(AGENPARL) - Roma, 18 Gennaio 2024 - (AGENPARL) – gio 18 gennaio 2024 PRESS RELEASE No 12/24
Luxembourg, 18 January 2024
Advocate General’s Opinion in Case C-450/22 | Caixabank e.a. (Judicial review of transparency in a
collective action)
Advocate General Medina: the transparency of ‘floor clauses’ in mortgage
loan contracts can be reviewed in the context of a collective action
That is so even in the case of an action brought against over a hundred Spanish financial institutions
‘Floor clauses’ were standard terms contained in variable rate mortgage loan agreements concluded with
consumers by a significant number of financial institutions in Spain. Those clauses set a threshold (or ‘floor’) below
which the variable interest rate could not fall, even if the reference rate (generally the Euribor) fell below it. When
the reference rates fell significantly below that threshold, the consumers realised they could not benefit from that
decrease and still had to pay the minimum interest rate (usually between two and five percent), despite having a
variable rate mortgage. Individual consumers and consumer associations have filed several thousands of lawsuits in
Spain claiming the illegality of ‘floor clauses’ in the light of the Directive on unfair terms, 1 as well as the restitution of
the overpaid interest. 2
The Spanish Association of Users of Banks, Savings Banks and Insurance (ADICAE) brought a collective action
against 101 financial institutions operating in Spain. ADICAE aims at stopping the use by those institutions of
‘the floor clauses’ (‘action for an injunction’) and at obtaining the reimbursement of the payments made under them
(‘action for recovery’). Following calls in the national media, 820 consumers supported the collective action.
Having lost the case twice, the banks appealed to the Spanish Supreme Court. That court has doubts about the
suitability of the collective proceedings to carry out a review of the transparency of the ‘floor clauses’ in order to
ascertain whether they are unfair, especially given the numerous consumers and financial institutions involved.
Advocate General Laila Medina points out that nothing in the directive suggests that the review of transparency is
precluded in the context of a collective action. Moreover, the judicial review of transparency in collective
proceedings is appropriate and possible. It just has to be adapted to the specificities of collective actions, such as
their level of abstraction, and focus on the standard contractual and pre-contractual practice of the professional
towards the average consumer. Excluding the examination of the transparency of contractual terms in the context
of collective proceedings would defeat the purpose of collective actions and be incompatible and inconsistent with
EU legislation aimed at strengthening the judicial protection of the collective interests of consumers.
That judicial review is also possible when the proceedings are brought against a significant number of
financial institutions and involve a large number of contracts, as long as the professionals belong to the same
economic sector, the contractual terms are similar and the right of each financial institution to effective judicial
protection is guaranteed. Advocate General Medina underlines that the Spanish Supreme Court has to determine
whether there is a sufficient degree of similarity to allow the collective action to proceed. In order to do so, it can
take into account that the professionals are all banking institutions and that all the clauses challenged are standard
‘floor clauses’ included in mortgage contracts and whose effect is to exclude the variation of the interest rate below
a certain level. According to the Advocate General, all those elements could be a strong indication of sufficient
Communications Directorate
Press and Information Unit
curia.europa.eu
similarity.
The Advocate General considers that it is possible to use the average consumer standard to carry out the
transparency review in the case pending before the Spanish Supreme Court, as this objective standard of
assessment is irrespective of the characteristics or the number of consumers involved.
NOTE: The Advocate General’s Opinion is not binding on the Court of Justice. It is the role of the Advocates General
to propose to the Court, in complete independence, a legal solution to the cases for which they are responsible. The
Judges of the Court are now beginning their deliberations in this case. Judgment will be given at a later date.
NOTE: A reference for a preliminary ruling allows the courts and tribunals of the Member States, in disputes which
have been brought before them, to refer questions to the Court of Justice about the interpretation of European
Union law or the validity of a European Union act. The Court of Justice does not decide the dispute itself. It is for the
national court or tribunal to dispose of the case in accordance with the Court’s decision, which is similarly binding on
other national courts or tribunals before which a similar issue is raised.
Unofficial document for media use, not binding on the Court of Justice.
The full text of the Opinion is published on the CURIA website on the day of delivery.
Stay Connected!
Council Directive 93/13/EEC of 5 April 1993 on unfair terms in consumer contracts.
In a judgment of 9 May 2013, the Spanish Supreme Court held, in the context of a collective action brought by a consumer association against
several banking institutions, that the ‘floor clauses’ examined were not transparent, because the consumers had not been informed properly about
the economic and legal burden placed upon them. The clauses were declared void. However, in view of the serious economic repercussions that the
retroactive restitution of overpayments would have on the banking sector, the Supreme Court decided to limit the temporal effects of the declaration
of invalidity to overpayments made after the delivery of its judgment. However, the Court of Justice ruled that limitation incompatible with the
Directive (see Judgment of the Court of 21 December 2016, Gutiérrez Naranjo and Others, joined cases C-154/15, C-307/15 and C-308/15; see also Press
Release No 144/16).
Communications Directorate
Trending
- Agenzia nr. 2187 – Insediamento nuovo Procuratore Aggiunto a Brindisi. Caroli: ‘Ampia disponibilità e massima sinergia con la Commissione
- Antisemitismo, Cecchetti (Lega): Piena solidarietà a Meghnagi e Fadlun. Vili minacce che confermano la necessità della legge
- Agenzia nr. 2186 – Vurchio: “Fare impresa nella Bat deve tornare a essere un’opportunità. Serve una strategia per il territorio
- AGENDA CAMERA DI DOMANI, VENERDÌ 20 NOVEMBRE
- Agenzia nr. 2185 – JTF Taranto. Fischetti: “Altri 4 milioni di euro per la formazione e il reinserimento lavorativo
- MANOVRA Nazionale, ANCE Enna: CAMBIARE NORMA SUPERBONUS PER SALVAGUARDARE LE IMPRESE
- MILLEPROROGHE, ZANGRILLO: “AL LAVORO PER STABILIZZARE PERSONALE ASSUNTO COL PATTO PER NAPOLI, IMPORTANTE INVESTIMENTO IN CAPITALE UMANO”
- Antisemitismo, Cecchetti (Lega): Piena solidarietà a Meghnagi e Fadlun. Vili minacce che confermano la necessità della legge
- FSE+, Toscana verso gli obiettivi finanziari 2026: attivate risorse per 850 milioni di euro
- Consiglio della Provincia autonoma di Bolzano – Comunicati del 18/11/2026
