the Commission notified the UK
that the control system on the award of EAGF and EAFRD funds to farmers by the UK
was contrary to EU law, prompting the UK to provide a detailed description of the
corrective measures implemented.
After concluding the investigation, the Commission sent the UK a summary report on
May 18, 2021, claiming, among other things, that the UK failed to take into account
related companies in 2017 when checking the “status of active farmers” of the
applicants for aid under the EAGF and EAFRD – thus breaching Regulation (EU)
1307/2013.
As a result, it proposed to apply a financial correction amounting to €2,686,358.72.
Background Documents T-56/22
There will be an Info Rapide for the case (available on request).
Thursday 1st February
Judgment in Case C-251/22 P Scania and Others v Commission
(Competition)
By their appeal, Scania AB, Scania CV AB and Scania Deutschland GmbH (‘Scania DE’),
three legal entities of the undertaking Scania (together ‘Scania’), seek the annulment
of the judgment of the General Court of the European Union of February 2, 2022,
Scania and Others v Commission (T-799/17)
The contested judgment dismissed Scania’s action, which was mainly seeking
annulment of the contested decision and, in the alternative, to reduce the amount of
the fines imposed on them in that decision.
Newsletter
Weeks IV – V: 22nd January – 2 February 2024
The Commission decision had considered that the agreements and/or concerted
practices between Scania and the settling parties constituted a single and continuous
infringement of Article 101 TFEU and Article 53 of the Agreement on the European
Economic Area (EEA Agreement) (Case AT.39824 – Trucks) from January 17, 1997 until
January 18, 2011. The infringement consisted of collusion with respect to pricing and
gross price increases in the EEA for medium and heavy trucks – hence restricting
competition on the market for those trucks – and the timing and passing on of costs
for the introduction of trucks complying with environmental standards (emission
technologies Euro 3 to 6 standards).
The Commission had then imposed a joint fine of €880,523,000 euros on Scania AB
and Scania CV AB, with Scania DE held jointly and severally liable for payment of
€440,003,282.
The Court will now decide on this appeal.
Background Documents C-251/22 P
There will be a press release for this case.
HEARINGS OF NOTE*
Court of Justice
Tuesday 23th January: 09:00 – Case C-4/23 Mirin (Citizenship of the Union – Right of entry
and residence)
Wednesday 24th January: 09:30 – Joined Cases C-647/21 and T-648/21 D. K. (Dismissal
of a judge) and M.C. and M.F. (Dismissal of a judge) (Principles of Community law)
Thursday 25th January: 09:00 – Case C-159/23 Sony Computer Entertainment Europe
(Intellectual, industrial and commercial property)
Thursday 25th January: 09:30 – Case C-109/23 Jemerak (Common foreign and security
policy – Russia sanctions regulation)
Wednesday 31st January: 09:30 – Case C-447/22 P Slovenia v Flašker and Commission
(State aid)
General Court
Monday 22nd January: 14:30 – Cases T-290/22 and T-763/22 Kesaev v Council (Restrictive
measures – Ukraine)
Tuesday 23th January: 09:30 – Case T-741/22 Ezubov v Council (Restrictive measures –
Ukraine)
Newsletter
Weeks IV – V: 22nd January – 2 February 2024
Tuesday 23th January: 09:30 – Case T-494/22 NSD v Council (Restrictive measures –
Ukraine)
Wednesday 24th January: 09:30 – Case T-651/22 Shamalov v Council (Restrictive
measures – Ukraine)
Thursday 25th January: 09:30 – Case T-561/21 HSBC Holdings and Others v Commission
(Competition)
Tuesday 30th January: 09:30 – Case T-362/22 Bazhaev v Council (Restrictive measures –
Ukraine)
Friday 02nd February: 09:30 – Case T-453/22 BASF and Others v Commission
* This is a non-exhaustive list and does not include all the hearings over the next two
weeks.
Trending
- Agenzia nr. 2187 – Insediamento nuovo Procuratore Aggiunto a Brindisi. Caroli: ‘Ampia disponibilità e massima sinergia con la Commissione
- Antisemitismo, Cecchetti (Lega): Piena solidarietà a Meghnagi e Fadlun. Vili minacce che confermano la necessità della legge
- Agenzia nr. 2186 – Vurchio: “Fare impresa nella Bat deve tornare a essere un’opportunità. Serve una strategia per il territorio
- AGENDA CAMERA DI DOMANI, VENERDÌ 20 NOVEMBRE
- Agenzia nr. 2185 – JTF Taranto. Fischetti: “Altri 4 milioni di euro per la formazione e il reinserimento lavorativo
- MANOVRA Nazionale, ANCE Enna: CAMBIARE NORMA SUPERBONUS PER SALVAGUARDARE LE IMPRESE
- MILLEPROROGHE, ZANGRILLO: “AL LAVORO PER STABILIZZARE PERSONALE ASSUNTO COL PATTO PER NAPOLI, IMPORTANTE INVESTIMENTO IN CAPITALE UMANO”
- Antisemitismo, Cecchetti (Lega): Piena solidarietà a Meghnagi e Fadlun. Vili minacce che confermano la necessità della legge
- FSE+, Toscana verso gli obiettivi finanziari 2026: attivate risorse per 850 milioni di euro
- Consiglio della Provincia autonoma di Bolzano – Comunicati del 18/11/2026
