(AGENPARL) - Roma, 26 Ottobre 2023 - (AGENPARL) – gio 26 ottobre 2023 Newsletter
Weeks XLIV – XLV: 30th October to 10th November 2023
Contact us
@ENDesk
Jacques René
Zammit
Week XLIV – 30th October to 3rd November
The Court is in All Saints recess from Monday 30th October to Sunday 5th
November.
Press Officer
Monica Pizzo
Assistant
Week XLV – 6th to 10th November
Wednesday 8th November
EN Desk Email
General Court
Judgment in Case T-282/22 Mazepin v Council
Sorchadh
Higgins & Olivia
Moore assisted
in the
preparation of
this Newsletter.
(Restrictive measures)
Mr Mazepin is a Russian businessman. He is the owner and CEO of Uralchem, a
Russian manufacturer of a wide range of chemical products. The company claims to
be the largest producer of ammonium nitrate and the second largest producer of
ammonia and nitrogen fertilisers in Russia.
Follow
In February 2022, following the initial stages of Russia’s aggression against Ukraine,
@EUCourtPress
Mazepin and 36 other businessmen attended a meeting with President Putin and
on X (formerly
other members of the Russian government. They discussed the choices to be made
Twitter)
Download our
following the Western sanctions against Russia.
For the European Union, Mr Mazepin’s invitation to this meeting shows that he
belongs to President Putin’s closest circle. The Council of the European Union deduced
that Mr Mazepin was supporting or implementing policies that threatened Ukraine
and decided to impose sanctions on him: all his funds and economic resources within
the European Union were frozen and he was prohibited from entering or passing
through the territory of the Member States of the European Union.
Mr Mazepin challenged the Council’s decision before the General Court.
Background Documents T-282/22
Communications Directorate
Press and Information unit
curia.europa.eu
Newsletter
Weeks XLIV – XLV: 30th October to 10th November 2023
All times are 9:30
unless otherwise
stated.
Don’t forget to
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 9th November
Judgment in Case C-376/22 Google Ireland and others
check the diary
on our website
(Freedom of establishment)
for details of
other cases.
In 2021, Austria introduced a law requiring domestic and foreign providers of
communications platforms to set up mechanisms for reporting and verifying
potentially illegal content. The law also provided for regular and transparent
publication of reports of illegal content. An administrative authority is meant to ensure
compliance with the law and can impose fines of up to ten million euro.
Google Ireland, Meta Platforms Ireland, and Tiktok, three platforms established in
Ireland, argue that the Austrian law is contrary to EU law, namely the Directive on
Information Society Services. An Austrian Court has referred the question to the
Court.
Background Documents C-376/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 9th November
Judgment in Case C-319/22 Gesamtverband Autoteile-Handel (Access to
information on vehicles)
(Approximation of Laws)
EU law obliges car manufacturers to make available to independent operators,
including repairers, parts distributors and publishers of technical information, the
information necessary for the repair and maintenance of the vehicles they
manufacture.
A German trade association for the independent parts trade considers that neither the
form nor the content of the information provided by the HGV manufacturer Scania to
its members meet this obligation. In order to remedy this situation, the association
brought the matter before a German court. Uncertain as to the scope of Scania’s
obligations, this court in turn referred the matter to the Court of Justice. It wishes to
know, among other things, whether the vehicle identification number should be
considered as personal data that manufacturers are obliged to communicate.
Background Documents C-319/22
Newsletter
Weeks XLIV – XLV: 30th October to 10th November 2023
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 9th November
Judgment in Case C-598/21 Všeobecná úverová banka
(Consumer protection)
In Slovakia, Všeobecná úverová banka granted two customers consumer credit
repayable over 20 years. The customers pledged their family home as collateral. Due
to a three-month delay in payment of approximately €1,000, which occurred during
the first year of the contract, the bank invoked an acceleration clause. This clause
enables the bank to demand early repayment of the entire outstanding balance and to
initiate an out-of-court auction of the family home. The customers have asked a
Slovakian court to suspend the auction, which they claim violates their rights as
consumers.
Under Slovakian law, such a clause can be enforced if the borrower is three months in
arrears with payments and the lender has given a further 15 days’ notice. The courts
are unable to review the proportionality of this clause in terms of the seriousness of
the breach of the consumer’s obligations in relation to the amount and duration of the
credit. The Slovak court asks the Court of Justice whether such a limitation on judicial
review is compatible with EU law.
Background Documents C-598/21
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 9th November
Judgment in Case C-353/22 Commission v Sweden (Control of the acquisition and
possession of weapons)
(Approximation of Laws)
On 26 July 2019, the Commission called on Sweden to comply with the amended Arms
Directive by 26 September 2019. The deadline for transposing these amendments into
Swedish law expired on 14 September 2018. In May 2022, the Commission asked the
Court of Justice to declare that Sweden had failed to transpose these amendments
into national law. It also asked the Court to order Sweden to pay financial penalties.
On 17 July 2023, the Commission informed the Court that Sweden had transposed the
amendments in question into its national law by 1 July 2023.
Background Documents C-353/22
Newsletter
Weeks XLIV – XLV: 30th October to 10th November 2023
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 9th November
Opinion in Case C-465/20 P Commission v Ireland and others
(Tax Rulings – Apple – State Aid)
In 2016, the Commission adopted a decision concerning two tax rulings issued by the
Irish tax authorities (Irish Revenue) on 29 January 1991 and 23 May 2007 in favour of
Apple Sales International (ASI) and Apple Operations Europe (AOE), which were
companies incorporated in Ireland but not tax resident in Ireland.
The contested tax rulings endorsed the methods used by ASI and AOE to determine
their chargeable profits in Ireland, relating to the trading activity of their respective
Irish branches. The 1991 tax ruling remained in force until 2007, when it was replaced
by the 2007 tax ruling. The 2007 tax ruling then remained in force until Apple’s new
business structure was implemented in Ireland in 2014.
By its decision, the Commission considered that the tax rulings in question constituted
State aid unlawfully put into effect by Ireland. The aid was declared incompatible with
the internal market. The Commission demanded the recovery of the aid in question.
According to the Commission’s calculations, Ireland had granted Apple 13 billion euro
in unlawful tax advantages. Ireland (Case T-778/16) and ASI and AOE (Case T-892/16)
claimed that the General Court should annul the Commission’s decision.
In its judgment of the 15th July 2020, the General Court annulled the contested
decision because the Commission had not succeeded in showing to the requisite legal
standard that there was an advantage for the purposes of Article 107(1) TFEU.
This case concerns the Commission’s appeal from that judgment.
Background Documents C-465/20 P
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 9th November
Opinion in Joined Cases C-608/22 Bundesamt für Fremdenwesen und Asyl and
others (Afghan Women) and Case C-609/22 Bundesamt für Fremdenwesen und
Asyl and others (Afghan Women)
(Asylum policy)
Newsletter
Weeks XLIV – XLV: 30th October to 10th November 2023
Since the return of the Taliban regime to Afghanistan, the situation of women has
deteriorated rapidly. This regime restricts or even prohibits their access to healthcare
and education, their exercise of a professional activity, their participation in public and
political life as well as their freedom of movement and sporting activities. They must
cover their bodies and faces, and are deprived of protection against gender-based
violence and domestic violence.
Two Afghan women applied for asylum in Austria, but the Austrian authorities rejected
their applications. The authorities considered that the first woman’s reason for fleeing
was not credible and that the second woman did not face a real risk of persecution in
Afghanistan.
An Austrian court asked the Court of Justice whether the treatment of women by the
Taliban constituted persecution justifying the granting of refugee status. If so, it also
asked whether the real danger of this persecution could be established for all Afghan
women regardless of their personal situation.
Background Documents C-608/22
Background Documents C-609/22
There will be a press release for this case.
Thursday 9th November
Opinion in Case C-516/22 Commission v UK (Supreme Court Judgment)
(Law of Institutions – Brexit)
The case concerns an application for judgment by default against the UK for alleged
breaches of their obligations. The act resulting in the breach of obligations is a UK
Supreme Court ruling in Micula v Romania on the 19 February 2020.
The Commission alleges that the Supreme Court judgment, delivered during the
transition period, violated EU law. The Commission argues that the question of
enforcement of the arbitral award, decided by the Supreme Court was covered by
Commission decisions and that by not staying its proceedings; the Supreme Court had
breached the UK’s Treaty obligations.
Background Documents C-516/22
There will be an Info Rapide for the case (available on request).
Newsletter
Weeks XLIV – XLV: 30th October to 10th November 2023
HEARINGS OF NOTE*
Court of Justice
Tuesday 7th November: 09.30 – C-626/22 Ilva and Others (Environment – Grand
Chamber)
Wednesday 8th November: 09.30 – C-727/22 Friends of the Irish Environment (Projet
Ireland 2040) (Environment)
Thursday 9th November: 09.30 – C-613/22 Dublin 8 Residents Association
(Environment)
General Court
Tuesday 7th November: 09.30 – T-302/22 Vinkurov v Council (Restrictive Measures)
Thursday 9th November: 09.30 – T-785/21 SC Ha Ha Ha Production v EUIPO – The
Smiley Company (SMILEY) (Intellectual property)
* This is a non-exhaustive list and does not include all the hearings over the next two
weeks.
Trending
- [Comune Palermo] Kick Light e Light Boxe, sei giovani atleti del Villaggio Santa Rosalia campioni del mondo – Dichiarazione consigliere Davì (IV Circoscrizione)
- [Comune Palermo] Linee AMAT 731 e 603 – Puma: “Corse saltate e orari ignorati. Così si abbandonano i cittadini
- Resistenza antimicrobica, allarme OMS: solo 42 Paesi su 183 dichiarano di aver finanziato e attuato i piani nazionali
- Dieta Mediterranea, Lollobrigida: patrimonio da tutelare e trasmettere alle nuove generazioni
- La condizione di insularità: dal riconoscimento costituzionale alle misure di contrasto – Martedì alle 15 diretta webtv
- Giornata Mondiale contro tumore cervice uterina – Martedì Montecitorio si illumina di verde “teal”
- Diritti umani, audizione Nunez, deputata Ecuador – Martedì alle 13 diretta webtv
- Il Natale di Verona in tavola – I sapori, la storia, le tradizioni della città di Romeo e Giulietta – Martedì alle 15.30 diretta webtv – Videomessaggio di Fontana
- Premio letterario nazionale Alsium Città di Ladispoli – Martedì alle 12 diretta webtv
- Misure di contrasto all’evasione fiscale, sicurezza delle banche dati dell’anagrafe tributaria e tutela della riservatezza dei dati dei contribuenti – Martedì alle 10 diretta webtv – Messaggio di Fontana
